4 ms·
Buybacks are almost solely to artificially trigger stock option targets for CEOs, right? Otherwise that is money that should be paid out as a dividend or reinve
by AtlasBarfed 8y ago
Buybacks are almost solely to artificially trigger stock option targets for CEOs, right? Otherwise that is money that should be paid out as a dividend or reinvested into operations and research.
- koolba 8y ago> Buybacks are almost solely to artificially trigger stock option targets for CEOs, right? Otherwise that is money that should be paid out as a dividend or reinvested into operations and research. No buybacks provide a potential tax advantage for investors. Dividends have tax consequences in the year that they're received. Buybacks lift the price of the stock by an equivalent amount but do not force the investor to realize the gains so they can defer the taxes to a later date.
- kaycebasques 8y ago> so they can defer the taxes to a later date. This assumes that the share price has maintained that elevated level at a later date. Ideally, you want to cash out on some long-term positions right around the time of the buybacks. The buybacks have raised the share price, but you’re only paying long-term capital gains taxes, which used to be capped at (I think) 15% for all investors, regardless of income bracket.
- simonsarris 8y agoNo, its the diffence between a bonus and a salary. A stock buyback is like giving employees [shareholders] a bonus. Some employees get bonuses every year based on how the company is doing. Employees are OK with getting a lower bonus next year. Employees get very, very unhappy when their salary gets decreased in a bad year. Investors are the same way. They punish a stock when a company decreases its dividend. If you aren't sure you can make a promise in perpetuity, don't increase your dividend, instead give shareholders a bonus, aka stock buyback. Then, if next year you need the cash to invest in the company, instead of another buyback, you do that. Investors stay happy because you didn't decrease your dividend. Some companies, like Target (which has never decreased its dividend ever) might have a hard time competing with Amazon because Amazon can make almost no profits on paper (until recent years) while funneling all their revenue back into the company. Target does not have this luxury. They DEFINITELY cannot say to investors "okay we're cutting our dividend for 2 years to compete with amazon by funneling it into growth." They'd get crushed. tl;dr, buybacks are wiser than dividends for any company that might want to spend the money on growth in following years, instead of doling it out to shareholders, as is done with dividends. Another reply already explained the tax implication reason.