8 ms·
In the United States private debt collectors will attempt to get bereaved family members of a recently dead person to begin payment on the deceased person's deb
by walrus01 8y ago
In the United States private debt collectors will attempt to get bereaved family members of a recently dead person to begin payment on the deceased person's debt, with social engineering tactics.
When the appropriate legal response is: "NAME is deceased, here is the contact info the for executor of the estate".
- SamuelAdams 8y agoI've never understood this behavior. How is this not considered harassment?
- cremp 8y agoBecause debt collectors have literal exceptions to harassment laws.
- djsumdog 8y agoI hate debt collectors as much as anyone, but they do have quite a few rules. Most jurisdictions have times during which you can call someone (collects need to be sure to adjust for the destination timezone; since they might not realize they're called at 6am if they're on a different coast). In Australia (if they show Tricky Business is at all realistic), Mercantile agents can't present you with a notice in front of other people and must serve you in person (similar to a legal summons in the US). So there are _some_ regulations in place.
- amyjess 8y agoIn the US at least, you can serve debt collectors notice that they must cease all future communications with you, and if they disregard that, the FTC can and will go after them. I'd recommend reading the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/rules/rulemaking-regulatory-reform-proceedings/fair-debt-collection-practices-act-text https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/rules/rulemaking-regulatory-...
- yebyen 8y agoIt's not outlandish to think that if, say, your parent bought a vehicle for you to use, and they held the <strike>title</strike> title documentation and lien note... while they were making payments on it on your behalf, and you were driving or in possession of the car when they died, that it follows logically that you should simply assume that debt and maintain an uninterrupted record of payments in order to be able to continue uninterrupted use of the car. Stretch that example to "a car that was bought with a credit card" and you can see how this could be a legitimate effort. I don't know how that plays out legally, but I assume there's not any legal option where the debt simply goes unpaid by the estate and by you, and the car is not legally meant to be repossessed. You may not have known that the car you are driving is not paid in full. Large assets can be repo'ed if the account that paid for them is in arrears. This is not necessarily going to happen right away, the estate may have accounted for this already, there are plenty of reasons why this contact is bogus, but it could also be possibly in your interest to follow up with payments in certain cases. (Fight me?) You could give the car back to the estate (probably the right answer?), or argue that it was a gift, and the estate should pay for it, but I don't know if either of those arguments will actually get you anywhere / prevent the car from being repossessed. You might have documentation that it was a gift, but there's also a lien on the title. Your gift might have been smaller than a car, there's no title, and you might not have any documentation of the gift. (I'm not sure if it matters that you can prove it was meant to be a gift.) It's probably not considered harassment or illegitimate on about the same basis that you can be newly considered responsible for your own debts that are "past the statute of limitations" that you have started payments on again, even if your last contact was some time after the statute of limitations had already expired. At that point the debt collectors can continue contacting you, but the collection efforts must include language that explains the fact that you can't be sued for these debts. Well, what they don't explain is that by making a payment, you could be resetting the statute of limitations and newly assuming responsibility for the whole debt, with a brand new expiry date. (I am not a lawyer and this is not legal advice, but this is my understanding of why you "just don't answer those letters.") You wouldn't have started making payments if you didn't feel that you ought to be responsible for the debt, "QED." Not saying it's fair or right, but there are cases where that's what the law assumes and approximately why it is so. There are also a lot of things that collectors can do, that would easily be considered harassment if you simply asked them to stop (and then they persisted anyway). People don't always ask, or know that they should ask. Especially if they don't want to pay! (Whether or not responsible, it rightfully makes people go on the defensive to receive a contact from a bill collector.) I'm getting downvoted but nobody is telling me if I've said something incorrect. That "disagree" button...
- chrisseaton 8y agoIf you're opening the letter of the deceased person, aren't you likely the the executor of the estate anyway? So you're just asking them to send the same letter again to yourself? I would have though if you aren't the executor then you shouldn't be opening their mail?
- walrus01 8y agoThey very frequently do this on the phone, to whatever numbers they have available for the debtor.
- chrisseaton 8y agoBut again, if you live in the same house as the deceased person, or have possession of their mobile phone, aren't you likely to also be the executor of the estate? Most people will have their spouse as the executor, so they are the right people to speak to.
- walrus01 8y agoThe tactics specifically attempt to get a person to begin payments on a debt, rather than the executor, so that the new third party person assumes the debt. In an estate payments for certain categories of debt may be lower priority in settlement. It's done in a very unethical way with specific verbiage and social engineering tactics. This is also done in cases where the collection agency may be aware that there is a "no getting blood from a stone" scenario of an estate that will have zero value when it is wrapped up, so guilt trip techniques are employed against any reachable family members to attempt to get them to assume payments.
- scarface74 8y agoExactly. I can’t think of any of my assets that will go through the estate. Our house, cars, life insurance [1], retirement [2] etc. are all either jointly owned or my wife is the beneficiary Debtors won’t be able to collect anything from “our estate”. Until we both pass. [1] https://finance.zacks.com/can-life-insurance-proceeds-paid-beneficiary-forced-pay-deceaseds-debts-6368.html https://finance.zacks.com/can-life-insurance-proceeds-paid-b... [2] https://www.thebalance.com/does-an-ira-or-401-k-be-used-to-pay-a-decedent-s-bills-3505413 https://www.thebalance.com/does-an-ira-or-401-k-be-used-to-p...
- astura 8y ago1) PayPal is not a (rogue) private debt collector; they are a financial institution. 2) This took place in the UK. (She owed £3,200). 3) The notice was sent to her, not her family. 4) It seems like she had a credit card with PayPal that had a balance on it (reference to "PayPal Credit"). Doesn't payment to creditors come out of the estate? So it seems PayPal might be legitimately owed if the estate has money. Thus there were no social engineering tactics
- pliftkl 8y agoPayPal _was_ legitimately owed money. I don't think that's at question - when you die with a debt, that doesn't "erase" the debt. The issue here isn't "dying with debt", it's PayPal's phrasing of this - "Hey, being dead is a violation of your agreement". A less insensitive letter that indicated that there was a $3200 balance against the estate wouldn't have raised any eyebrows (unless UK credit laws are very unusual).
- jacquesm 8y agoWhen you die with a debt and the heirs wave their rights to the estate the debt dies with you.
- cperciva 8y ago(rouge) They're not that either, but I think you meant rogue.
- astura 8y agoHaha, Yes, I certainly did. Fixed.
- djsumdog 8y agoAll creators do have a right to attempt to regain their losses before assets are distributed to people on the deceased person's will or next-of-kin. If the executor of the estate runs out of funds from that estate, the company will usually just write off the debt or they might go to court to make sure, but then write off the debt. The inheritor never pays the debt of the deceased.
- mindslight 8y agoA formal appointment of executor, or even just understanding the role of de facto executor, takes a bit of time. Meanwhile, there is a strong feeling of wanting to "make things right" with the ongoing accounts - eg just paying off a credit card bill out of one's own account and moving on to the next envelope in the pile. If the estate has debt but no assets (which is quite common given probate-avoiding estate planning tools like joint accounts and contract beneficiaries), then such payments are a straight up waste. Unnecessarily paying off a decedent's debts may still be in line with the decedent's life philosophy and wishes, but one certainly shouldn't be goaded into doing so due to harassment from creditors at an already emotional and stressful time.