7 ms·
British geologist Herbert Henry Thomas’ seminal study on Stonehenge was wrong
- mettamage 8y agoWow, this story leaves quite an impression on me on what it means to be a celebrated expert who is quite uncontested. You can basically meddle with the knowledge we humans have on that front and it will take quite a while for people to uncover it. I feel immediately more critical on our scientific and academic leaders and more responsible myself -- despite having no position in academia.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoOld mate’s been dead for 85 years. You’d think if someone had a better idea they’d have come forward with it earlier. I find it hard to believe no one spoke up because old dead guy is so renown.
- toolslive 8y agoThe whole thing reminds me of the Piltdown man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piltdown_Man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piltdown_Man A friend of mine, who is an archaeologist once explained me there are topics in archaeology you cannot touch without risking your career.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoThe expert was largely uncontested as the explanation he gave was adequate given the question being asked. More evidence was needed for a better explanation, and there wasn't a strong push to fund more research to answer "where did the stone for Stonehenge come from?" Though there can be some examples of scientists unwilling to question past experts, the bigger obstacle is the limited amount of evidence that scientists are able to collect.
- vlz 8y agoYes, and I would emphasize the funding aspect. Archaeology is not a discipline we spend tons of money on anyway. I would expect errors to live on longer here than in say cancer research.
- chriselrod 8y agoReminds me of Brian Wansink, the Cornell professor who was a "world-renowned eating expert for over 25 years". When statisticians finally started looking at his lab's work, they noticed absolutely extraordinary amounts of errors. Like, 150-errors-in-just-4-papers level of extraordinary. http://andrewgelman.com/2017/06/15/pizzagate-gets-even-ridiculous-either-not-read-previous-pizza-buffet-study-not-consider-part-literature-later-study-found/ http://andrewgelman.com/2017/06/15/pizzagate-gets-even-ridic...
- beagle3 8y agoYou should. It happens all the time, and more often than not whitewashed later so if you read the history later all looks dandy and nothing more than a minor healthy disagreement. Dan Shechtman had to wait for Linus Pauling to die to be unlabeled as fraud (and later receive a nobel). Turns out he wasn’t the first to observe the supposedly impossible 5-fold crystal symmetry - but he was the only one willing to risk his name and career to make it known (and was not far from being pushed out as a fraud). Barbara McClintock had a similar story with jumping genes. Semmelweis with washing hands. There are cranks, of course, and they likely outnumber the real discoverers 100:1 - but the price of knowledge is eternal vigilance against prevailing dogmas, especially those of deferring everything to leaders of the field.
- ksangeelee 8y agoThe abstract for the study (which is behind a paywall) states of Thomas's work "While respectable for its time". The article doesn't feel like it reflects this sentiment. The title also seems unfairly overstated, claiming Thomas was 'spectacularly wrong'. He correctly identified where the rocks came from, to within a few miles of the location identified in the study.
- 21 8y agoMax Planck said that "science advances one funeral at a time". Or more precisely: "A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it."
- rasz 8y agoVery true. Remember that National Strength and Conditioning Association (NSCA) peer reviewed "revalence of injury during CrossFit training" study telling you it causes harm (covered by hackernews multiple times)? Turns out it was 100% fabricated. https://www.buzzfeed.com/stephaniemlee/russell-berger-crossfit-science-lgbt https://www.buzzfeed.com/stephaniemlee/russell-berger-crossf...
- shawn 8y agoOnce we realized he got everything wrong, we went back to the material he used, the specimens he used, the thin sections he used, the maps he used. And we could see that time and time again, he slightly changed this — or let's say he forgot," Ixer told Live Science. One of these is a far more serious charge than the other. Scientists don’t fabricate data. At least, not if their work matters. And even then, the fabrications are usually discovered. I guess the article feels strange because it’s stopping short of saying he was an outright fraud, but strongly hints at it. And that kind of conclusion seems to require more substantive evidence than they showed. Old work is mistaken and superseded constantly. In physics, it’s only possible to falsify a theory, not to prove it’s true. So scientists can only be sure they’re wrong (or approximately correct, if you’re feeling glass-half-full about it). But creating fake data reduces science to nothing more than an efficient method of converting money into mistaken ideas. It undermines everything science stands for. Could anyone dig into the paper to find out whether he did in fact make changes to any data? Either he did and was lying, or didn’t and was mistaken. It’d be interesting to know precisely which.
