4 ms·
This article makes in seem like ancient history, but there are still projects around that use CVS or very similar VCS like for example ClearCase. My software en
by adrianN 8y ago
This article makes in seem like ancient history, but there are still projects around that use CVS or very similar VCS like for example ClearCase. My software engineering career started after git got popular, but I had to work with ClearCase. I wouldn't wish it on anybody.
The inability to go back to old states of your project unless you happened to tag them makes finding the cause of bugs extremely hard. I don't know how it is in CVS, but in Clearcase you can tag only a subset of the files and what you check out from the server is determined by a complex configuration file ("the configuration specification"). This is an additional hurdle to reconstructing old states of your software because now you need to know the config-spec to do so. Even if you have the old config spec, it might contain fallback rules ("just take the latest version of the file") that effectively make it impossible to reproduce the old state. Unless you're extremely disciplined in your usage of the tool it's a real challenge to fix bugs for old releases. And don't get me started on trying to backport bugfixes into several old releases when branches are managed for each file separately.
This lack of a proper project wide history also makes it extremely challenging to migrate to a different tool without losing a lot of information.
- vidarh 8y agoI have source sitting around that was maintained in CVS. Nothing I'm still using, but old archives I keep for nostalgia... But I feel really old now, when tech I used in the early part of my career is now considered ancient enough to justify "historical" accounts of how we worked in the dark ages. But I do remember when CVS was considered a step up, so I suppose I'm getting old.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoThere are JavaScript frameworks from two years ago that are considered ancient, so don't let this get ya down, grandpa. ;)
- beefhash 8y agoCase in point: OpenBSD[1]. [1] https://cvsweb.openbsd.org/cgi-bin/cvsweb/ https://cvsweb.openbsd.org/cgi-bin/cvsweb/
- Freaky 8y agoAnd NetBSD: http://cvsweb.netbsd.org/bsdweb.cgi/ http://cvsweb.netbsd.org/bsdweb.cgi/
- renox 8y agoClearCase is only similar to CVS as it is a centralised version control system otherwise it's very different
- mjw1007 8y agoCVS indeed has the problem where you can inadvertently tag only a subset of the files you shipped. But it did also let you check out files as of a particular timestamp, which could be more reliable.
- acemarke 8y agoWe previously used Clearcase at work. At one point a coworker ran a survey asking for people's experience with different VCS options. The best reply I saw was : "Clearcase is the single most productivity destroying tool I have ever worked with."
- raverbashing 8y agoClearCase is the reason why I will avoid all and any (and will encourage others to avoid) SW products by that famous three-letter company unless absolutely needed (but it never is) Or maybe I should just send the PTSD bill to them
- pvg 8y agoThey didn't write ClearCase.
- raverbashing 8y ago"You adopt the child, you're responsible for it" MS didn't write Skype but it sure got worse after they bought it.
- pvg 8y agoClearCase was as delightfully terrible before IBM bought it and before Rational bought it. Writing off all software from IBM because they sell some lame software just seems weird. It's a huge company. I'm sure some people who enjoy soup have written bad software but it's saner to evaluate whether software is actually good or bad rather than checking if the authors like soup.
- raverbashing 8y ago> off all software from IBM because they sell some lame software just seems weird If you disregard their bully sales and "promotion" tactics ando how much the "Rational" suite of products cost So no, I'm happy that github took over and I'm happy to boycott it as much as I can
- hestefisk 8y agoFwiw it came from the IBM acquisition of Rational.
- simula67 8y ago> My software engineering career started after git got popular, but I had to work with ClearCase Me too I agree with you, the code I had inherited was built with clearmake and no one had any idea how to move it to a newer build system. It was multi-platform code and you had to compile all the C++ code on an HP-UX machine first. The build would fail the first time and then succeed the second time. Once it was built on HP-UX, it could be built on any other platform There was a dedicated "build engineer" who was the only one who knew how to fix build issues. Thankfully the project was finished by the time he had left the company :)
- BeetleB 8y ago>This article makes in seem like ancient history, but there are still projects around that use CVS or very similar VCS like for example ClearCase. Don't remind me. I worked for a group in a top tech company that used cvs until 2014 and were very resistant to switching. They finally switched due to a department mandate to stop using cvs (they were not the only team in the department using cvs).
- philwelch 8y agoClearCase required its own custom file system on the server, but lacked atomic commits. Also, the same workplace where I used ClearCase was the one that used Lotus Notes.