7 ms·
> The difference is between a specific invention vs. a law of mathematics or nature. The latter absolutely should not be patentable. I do not understand the di
by enriquto 8y ago
> The difference is between a specific invention vs. a law of mathematics or nature. The latter absolutely should not be patentable.
I do not understand the difference between the two. As a mathematician with an interest in philosophy, I would say that about 50% of mathematicians would agree that algorithms and theorems are discovered, not invented.
Thus, your example of RSA as a "good" patent sounds preposterous to me. The RSA algorithm was discovered, and it is a law of nature as much as the Euclidean algorithm to find the gcd. I find it honestly absurd that it can be patented (not angry, merely surprised).
- rayiner 8y agoThat's a bit of reductio ad absurdum. The RSA algorithm is a "law of [mathematical] nature" as much as a log cabin is natural. The composition of natural building blocks into something that performs a function is a work of human ingenuity. That said, RSA itself probably would not be patentable today. The Supreme Court's decision in Alice probably precludes pure algorithm patents. You need an algorithm in the context of a specific use case. For example, a cell phone that uses RSA to encrypt keys to protect data in flash memory.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoA modern RSA patent application would get past Alice. It is a protocol that could be described/claimed in the context of communication between computers. Where the protocol improves the performance of a computers or communications because X,Y, or Z and improves the security of the session.