5 ms·
I'm very interested in solutions to this, as a bay area resident - somehow separating units into "the poor people houses" and "the rest of the people houses" do
by komali2 8y ago
I'm very interested in solutions to this, as a bay area resident - somehow separating units into "the poor people houses" and "the rest of the people houses" doesn't quite seem like the right long term solution to anything.
I don't have a solution, hence why I ask.
- comicjk 8y agoYou could give poor families a housing subsidy, which drops off smoothy as a function of income. You can't give a family half a house, but you can easily give them half as big a subsidy, knowing that they can more than make up the difference with their higher income. This also means that the family receiving the subsidy can live wherever they want. I think some of the smarter housing programs already work this way.
- SilasX 8y agoThat still has the effect of a (probably high) marginal tax and disincentivizes increasing one's income just the same. Why take night classes or work harder at your job if the $100/week raise comes with $80/week less in rent subsidies + taxes? (Example figures; you can change it around but most realistic situations are going to look similar.)
- gizmo686 8y agoIf you want to abolish the marginal tax, then I would start by looking at tax reform. If you think the marginal tax imposed by a given welfare system is too high, you can just tweak the numbers.
- SilasX 8y agoI meant that it's effectively a high marginal tax, when you decrease the housing subsidy as the recipient earns more income. That is, if every $100/month gain in wages comes with a $30/month decrease in subsidy, that's effectively a 30% marginal tax (on top of all their other taxes). (And I don't know what you mean by "just tweak the numbers"; the more generous benefits you want, the more you have to disincentivize work; no amount of "tweaking" avoids the core tradeoff.)
- gizmo686 8y agoWhat do you want the marginal rate to be? 1%? Just have a $1/month decrease in the subsidy for every $100/month increase in wages. Personally, I would prefer if all welfare was unconditional and we did all of this tweaking through the explicit tax code, but that is an implementation detail. >The more generous benefits you want, the more you have to disincentivize work; What disincentives work is the marginal decrease in benefits. Assuming you have adequate funding, there is no need to increase the rate of marginal decrease. If you don't have adequate funding, then you will need to fund the increased benefits to the not-as-poor by decreasing benefits to the poorer. There is, admitadly, a decreasing marginal value of money that does behave like you are describing, but its effect is dwarfed at the level of income we are talking about.
- ScottBurson 8y agoIt's true that the price of receiving a subsidy at all is that any money you make is going to be effectively taxed at a higher rate than it would have been otherwise. I think people can live with that as long as the effective tax rate doesn't get too high. Not sure what "too high" would be for most people, but I would guess that as long as the total effective incremental tax rate is never over 60% — meaning that after the reduction of the subsidy plus income tax, one would never keep less than $.40 of one's next dollar in earned income — that would probably be good enough. Yes, there will still be people who will find that a barrier, but at least there won't be this point where your next dollar of earned income will be effectively taxed at 50,000%. The extreme version is UBI, where everyone receives the full subsidy unconditionally, and the effective incremental tax rate is always just the income tax rate. I'm not sure that's a bad idea, but we could get rid of the current cliff much more easily than we could institute a full-blown UBI.
- SilasX 8y ago>It's true that the price of receiving a subsidy at all is that any money you make is going to be effectively taxed at a higher rate than it would have been otherwise. I wasn't referring to that; I was referring to the decreasing-subsidy-as-income-goes-up as being effectively a marginal tax. (I think the rest of your comment is recognizing it as one.) >I would guess that as long as the total effective incremental tax rate is never over 60% — meaning that after the reduction of the subsidy plus income tax, one would never keep less than $.40 of one's next dollar in earned income — that would probably be good enough. Yes, there will still be people who will find that a barrier, but at least there won't be this point where your next dollar of earned income will be effectively taxed at 50,000%. Even a 60% marginal tax is very strongly disincentivizing and makes it difficult to justify most any feasible long-term plan for increasing one's productivity from a poverty level. >The extreme version is UBI, where everyone receives the full subsidy unconditionally, and the effective incremental tax rate is always just the income tax rate. I'm not sure that's a bad idea, but we could get rid of the current cliff much more easily than we could institute a full-blown UBI. Right, that's the major upside of UBI. The downside is that it's really expensive (in terms of tax rate relative to benefits) and can't be concentrated on people who might need more help (temporary or otherwise) than others. And if you combine the two, then it's an even more punishing tax with its own effects.
- ryandrake 8y agoIf you could go from $200/week salary + $200/week welfare to $300/week salary + $120/week welfare, it would be in your interest to do so, as the total is more in the second scenario.
- michaelt 8y agoAnd if the extra $100/week salary came from going working 30 hours/week instead of 20?
- ryandrake 8y agoSure. 1. It's still more than you had before and 2. The next incremental increase you get, you'll be "keeping" even more on a percentage basis. The argument, "I don't want more income because I will lose some % of it due to [tax | benefits reduction]," makes no sense to me.
- michaelt 8y agoWould you work 10 hours for $20 cash, or do you know anyone who would? If so, I'll gladly hire you next weekend to paint my garden fence.
- lostapathy 8y agoYour example is pretty simple to avoid - don't phase it out so abruptly as to break the incentives to work.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I'm very interested in solutions to this, as a bay area resident - somehow separating units into "the poor people houses" and "the rest of the people houses" doesn't quite seem like the right long term solution to anything. The real problem is that we do taxes wrong. We have a progressive tax schedule on the tax side, but then we want to have benefits phase outs on the benefits side. But these are really opposites that cancel each other. It's also very hard to reason about, because if you have multiple benefits programs that phase out in the same place, you can accidentally produce these >100% marginal rates at specific income levels. And progressive tax schedules are very expensive. If you e.g. reduces taxes by 10% on incomes under $40,000 then someone who makes $40,000 pays $4000 less in taxes. But so does everyone who makes more than $40,000, because they now pay $4000 less on the first $40,000 of their income. The answer is to not phase out benefits whatsoever, let that be the progressive component of the system, and use a single uniform tax rate. The uniform rate supplies the revenue to compensate for the lack of phase outs, but will never produce a cliff.
- jadedhacker 8y agoIf you want the left perspective, all or nearly all housing would be public housing. This cuts landlords and banks out of the loop and decreases housing prices for everyone. No one goes homeless. You can move whenever you want, though there might be waitlists in some cities depending on how it's implemented. For what it's worth though, we already have waitlists, you can just skip them by having sufficient money.
- komali2 8y agoThis seems interesting, I wonder why it's being downvoted? I personally don't understand the value landlords contribute to society so I'm curious what a society without them looks like. I expect I can get sarcastic answers about failed Communist states, but I'm hoping someone has spirited examples.