4 ms·
I've been wondering, for a while, if regulatory capture is a natural outcome of two-party systems. The central genius, IMHO, of the US Constitution is the buil
by specialist 8y ago
I've been wondering, for a while, if regulatory capture is a natural outcome of two-party systems.
The central genius, IMHO, of the US Constitution is the built-in trilemma (separation of powers, court vs legislature vs executive), which has proven more durable. (Present circumstances notwithstanding, ahem.)
What would a trilemma for regulations look like? Give "the market", in the form of consumer advocates, a seat at the table?
I still have no idea.
I've asked everyone I can think of. Famed muckraker Greg Palast's, who has direct experience trying to thwart regulatory capture, answer was "more transparency, more participation".
Which I find very unsatisfactory. Having done the whole agitator, whistleblower routine, it really isn't sustainable for outsiders to serve as the counterbalance. It occurs to me each of the three parties needs some kind of veto power.
- dmix 8y agoA few ideas: 1) Regulations by default should be capped at organization size or industry. Minimum wage is a great example of this, great for 25% of companies/industries, terrible for the rest - its hard to measure jobs that are never created as a result. 2) A powerful, well financed agency whose mandate is to audit all regulations, monitor and capture data regarding it's function, and review their ultimate utility to society as a whole. The vast majority of harmful regulations were designed in a different era and for a different evolved market. Markets also adapt to regulations as well naturally reducing utility. This agency would have the power to temporarily end regulations until congress reviews it and either updates it or ends it officially. 3) Time limits on regulations forcing them to be renewed every x years, requiring data to show it's helping, not harming society
- KozmoNau7 8y agoRE: your point #1, nope that won't work. By capping based on revenue, bigger companies will simply spin off certain employee segments into separate contractor companies. Create a possible loophole, and it will be exploited.
- specialist 8y ago1) Hmmm. Like sectoral bargaining for wages? https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/4/9/17205064/union-labor-movement-collective-wage-boards-bargaining https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/4/9/17205064/un... I'd have to chew on this one. I'm not willing to forfeit environmental, consumer, safety umbrellas without an compelling upside (upgrade). 2) Ah. An regulation ombudsman? Like the Congressional Budget Office, but for rules and regs? 3) Emphatic agreement. I've adopted an almost religious devotion applying TTL (time to live) to everything. DHCP lease expiration and renewal, auth security tokens, cache invalidation are such effective architectural patterns, they feel like magic to me.
- dingo_bat 8y agoI feel that minimum wage pushes companies to invest in technology and automation. Which is always good. Set the minimum wage at $50 and eventually no human will need to work for so less money.
- snovv_crash 8y agoI would say that regulatory capture is the natural outcome of a Republic, due to the fact that the representatives can be persuaded to act against their constituents wills. A Direct Democracy is now technologically viable, and having people regularly participate in voting on small topics keeps people accountable and also allows more nuanced views where somebody doesn't have to, eg. be anti single-payer-healthcare AND be anti illegal-immigrant at the same time. This reduces deadlocks and we don't get stupid compromise bills with pork spending being passed so that each team gets something they are happy about.
- bicubic 8y agoI think a direct democracy would be a disaster. The average person can't sink the time to become knowledgeable on all matters that affect them. Worse yet, the average person is trivially manipulated through mass media. To game the entire system, you just have to gain control of the education sector and grow yourself a generation of placated consumers that do as they're told. And exactly this seems to be happening in many countries right now. Getting a desired outcome on any given vote by polarising the topic along some axis sounds like something that could be achieved with current generation ML.
- snovv_crash 8y agoAre you arguing that it is easier to corrupt an entire population than a few elected representatives?
- craftyguy 8y ago> I think a direct democracy would be a disaster. For an example of what this would look like, see: popular subreddits, Twitter, etc. Sensationalism prevails, actual content fails.
- Pica_soO 8y agoActually, we had sort of a trilemma, during the cold-war- when there was a external force on the market to behave "well" or face socialization of capital by internal forces. Thats why the front-states of the cold war where either war-zones or rich show-rooms.