- l0b0 8y agoUpvoted, but citation needed for "the fabrications are usually discovered." Basically the state of any research that nobody has tried to replicate yet is unknown.
- coldtea 8y agoIt's also a logical impossibility to really determine whether "fabrications are usually discovered" or not. We can only know about fabrications after they have been discovered -- so there could be 2x or even 10x as much that we don't know about and count among the "non fabricated" work.
- tlb 8y agoIt's not impossible. We know how many fabrications are discovered. You can take a random sample of papers and analyze them in depth to estimate the number of papers that are fabricated.
- lifeisstillgood 8y ago>>> Such a monumental procession would have been akin to transporting the space shuttle Endeavor in a parade, for all to see and celebrate, the archaeologists said. This is another one of those "sounds good" ideas that the article is complaining about. The total population of the UK would have varied from 40,000 lower bound to 200k in this period (see below - figures really hard to find) Basically that's empty. It's like the pyramids - at some point the labour force needed looks like "everyone" - processions did not go "past" anyone - there was basically no one to go past. And at some level of population, there was no one to go past because they were all pushing huge slabs of stone. It's worth noting this took hundreds of years to achieve as well - this was socially deep - and we understand nothing about it ... weird https://digitalcommons.wayne.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1060&context=humbiol https://digitalcommons.wayne.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article...
- tlb 8y agoYou can never have all the people pushing the rock. Women, children, and the elderly wouldn't. And you need a large supply chain to feed and shelter the rock pushers along the route. As a benchmark, 31% of Germany's population were in uniform in WWII. That's probably the greatest fraction a society can devote to a project.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoEverybody should have been in air-quotes - but whichever percentage you choose (I have heard upto 90% of all able bodied workers in Egypt were on the pyramids until harvest time) at some point it is mind boggling - how were there enough people in the UK - stonehenge was a multi-generational project on a scale that dwarfs St. paul's cathedral and similar projects - hundreds of years long and involving such a fraction of the population for what? A petrol pump for visiting space aliens would have made more sense than fifth aveneue style sunsets.
- mjw1007 8y ago"Spectacularly wrong" here appears to mean that he correctly identified that the bluestones came from the Preseli hills almost 200 miles from Stonehenge (and was the first to do so), but didn't get quite the right outcrop. He thought they came from Carn Meini; the article says we now think they came from Craig Rhos-y-felin and Carn Goedog. https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2013/nov/20/archaeologists-stonehenge-origins-wrong-place https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2013/nov/20/archaeologis... says that Carn Goedog is less than a mile from Carn Meini.
- Moodles 8y agoI'm so fed up with science and politics journalism.
- zorkw4rg 8y agoThe article even makes mentioned potential fraud: "[Thomas] was forgetful and sloppy, but at worst he was being deceptive" Without any further explanation. Science "journalism" certainly has the reputation it deserves.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoTo be fair, that’s a quote from the co-author of the study not the author of this article. And it does elaborate further later in the article on the context of where he was either forgetful or deceptive.
- lobotryas 8y agoTrue, but the article author decided to include it. A less charitable interpretation might say it was included strictly as click bait.
- kryptiskt 8y agoRight, this is overselling a paper at its worst. They're just dressing up a mundane result with bombastic rhetoric.
- 8y ago
- dalbasal 8y agoA question that really interests me about Stonehenge, Gobleki Teppeh and other such mysterious monumental sites is "how many people did this?" When we (now, and in the past) look at ancient construction projects, we instinctively tend to imagine fairly "brute force" construction methods. Basically, the way things are done now but with people powered trucks, cranes and such. Think of all those depictions of many people dragging huge loads on rollers or sleds. Very large groups of people using muscle power. Thousands of labourers, hundreds of years. Herodotus suggests that it took 100,000 builders over 20 years to build a pyramid, 2m man years. In egypt, it's plausible. They had huge numbers of people, an empire, large scale slavery... With stonehenge in 5,000 ypb britain, there are thought to be far fewer people. It wasn't a massive urban culture like egypt. People are thought to have lived in small dispersed groups at that time, with little evidence of large "political" authority that could command a large labour force. Gogleki Tepeh's builders achieved similar feats 12,000 YBB. This is before large scale societies are thought to have existed at all, anywhere. So either, (1) "civilised" society was much more common historically and ancient in origin (2) There were "pre-civilised" ways of organising very large numbers of people. Or (3), they had very clever building techniques that did not require many people. Any of these answers, or some combination of them could add a lot of flavour to our understanding of the neolithic, culturally.
