8 ms·
Seriously, Juice Is Not Healthy
- projektir 8y agoRepeat after me: overeating is unhealthy. What you happen to overeat is beside the point.
- amasad 8y agoThis is demonstrably false. No respectable scientist believes in the calories-in-calories-out model of obesity anymore.
- zaptheimpaler 8y agoGo eat 5000 calories a day of veggies without becoming obese then. Just because calories isn't the only important factor in obesity does not mean its not a factor at all. Scientists are simply building a more sophisticated understanding of obesity that looks at many other factors.
- User23 8y agoI think the post you’re responding to is referring to well established results such as that there is no metabolic pathway to convert dietary protein to adipose tissue. While some dietary protein is glycolysized, that pathway only satisfies immediate energy needs. Excess dietary protein that isn’t used on lean tissue is eliminated by the kidneys.
- zaptheimpaler 8y agoThats interesting.. so does that mean eating a lot of protein cannot make you gain fat? It would just be a tax on your kidneys instead?
- indecisive_user 8y agoWell in practice it would be very tough to over eat on protein alone. Assuming a 2000 calorie diet you'd need to eat over 500g of protein which is roughly 4lbs of chicken breast or 5lbs of tuna. But at that point it would also be quite harmful to the kidneys
- User23 8y agoUnless you’re Dwayne Johnson. Seriously though if you don’t have kidney disease then you really don’t have to worry about protein consumption.
- emodendroket 8y agoI think it may be difficult to eat that much just eating vegetables.
- jakobegger 8y agoEating 5000 calories of veggies is impossible. That's like 25kg of tomatoes or 35kg of lettuce. You can't eat that in a day.
- Gobd 8y agoWhat do they believe in now? I still thought calorie-in/out was the truth. I'd love to see some articles.
- WilliamEdward 8y agoBe wary anytime someone mentions "scientists" in their argument. More than likely OP has no source. Nevertheless, I get his point. Basically, calorie-in/out is still very much used but it doesn't tell the full story. At the end of the day you will gain weight if you eat too many Calories, but eating an apple will make you feel fuller than a chocolate bar, etc. Scientists dont even have a stake in this really it's more like nutritionists, and the jury is out as to whether we can call them scientists.
- benjaminl 8y agoIt is way more complicated than that. The body autonomously regulates the amount of calories that you eat. For example when you exercise more studies show people will eat almost exactly an extra amount of food equalent to the calories exercised. The average person gains an extra 1 to 2 pounds a year. It takes 6,000 calories to gains 2 pounds. This is about ~16.5 calories a day. About a fifth of a slice of bread. This is an imbalance of energy, on a 2000 calorie diet, of less than 1%.
- projektir 8y ago> It is way more complicated than that. The body autonomously regulates the amount of calories that you eat. For example when you exercise more studies show people will eat almost exactly an extra amount of food equalent to the calories exercised. The whole point of something like calorie counting is so that this is no longer some automated, subconscious process.
- projektir 8y agoOK... that is news to me... do you have a link to a paper that proves this demonstrably false? Disproving a law of thermodynamics sounds like a big deal. How does the new model explain people losing weight in adverse conditions? I'm watching someone steadily lose weight via calories-in-calories-out model in front of me right now.
- _bxg1 8y agoObviously calories matter, but there's just so much more going on than that. For example, your body's shifting metabolism. Eating certain things causes this to shift. Some people eat healthy constantly and remain overweight; others can't put on pounds no matter what they take in. That's a difference in their natural metabolisms. This is also why exercise matters beyond just the calories you burn over the course of a workout.
- projektir 8y ago> Obviously calories matter, but there's just so much more going on than that. The purpose of black box perspective is to not worry about the "so much more going on". Regardless of what happens in the box the rules of energy must stay put. As for the human body, the science there is young, it's extremely complex, there's a lot of misinformation, a lot of it was grabbed by governments ("don't eat fat!") to ill effect. Let's not. Just take it easy with the portions. Metabolism shifts are not that large. If you are following CICO, you're counting calories, and that is already an error prone process. There's not a big difference between "my metabolism shifted because of this odd food", "I drank some alcohol", and "I miscounted how much beans I actually had". It's fine, if you have a good enough weekly target and you stick to it, you will have a baseline. If you are not losing weight, reduce the target. It will work. If you are saying it won't I want to see a straight up study that says it put 500 men on a 1500 cal/day diet and they didn't lose weight. Note that I am only talking about the physical angle, not the sociological one. "Juice is not healthy" is, to me, a non-sociological claim, but a scientific one, and I would prefer that "x is unhealthy" means "x is mildly poisonous", not "x is calorie-dense", because there's nothing actually wrong with calorie-density.
- 8y ago
- quest88 8y agoHuh, what do they believe to be true now?
- diab0lic 8y agoCould you please do us the service of demonstrating that it is false? Overeating is unhealthy is demonstrably true.
