4 ms·
> That really depends on where you put 'beginning'. It does not. In 1995 the Internet was useful for 30m people. In 1985 it was useful for 30,000. Email was be
by wpietri 8y ago
> That really depends on where you put 'beginning'.
It does not. In 1995 the Internet was useful for 30m people. In 1985 it was useful for 30,000. Email was better than paper mail from the get-go. Networked file transfer was way better than mailing magtapes or CDs. Remote terminal connections were way better than driving or doing long-distance dialup. The Internet was not the wonder it is today, but from very early on it had clear practical use.
> But more to the point, blockchains are useful now, just like the internet was.
Not really. I ask regularly here, and so far there's approximately no commercial use case where blockchains are better than some other technology. The main exceptions being hype, fraud, speculation, and some light financial crime like money laundering and capital control evasion. If you have some examples, I'll of course read them with interest.
My personal bet is that blockchains will be like XML: a technology that was going to be The FUTURE for a while, got put into a bunch of things (often generating large consulting revenues), and then quietly dropped later as people discovered that there were better alternatives for almost every practical use case.
- jacobush 8y agoXML quietly dropped? If blockchains are dropped in the same manner, it will be around forever and ever. It will outlive Cobol.
- wpietri 8y agoFair point. I haven't seen any new use it in years, and it's down to 12% of its peak interest: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=xml https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=x... (Or less, perhaps, in that I suspect the peak was earlier.) But yes, I'm sure it's in plenty of Y2K-ish enterprise systems, spreading like kudzu.
- Animats 8y agoThere are many widely used data formats, such as OpenDocument files, that are XML underneath, often packaged up as .zip files. Much engineering data, such as KiCAD printed circuit board layout info, is in XML. COLLADA, for 3D animation and robotics, is XML. Open Street Map is XML. If you need to represent a large, complex tree-structured data object portably, XML is still usually the way to go.
- wpietri 8y agoI agree that it's a decent approach for that extremely narrow use case. My point is the extent to which that is different from the peak of XML's hype cycle, which was circa 2000. Then, XML was everywhere. E.g., eBay circa 2004 would render data internally as XML, which would get passed off to multiple Rube Goldbergian XSLT transformation layers on its way to becoming HTML. Or I did some work at a bank around then, and their internal architecture was very XML-heavy. There was no good reason for this, and from what I see JSON now dominates. I note though that your examples were all created when XML's hype cycle was in full swing, and many have enterprise roots. I'll be interested to see if projects created today end up using XML even for the document-creation cases for which it was intended. JSON is also a way to represent large tree-structured data, and I wouldn't be shocked to see it take over most of the data sharing just because that's what everybody knows.
- Animats 8y agoJSON tools tend not to scale. See [1] A 1MB JSON file will blow up some tools. Engineering models of real-world objects are much larger than that. There's sort of an assumption with JSON that you'll read it into a JSON tree and work on that, not process it sequentially. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12063626 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12063626
- wpietri 8y agoI'm willing to believe that's currently true, but that doesn't strike me as much of a moat for XML.
- pessimizer 8y agoXML is useful, if cumbersome. Blockchains have not shown themselves to be useful for anything at scale.
- darawk 8y ago> It does not. In 1995 the Internet was useful for 30m people. In 1985 it was useful for 30,000. Email was better than paper mail from the get-go. You see that now. But in 1985 most people thought email was silly, if they knew about it at all. Why replace the mail? The mail is fine. It's only when you look back on it, with modern eyes, that you see how great it was. > Not really. I ask regularly here, and so far there's approximately no commercial use case where blockchains are better than some other technology. The main exceptions being hype, fraud, speculation, and some light financial crime like money laundering and capital control evasion. If you have some examples, I'll of course read them with interest. I stated some above. But i'll copy/paste: - Value transfer - Prediction markets - Asset trading/custody (not just cryptoassets, I mean, potentially real estate, equities, etc. can be tokenized) - Venture capital that is more transparent and open (the ICO space is obviously not there yet, but I think it can move in that direction) Now, you may counter that existing institutions do these things just fine. But blockchains do them in a different way, with different properties. Just like email did the same thing as mail, in a different way, with different properties. For instance, decentralized exchanges exist - exchanges that don't require you to provide custody of your assets to the exchange. That is a true revolution, and it doesn't just have to be for crypto tokens. Those tokens can represent real life goods, property, etc. You can tokenize anything, in principle.
- ckastner 8y ago> You see that now. But in 1985 most people thought email was silly, if they knew about it at all. > Why replace the mail? The mail is fine. It's only when you look back on it, with modern eyes, that you see how great it was. These statements may support your argument, but they have no basis in reality.
- wpietri 8y agoHaving lived through 1985, most people did not think email was silly. Even we primitives of that dark age could tell that instant delivery was generally better than waiting a few days. Moreover, the "most people" standard does not apply. I'm not asking what "most people" think about Bitcoin. I'm asking for evidence of delivered value to early-adopter audiences. In 1985 any crowd of tech people could tell you why email was better. It would have been easy to find non-technical academic staff who were excited about email, as many of them had been using (mostly non-Internet) email for years at that point. Neutral observers could easily be shown that it was valuable. > I stated some above. But i'll copy/paste: No, what you stated above was hypothetical. None of those are areas where blockchains are demonstrated to be better than commercial alternatives for any significant audience. Ten years ago, even five years ago, I would have given you a pass for selling the amazing possibility rather than any actual facts. Sorry, but time's up on that. I'm asking for proof of traction, not further hype.
- cubano 8y agoMy personal bet is that blockchains will be like XML: a technology that was going to be The FUTURE for a while, got put into a bunch of things... That's an outstanding analogy, one I had not considered before, but certainly XML is far less..err...includable is perhaps the word(?)... into a software project then a blockchain-based datastore and verification would be, right? Let's just hope a XSLT-like companion to the blockchain is never developed...
- wpietri 8y agoIntresting! They strike me as equally includable. It's easy enough to do XML-based persistence, or XML-based messaging between nodes of a distributed system. Indeed, Jabber, an XML-based protocol, is seeing new life as a big IOT protocol. My cheap robot vacuum spends its day hanging out in a chatroom and communicating via XML, for example.