6 ms·
Windows also lost the ability to have multiple UI styles after Windows XP -> Vista, and has yet to recover it as far as I know. Microsoft also never officially
by Razengan 8y ago
Windows also lost the ability to have multiple UI styles after Windows XP -> Vista, and has yet to recover it as far as I know. Microsoft also never officially exposed the API so you had to use performance-degrading hacks like WindowBlinds.
In my experience as a Mac + iOS user and developer for the past 8 years, and for the rest of my life before that on Microsoft platforms, Apple's record has been much better compared to Microsoft re: abandoning APIs or pulling the rug out from under devs.
Take NSDocument for example. It has been around for almost 20 years. All you usually needed to do was inherit from it and adopt its interface and your app would often get new features for free with each release of macOS, like autosaving and version histories.
The foundations for multiple UI appearances have been there since macOS 10.10 Yosemite, 4 years ago. They were hard not to notice.
As a user and developer I'm glad they took the time to work out a sensible implementation that is very easy to adopt now and makes good sense for the future. It definitely seems to be in a better spot than Windows' support for multiple appearances currently, if it has any.
If you see the WWDC sessions on Dark Mode, you might come to appreciate the thought and effort they've put into it:
[0] Introducing Dark Mode: https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2018/210/ https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2018/210/
[1] Advanced Dark Mode: https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2018/218/ https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2018/218/
- Illniyar 8y agoYou can say a lot of things about windows but abandoning apis isn't one of them. Windows is the king of backwards compatibility, for better or for worse.
- Razengan 8y agoDirectInput -> XInput, which dumbed down many of the advanced Force-Feedback features to the level that the simple Xbox gamepads could support, compared to the original Sidewinder line of awesome joysticks (another victim of Microsoft abandonment.) Often not making many APIs available in their latest programming technologies like .NET/C# (at least initially.) WPF, Silverlight, the "Metro" experiment that lasted for a single (!) version of Windows (8), and great discontinued apps like PhotoDraw, are some of the other cases that personally affected me.
- RaleyField 8y ago> (!) They changed the name to Modern UI, some reported [1] because it clashed with their German partner Metro AG. In any case Modern UI started with Zune and you could get for the time nifty looking media player for it on XP [2]. You can still see it in newer parts of Windows 10 with its aversion to skeuomorphic design, preferring text and minimalist 1 color icons. [1](https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/08/microsoft-metro-out-windows-8-style-ui-in-amid-rumors-of-a-trademark-dispute/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/08/micro...) [2] https://archive.ledfrog.com/2011/06/microsoft-zune-software-review/ https://archive.ledfrog.com/2011/06/microsoft-zune-software-...
- Razengan 8y agoI was referring to that crippled subsystem with the fullscreen Start Menu/Screen and the touchscreen-compatible apps that launched from it, separate from the "full" "desktop" experience, where you had two versions of IE, Outlook, Skype etc. It was also all you could access on the now-abandoned Windows RT. Is that dichotomy still present in Windows 10? See, it's a confusing exercise to even figure out what their sub-platforms are supposed to be called. Apparently they are now "Universal Windows Platform (UWP) apps (formerly Windows Store apps and Metro-style apps)" [0] Do they have access to the full feature set of DirectX etc.? Do they have support for multiple appearances, Dark Mode, etc.? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Windows_Platform_apps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Windows_Platform_app...
- pjmlp 8y agoWin32 is kind of legacy. UWP is what was WinRT on Windows 8, they have just been improving it all these years. Of course they have access to full DirectX 11 and 12. All new APIs are UWP based, and with they learned with the Desktop Bridge for Win32, they changed their strategy and are now merging UWP and Wi32 into a single container/store model. Some of the talks related with it were done at MSBUILD 2018, check MSIX, .NET Core 3.0 roadmap, XAML Islands, XAML Direct. If they don't change direction, in a couple of Windows releases they will be merged, with UWP continuously taking over Win32, like Win32 did before to Win16. As for Apple, I can quickly refer to Object Pascal, Quickdraw 3D, JavaBridge, Quickdraw Java APIs, A/UX, Dylan, Newton, MCL, Hypercard....
- xorcist 8y agoCompared to what? Apple or the mobile OS du jour? Most other operating systems in commercial use, and we can look both at the commercial unices and the embedded stuff, supports APIs much older than Windows itself. Support for the Win16 API has been abysmal recently. My limited experience of old DOS and Windows applications is that they often run better under dosbox or wine than native.
- pjmlp 8y agoHow much of those commercial unices and the embedded stuff older than Windows are actually still being updated beyond bug fixes?
- DonHopkins 8y agoAnd in some cases, like their speech synthesis and recognition APIs, Windows has been pretty darn good about having the APIs in the first place, maintaining and improving them over more than a couple decades, with the APIs being quite rich and supporting third party components like voices, synthesizers and recognizers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Speech_API https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Speech_API While Apple's speech APIs, for all their huff and puff and other legitimate work on accessibility, are totally lacking, way behind, locked away from third party developers, and sadly deficient for application developers who need more than the most basic off-the-shelf features. For example, SAPI has for decades been able to a send mouth positions (visemes) synchronized with the speech, to animate the lips of the Wizard or Rover the Dog or Clippy (or whatever a paperclip uses to articulate), which is proven to improve speech understanding. But not a peep from Apple's speech API -- their lips are sealed. https://www.codeproject.com/Articles/1609/Converting-Text-To-Speech-and-and-using-mouth-moti?msg=260302#xx260302xx https://www.codeproject.com/Articles/1609/Converting-Text-To...
- coldtea 8y ago>You can say a lot of things about windows but abandoning apis isn't one of them. Actually abandoning APIs is very much one of them. While programs written in older API still work, MS is notorious for abandoning APIs (as opposed to removing them) and asking developers to support its new shiny thing even faster than Apple changes frameworks (heck, you could still compile NeXT apps 30+ years later, and the frameworks where still supported, albeit with some alterations). MS always invents new frameworks and APIs every 2-3 years for the same thing, e.g. GUI programming (or at least used to, haven't followed for the last several years).
- johnchristopher 8y agoAs a user I gave up on themes. I now just roll with the week's flavour instead of trying to keep up with tweaks, icons hunting, etc. :(
- whywhywhywhy 8y ago>It definitely seems to be in a better spot than Windows' support for multiple appearances currently, if it has any. It has had pretty much what Apple are implementing since Windows 10. Dark mode and a custom highlight colour that gets applied across the OS. Of course like on MacOS developers have to be using the latest UI framework to take advantage of this which unfortunately on Windows developers are a fair bit slower on the uptake than on MacOS. Then again, I don't expect to see much uptake on the Mac side either considering I can't remember the last time I installed a new app and it was a native AppKit(?) UI and not just an Electron app.
- Razengan 8y ago> It has had pretty much what Apple are implementing since Windows 10. The last time I checked Windows 10 did not support Dark Mode across all apps, not even its own File Explorer (unlike Finder and almost all other apps and applets that come with macOS Mojave.) Has that changed? Do many third-party Windows apps support Dark Mode by now? > Of course like on MacOS developers have to be using the latest UI framework From what I remember from the WWDC sessions, I think you can choose to target the second-last macOS release (10.13 High Sierra) and still opt-into Dark Mode support on 10.14 Mojave. > Then again, I don't expect to see much uptake on the Mac side Pretty much all "heavy editing" apps like Final Cut, Affinity, Pixelmator Pro or even players like VLC use native AppKit and already offer an option for a custom dark mode or the official limited opt-in version that has been available since macOS 10.10 Yosemite.