7 ms·
As mentioned (and slightly buried) by the article, the really fascinating part is that we already have consumer bicycle gears that deliver 97% efficiency: a Dur
by woodruffw 8y ago
As mentioned (and slightly buried) by the article, the really fascinating part is that we already have consumer bicycle gears that deliver 97% efficiency: a Dura Ace groupset is expensive compared to the stuff you'll get at Wall-Mart, but they're sold at pretty much every cycling store. I wouldn't be surprised if the Ultegra and 105 (Shimano's next two groupsets by price) were nearly as efficient as well.
2% is nothing to sniff at in cycling (people pay thousands of dollars for that kind of advantage), but there are other factors as well: resistance to stress (sprints), ease of maintenance and service, and weight all factor into the utter dominance of the current groupset design. It'll be interesting to see if CeramicSpeed can advance their design on those fronts.
- hinkley 8y agoCan you run torque through two 90° angle changes for less than 3% losses?
- jacquesm 8y agoDepending on how you do it: yes. Look closely, the gear teeth on the driving wheel are miniature roller bearings.
- hinkley 8y agoAre you sure those aren’t bushings? The round bits in a bike chain are bushings, which is part of the efficiency of the existing drivetrain. These folks have essentially turned the chain inside out and attached it to the ends of a shaft.
- jacquesm 8y agohttps://hips.hearstapps.com/hmg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/images/ceramic-speed-driven00009-1531153680.jpg?resize=768:* https://hips.hearstapps.com/hmg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/images... Look closely in that picture you can clearly see the inside of the small bearings.
- hinkley 8y agoWell I'll be damned. Them's bearings alright.
- jacquesm 8y agoThat's also a weak point: those tiny bearings are going to take all the load from the cyclist one or two at the time, I predict they won't last long if it works at all under substantial load. And to reduce friction they're open cage which will not play well with sand and other grime.
- usrusr 8y agoPossibly. They must be getting their idea out 99% from somewhere, and existing transmissions in other application domains are a likely candidate. But I really don't believe that it could work at bike-friendly torque/weight ratios, in a system open to the gritty environment, in a multi-gear setup where angles are not aligned (the inner part of the teeth moves slower than the outer part, permanent slippage, yay). As far as I understand it this is a mockup celebrating the intention of getting to 99, not a prototype that has achieved it. More artist's impression than product. What's still impressive though is that the concept does away with pretty much the only actual product the company has, the pulley wheel. That is bold in a strictly economic way.
- davidgould 8y ago> we already have consumer bicycle gears that deliver 97% efficiency: a Dura Ace groupset is expensive compared to the stuff you'll get at Wall-Mart, but they're sold at pretty much every cycling store. I wouldn't be surprised if the Ultegra and 105 (Shimano's next two groupsets by price) were nearly as efficient as well. There isn't really much difference in efficiency with price in group sets until you get into the really bad cheap stuff. Most of the differences are cosmetic or ergonomic and status related. Chains and bearing and cogs are the only items that affect efficiency and they are all pretty good. Good chain line and proper maintenance and lubrication make more of a difference. Internal hubs are slightly less efficient overall and this depends a lot on the internal design and which gears are in use. But even these are something like 94% - 97% efficient. Shaft drives have been the "next thing" since the end of the 19th century but have never managed to combine reliability and efficiency well. I doubt an exposed mesh 90 degree gear set with what look like teeny tiny exposed ball bearings are going to be as efficient after a good splash of water laden with brake dust and road grit. It might work if they enclose the whole system.
- rienbdj 8y agoweight is a big factor between cheap and expensive groupsets
- magicalhippo 8y agoOverheard at a popular stop for bikers near me: "Yeah, I could have gotten the model above it which is 500g lighter, but it would have cost me another $3500." It should be noted that the guy who said it could have easily lost 500g by a minuscule adjustment to his daily snack intake...
- whafro 8y agoNo, it should not have been noted.
- magicalhippo 8y ago
- flr03 8y agoWealthy middle-age people and pro now spend fortune to save half a watt so that 2% gain is indeed not marginal at all. Although I tend to be very cautious with manufacturers claims, for some reason especially CeramicSpeed. That being said, I wish them to succeed, as it will bring some fresh air to cycling.
- mrob 8y ago>2% is nothing to sniff at in cycling (people pay thousands of dollars for that kind of advantage) 2% is nothing to sniff at only if you're hampered by the arbitrary UCI rules. By far the biggest factor in cycling performance is air resistance, and the obvious solution (fairings) is banned. The UCI has been disastrous for bicycle technology. Most high-end buyers like to pretend they could compete professionally one day, so they abide by the same rules, which means there's no incentive to develop truly fast bikes. The UCI rules should allow any safe design, and avoid giving an advantage to richer teams by setting a price limit (bicycles are already required to be commercially available).
- woodruffw 8y agoI agree that the UCI has been bad for progress. That being said, I raced in college (at the collegiate level, not professionally) and saw plenty of people using UCI-noncompliant bikes. Historically, the UCI did use "safe design" as the metric -- they used it to exclude Graeme Obree, whose bicycle-cum-dishwashing-machine was probably safe enough for him to be riding on a closed track. That's not to say that the UCI should block innovative designs, just to note that they'll use any regulation supplied to restrict cyclists/companies/countries that end up on their naughty list.
- nerdponx 8y agoDo you think there's a market for super-efficient commuter bikes? Or is air resistance no longer the limiting factor at commuter-bike speeds and weights?
- mrob 8y agoI think there's a limited market for them, because the value of aerodynamics depends heavily on how you ride. Wind resistance increases with the square of the speed. Pros can ride at 30mph average on fast stages, where managing wind resistance is huge. A typical road bike commuter might average 15mph. All else being equal that's 1/4th the wind resistance (1/8th the power needed to overcome it), which is still big, but not the overwhelmingly important concern it is for the pros. A commuter on a utility bike who doesn't want to sweat might average only 10mph, so 1/9th the wind resistance (1/27th the power needed to overcome it). At that speed it doesn't feel so important. For the pro, speed is the top priority, but the commuter also has to consider comfort, reliability, and visibility of other traffic (recumbents put your head lower down so it's harder for you to see over cars, and it's harder for them to see you). On heavily congested roads, e.g. central London, traffic might prevent you from going fast enough for wind resistance to be a major concern. If you commute over steep hills then reduced weight might benefit you more. But if you have a long and flat commute with light traffic, I think a super-efficient commuter bike would be valuable, and it's a pity that UCI rules discourage development of super-efficient bike technology. EDIT: added power values as per HankB99's comment.
- tjoff 8y ago... ease of maintenance and service ... Exactly, and gears and chain are horrible in this regard. The absolut vast majority barely maintains their chain which leads to a much lower efficiency and really poor longevity (no it is not hard, but apparently too hard/boring to get done). Unless the owner is a bike enthusiast you can almost guarantee that the maintenance is abysmal. I realized this for myself and bought a belt-driven bicycle so I wouldn't feel bad abusing my current bike. For your day-to-day bike I'm very happy with it and the maintenance benefits alone make it so worth it.