2 ms·
> If something is in the public domain in the U.S. then anyone can use it for any purpose, including releasing it under whatever license they want In the US. P
by masklinn 8y ago
> If something is in the public domain in the U.S. then anyone can use it for any purpose, including releasing it under whatever license they want
In the US. Public domain dedications have no legal standing in most of mainland Europe's IP regimes. A public domain dedication is the equivalent of no license at all.
And because a public domain dedication has no legal standing, a third-party slapping a license on the code does not make it legally licensed as far as european IP courts are concerned, they don't have that right, their "license" is worth as much as you deciding to license Windows under GPLv3.
> But if you think you need it licensed, you can have it licensed.
Unless djb offers to provide a fallback license (which incidentally is exactly what CC0 does and why it's legally sensible and valid[0]), then no, you can't "have it licensed".
[0] https://rd-alliance.org/sites/default/files/cc0-analysis-kreuzer.pdf https://rd-alliance.org/sites/default/files/cc0-analysis-kre...
- voidmain 8y agoI am no expert in German copyright law! But your own source says: "It is worth noting that the result would stay the same if CC0 would not even contain such an explicit fallback rule. According to the prevailing opinion of the legal scholars, public domain licenses (which cannot be interpreted as a waiver of rights under the German copyright, see above) are reinterpreted as unconditional, unlimited, non-exclusive (i.e. public) licenses." which appears to contradict your statement that public domain dedications are treated as no license at all.