4 ms·
Problem is, some domain and number holders have no incorperated body: they hold the resource as a private individual. Hard to formulate consistent data law arou
by ggm 8y ago
Problem is, some domain and number holders have no incorperated body: they hold the resource as a private individual. Hard to formulate consistent data law around WHOIS when its both people, and corporate entities.
I was in the WHOIS as was from SRI-NIC. I kept GM85 in my current nic-hdl for resources as a memory of the days gone by: they even published a paper copy of the listing.. the phone book of the internet, how .. quaint.
Yes, the protocol is designed for days gone by. but the GDPR laws apply to RDAP, even though it has HTTPS and could in principle use Oauth or similar to constrain whats shown to open access.
- lucb1e 8y agoI don't understand the problem. You say the problem is that both individuals and companies register domains, but why should the info of either be visible in a public database?
- ggm 8y agoSo that people who are seeking redress can find who holds the resource. That's what whois is mostly about: redress. I'm not trying to defend that against peoples rights to privacy I'm observing there's a significant community of interest in "who did that" if you don't believe that's necessary then you win with GDPR. If you do, then the masking means you cannot know, but lawyers and judges and police and governments can.
- vorg 8y ago> some domain and number holders have no incorperated body: they hold the resource as a private individual whois has been useful to me in the past for finding out whether a DNS name is held by the foundation/company/trust/whatever or if it's held by a private individual who set up the foundation/trust/whatever. When a whois lookup shows a certain private individual listed as owner, admin, and tech contact for some DNS name, then I can know the foundation is a sham created to make it look like the open source product is community controlled, when in fact it's really just one narcissist pulling the strings. I say keep the whois service as is.