- zorkw4rg 8y agoThe number of 20 years is often repeated for the great giza pyramid, however its constructed using 2.3 million stones (~2.5 ton each) meaning they would have to place a stone every 5 minutes, for 20 years to make any sense. Traditional theories of egyptology fiercely defended by argument of authority are utterly useless. In reality nobody has any idea how, when or even by whom (I would despute the cartouche as solid evidence) the great pyramid was actually built and egyptology certainly won't figure it out (at least not with its current systemic issues).
- dalbasal 8y agoThe 100k workers over 20 years figures aren't a theory of modern researchers. Those estimates are from Herodotus, who was reporting on what Egyptians of his day (2,500 ybp) thought. That's why it's repeated so often. It could be that they/he was wrong. I think it sounds plausible in terms of the amount of work. 1 man year per stone.
- m0nty 8y ago> "Nobody would drag the stones up the Preseli Hills only then to drift them down south to Milford Haven," Ixer said. And going to the sea from the northern slopes isn't ideal, either. "You've actually got to make a long sea journey all the way around the south coast of Wales," he said. "So, it seems a pretty unlikely suggestion." I'm not sure about this. It was a massive effort to move the stones in the first place, maybe if you could do most of the moving by boat or raft rather than dragging them all the way, it might have been a worthwhile trade-off. It's a long way from Newport (West Wales, not the one nearer to England) to Salisbury, and the terrain is hard going all the way. We're talking here about people who reshaped Maiden Castle in Dorset by hand, using (as far as we know) tools made from antler and moving the earth in baskets. Who built Silbury Hill using similar methods. Who thought it worthwhile moving these massive stones (and hundreds like them) across the country at a time when any journey was far more difficult and dangerous than today. They were not like us.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoThe tone of the article is aggravating - "debunking" and "debunked" are continuously used to say that, basically, modern researchers used modern techniques to prove older results partially wrong. As if this is something uncommon, in the sciences! I am very surprised that the accusations of potential fraud come from the researchers themselves, despite the fact that they admit the use of tools unavailable to the older researcher. It make me wonder whether all this talk of "debunking" and "myths" would be the case if this was not about Stonehenge, a subject that tends to attract lots of attention from quacks and loons of all stripes.
- j1vms 8y agoNot related to the geological aspects, but Spinal Tap's account of what happened at Stonehenge is the most plausible. https://youtu.be/qAXzzHM8zLw https://youtu.be/qAXzzHM8zLw
- extralego 8y agoThomas was so widely respected that nobody questioned his work for decades. We naturally encourage questioning honorable confidence in the abstract but rarely in concrete actions. Serious question: Is there a field, or even a social context, in which doing so would actually be rewarded? And sort of related: Is a system for such questioning a necessity for a meritocracy or can a be meritocratic system still exist at the same time? I guess I just assume that, for example, companies claiming meritocracy were just actively ignoring organic social structures responsible for most of the honor hierarchies in the first place. I always thought social paradigms associated with enlightenment we’re essentially anti-structures to contend with this sort of thing. But doesn’t meritocracy in tech somehow seem to take those efforts for granted? I have never worked at these companies so I am really curious.
- DanBC 8y ago> Serious question: Is there a field, or even a social context, in which doing so would actually be rewarded? Health care is putting considerable effort into creating psychological safety and just culture, in front line staff and in the board, to create the ability to question what happens. This is to prevent things like the Argon Beam Liver Tattoo doctor from carrying on without being stopped; or to ensure boards question the serious incident reports they get. So far it's had a limited effect, but culture takes a long time to change.