3 ms·
>It's a matter of opinion, but I don't think it's an intolerable burden if your tax prep costs are <10% of your total tax bill. And I do. For most of the world
by BeetleB 8y ago
>It's a matter of opinion, but I don't think it's an intolerable burden if your tax prep costs are <10% of your total tax bill.
And I do. For most of the world, tax prep costs are negligible. I'm not sure how many countries have tax prep for individuals as a big business like it is in the US.
- perl4ever 8y agoIn context, we're not talking about a big business, because the market is a small number of people with special needs. It seems quite inappropriate to compare them to "most of the world".
- BeetleB 8y ago>In context, we're not talking about a big business, because the market is a small number of people with special needs. It seems quite inappropriate to compare them to "most of the world". I think we're talking about very different things. To directly address your comment: When you say the market is a small number, you are correct: The market is workers living outside the US who happen to be American. Foreign workers of pretty much every other country do not deal with this. It's a market very targeted to Americans. And its smallness makes it expensive. But when I said how your comment about paying for tax prep was a very American outlook, I was referring to the reality that so many in the US rely either on tax software or pay a company to do their taxes. This is a practice alien (AFAIK) to most countries - they have much simpler tax codes and rarely do they need to make special payments for tax prep. Having to pay a tax prep company because you happen to be American is effectively a tax on being an American. For many outside the US, saying "It's not a big deal - just pay a tax company to handle it" is like me telling a typical American "It's not a big deal. Just pay a company $500 annually to do the paperwork that gives you the right to own a pet" - it's a crazy notion. It's easy to dismiss it as "Less than 10% of your tax burden - what's the big deal?" Just a few days ago I was reading a story of a Canadian/American dual citizen. She was born to American parents, but as a kid her parents migrated to Canada - she had lived most of her life in Canada, and had no real relations in the US. The old tax law was that she is not considered a US citizen unless she actively declares herself as one after she turns 18. That law changed recently (I think under Obama) to treat her like all other Americans for tax purposes. Suddenly she had to deal with filing paperwork, and getting taxed on certain retirement/investment benefits (that are tax free in Canada but not in the US - think stuff like Roth IRA in the US), etc. When I was in school, I knew many foreign grad students - it can take 5-8 years to get a PhD - and if you're young and married, there's a good chance you'll have a kid or two during your stay at school. Some of them returned to their home countries (contractual obligations, etc). I don't know if their kids will eventually move to the US and claim citizenship, but they will have the burden of dealing with US taxes wherever they live in the world - whether they earn a good amount of money or not. Finally, getting back to your original comment:
- perl4ever 8y ago"It's easy to dismiss it as "Less than 10% of your tax burden - what's the big deal?"" My heuristic is that a percentage of a percentage is quite small, in general. It's fundamentally different from $500, which could be a lot of money or not depending on context. Percentages scale.