9 ms·
There's something in all this that I suspect demonstrates a possible flaw in Google's traditional data-orientation, as opposed to human judgement. What the col
by barrkel 16y ago
There's something in all this that I suspect demonstrates a possible flaw in Google's traditional data-orientation, as opposed to human judgement.
What the colour gradients (1Mcolors) example in the referred to article (http://englishhard.com/2010/10/01/real-world-analysis-of-googles-webp-versus-jpg/ http://englishhard.com/2010/10/01/real-world-analysis-of-goo...) shows is that WebP, at the limits of quality, prefers to blur. The problem is that most real-world scenes are of objects that have texture, and an artificial texture is psychologically more pleasing than blurring away all these high-frequency small detail patterns. Dark Shikari’s article (http://x264dev.multimedia.cx/?p=541 http://x264dev.multimedia.cx/?p=541) shows this really clearly: in a real-world landscape, WebP loses badly to both jpg and x264 with too much blurring.
Thing is, if you just do the "obvious" quality metric and do a subtraction of the encoded picture from the original, and sum up all the differences, that doesn't encode the psychological aspect.
A blurred image might indeed do well here, because the blur colour will be somewhere in the middle between the highs and lows of the high-frequency pattern, so the error won't be too large.
But a psychologically-oriented encoding may have encoded a pattern that resembles the original frequencies, but not precisely aligned, so the highs and lows may not coincide exactly between encoded image and original. It may thus simultaneously give a worse difference on a subtraction, but please the eye more.
- kevinpet 16y agoI had an internship working on measuring accuracy of fractal image compression algorithms many years ago. I remember the same thing -- measured accuracy was poor, but perceived quality was high.