3 ms·
Typical Apple jerk move. 1. Apple didn't provide Vulkan support. 2. Developers of MoltenVK found "public" Metal API to be inadequate, and used something that
by shmerl 8y ago
Typical Apple jerk move.
1. Apple didn't provide Vulkan support.
2. Developers of MoltenVK found "public" Metal API to be inadequate, and used something that Apple considers not public to implement Vulkan translation.
3. Apple found an excuse to ban usage of MoltenVK under pretense that their non public APIs shouldn't be used.
Surely, Apple could:
1. Provide Vulkan to begin with.
2. Provide public APIs in Metal that are adequate to implement Vulkan.
But doing that would reduce Apple's lock-in, so they are resorting to jerk moves. Apple being Apple.
- innagadadavida 8y agoTo play the devils advocate, Why should Vulcan propagate their own APIs instead of picking one and porting others to work on top of it? All they are doing is this: https://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/ Considering they don’t control any platform, they are misguided.
- shmerl 8y ago> Why should Vulcan propagate their own APIs instead of picking one and porting others to work on top of it? I suppose you are asking, why should developers strive to use cross platform API, instead of using Apple's lock-in. The answer is simple - reducing work duplication. It's same reason you'd avoid using ActiveX, Silverlight and Flash and would use standard HTML/JavaScript. Apple obviously are irritated that someone found a way to break their lock-in, so they are looking for ways to mess things up under some side pretenses.
- nextweek2 8y agoVulkan was called Mantle before AMD gave it to the open standards group. Mantle existed before Metal and Apple knew it was being made into an open standard before they released Metal. AMD and Khronos were open about their plans and Apple was/is part of the group. To answer your question, Khronos are trying to promote an open free API to help developers save time and effort, picking Metal as a closed source and late arrival would be unworkable.
- tpush 8y agoAgain this ideological nonsense. This app used MoltenVK which used private APIs so Apple banned it, like all other applications that do so. Case closed.
- shmerl 8y agoApple's opposition to Vulkan is purely political to begin with. Their usual anti-competitive lock-in garbage. So no one will buy their "like all other applications" excuse.