3 ms·
After reading a number of comments... I wonder if we in the tech sector tend to romanticize the trades. I don't necessarily disagree, but would only offer a ca
by analog31 8y ago
After reading a number of comments...
I wonder if we in the tech sector tend to romanticize the trades. I don't necessarily disagree, but would only offer a caution: Look at their hands. I had a new screen door installed on my house, ordered it through Home Depot, and they contracted it to a father-son business. The father was not much older than me (mid 50s), but was broken and hobbling.
There's also a widespread view that we will always need tradespeople, e.g., to build houses. But the trades are being replaced by automation in subtle ways that could eat away at their livelihoods bit by bit. Examples include plumbing fittings where you just cut a plastic tube and squeeze it onto a fitting, rather than sweating it together with a torch. Another is the ability to design and order a "custom" house that's built in a factory and assembled on site.
- notacoward 8y agoI think it's a form of overcompensation. We all know deep down that we're pampered and privileged and frankly not contributing as much to the world as we're taking out of it. Thank you, supply and demand and barely-free-enough markets! But instead of just accepting that and making our peace with it, many of us try to make up for it with our choice of sports, hobbies, or accoutrements. There are way more techies obsessed with martial arts or brewing or sports cars than even other demographic factors such as income would predict. I think it's the same with trade and craft knowledge. Any techie with any exposure at all to the more traditionally "manly" trades (I'd include things like military/police work or firefighting here) tends to flaunt it as a way to show that they're more worldly and "authentic" than all those other techies who have never known any other life. I used to do it myself, except that my "trade" was the simple one of actually being poor. Then I realized that it was just another kind of virtue signaling, and it lost its appeal.