3 ms·
> This leaves us at our current state, which is "nobody gets to make the decision." Except that is not our current state. Our current state is that a bizarre
by lisper 8y ago
> This leaves us at our current state, which is "nobody gets to make the decision."
Except that is not our current state. Our current state is that a bizarre legal process makes the decision, and that process is different in every state.
Any time you have uncertainty, you necessarily have both type I and type II errors. You can tweak your decision criteria so that you get more of one or more of the other, but you can never eliminate errors entirely. The fundamental problem we have is that we can't agree which is worse: having someone die before their time, or having someone live past it.
One thing that would help is to recognize that our choice of terminology is hurting us: we talk about "saving lives" but in fact there is no such thing as "saving" a life, only extending one. Once you look at it that way you realize almost immediately that if you're going to allocated resources to extending a life, it probably makes more sense to, say, allocate those resources to a 20-year-old rather than a 95-year-old.
- whatshisface 8y ago>in fact there is no such thing as "saving" a life, only extending one. Most of the objection to euthanasia is focused on the case where you are administering deadly medications to a person that can survive on their own. Ending life support is another debate, although one that shares many properties and players with euthanasia.
- lisper 8y agoYeah, that's actually another thing that I think is messing us up, this idea that "letting nature take its course" is somehow better in and of itself than intervention. If you know that the outcome of "letting nature take its course" is going to be a bucketful of pain, and you have the option to eliminate that pain with a low-cost intervention, and you choose not to intervene, then IMHO that pain is on you every bit as much as if you'd actively tortured the person. (All this is assuming that the subject consents, of course. Some people might choose to experience the pain. I can respect that.) On the other hand, I really don't see the salient difference between euthanizing someone and sedating them until they die of starvation and dehydration. Once you start to intervene with the intent of producing a painless death, why not just get it over with?
- BoiledCabbage 8y agoBut what is "life support" in a hospital? Do providing food and water count? Would it be ok to also remove those forms of life support to allow one to finally die if it's their wish? Stop providing heat to their room? If so, why so? Why is that form of induced death better or worse than administering a drug? If not, why not? It's clearly a form of hospital administered life support just like a breathing machine. I don't have the answer, but it's not a cut and dry question. Like most things around life and conscienceness it's complicated.