- rosstex 8y agoRelated: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5496172/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5496172/ https://www.physiology.org/doi/abs/10.1152/ajpendo.00156.2017 https://www.physiology.org/doi/abs/10.1152/ajpendo.00156.201...
- Numberwang 8y agoSeems like it doesn’t matter what scientists say. People still go for stupid things like keto and other weird train wreck diets.
- dangrossman 8y agoSeveral people have asked for sources, so I'd like to point those people to this article, which is an easy-to-digest overview: http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-teicholz-calorie-count-fda-rule-20180520-story.html http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-teicholz-calorie-... It starts with "Since the early 1900s, medical research has shown that people do lose weight on calorie-restricted diets — in the short term. But in most cases, they quickly gain it back..." and goes onto the studies on things that actually do work long-term, like fixing your sleep, fixing your stress, and limiting carbohydrates in your diet.
- DanAndersen 8y ago>But in most cases, they quickly gain it back. So they gain it back once they stop being on calorie-restricted diets? This isn't a surprise to anyone. The point of any of these things, CICO or otherwise, is that you do them for your lifetime as a lifestyle change.
- dangrossman 8y agoWe have a century of evidence that calorie restriction is not a diet people can stay on. I just sourced this above. Calorie restriction alone while eating fast food, soda, cake, etc is a diet of chronic hunger/deprivation, and "become a monk with an iron will until your death" is not a reasonable "lifestyle change" to suggest. That's why "just count calories" is not the advice any respectable scientist would give an obese person, which I believe was @amasad's point.
- maxerickson 8y agoBut to sustain a weight loss you basically do have to eat less, forever. I say this being 60 pounds below my highest weight (200 vs 260). Someone is talking about protein conversion, but I expect it is just harder to eat excess calories of meat. The 2 pounds of beef a day it would take many people to maintain body weight is a lot of beef to sit and eat.
- projektir 8y ago
- gameswithgo 8y agoIt isn't that no one believes in that model of obestity any more. If you locked people in a cage and gave them 1,000 calories of snickers bars a day, yeah they would get lean. But what complicates the situation is that what you eat affects how much you crave food, and what foods you crave, and how much energy you have, and how you sleep, etc. Sugar seems to be bad on all of these ancillary fronts.
- emodendroket 8y agoWell, yeah, exactly. Saying that "consuming fewer calories than you expend leads to weight loss" is obviously true, but it's a little like saying "you win a game of football by scoring more points than your opponent." While it isn't wrong it doesn't tell you that much about how to go about it.
- eloff 8y agoNot the OP, but for all the people commenting below, I think what the OP means to say is that the body is a very complex system and calories from different sources absolutely do have different affects, on your ability to control fat storage and fat burning and to modulate your appetite. The laws of thermodynamics still hold - if you overeat it doesn't matter what you're eating, you will gain weight. But calories in calories out is so simplistic by comparison to reality, that it's a harmful way to look at things.
- jib 8y agoIt is the Newtonian physics of nutrition. It is demonstrably wrong, yet following the rule will lead to success for just about every real life use case.
- knicholes 8y agoYou're really going to have to clarify what you mean by "this." Overeating is healthy?
- emodendroket 8y agoI'd think the part about "what particular foods you eat doesn't matter"
- baal80spam 8y agoThey they shouldn't call themselves respectable.
- mattybrennan 8y agoI mean, this calories in calories out study is in the same NYT issue: "Exercise May Aid in Weight Loss. Provided You Do Enough." https://nyti.ms/2KMz7f9 https://nyti.ms/2KMz7f9
- WilliamEdward 8y agoCalories-in-Calories-out is a straight-up fact. The thing 'scientists' don't like about it is that even if you lose the same amount of weight, where you got your calories from will impact your health differently depending on whether it's a chocolate bar or an apple. Nevertheless, Calories-in-Calories-out is a true model.
- maxxxxx 8y agoVery true. But don't make it the only factor in losing weight. You need to manage amount of food, what you eat and when you eat. They all are important.
- projektir 8y agoImportant in what sense? Important in this context to me would mean: if I don't eat spinach, or if I skip breakfast, I will NOT lose weight on a calorie deficit. Is that what you mean by important what you eat and when you eat, or something else?
- maxxxxx 8y agoLet's assume you eat the same amounts. It makes a difference if you eat in the morning or in the evening. If you eat very late most likely you won't digest as well and you will gain weight. You will always lose weight on a deficit but depending on when you eat the amount for a deficit will be different. Same for the type of food. From my own observation I will gain weight if I eat only a few pretzels daily even if everything else is the same. I assume they cause my digestive system to lose efficiency.
- scarface74 8y agoLet's assume you eat the same amounts. It makes a difference if you eat in the morning or in the evening. If you eat very late most likely you won't digest as well and you will gain weight. That’s considered a myth that’s been debunked ages ago. https://www.webmd.com/diet/features/diet-truth-myth-eating-night-causes-weight-gain https://www.webmd.com/diet/features/diet-truth-myth-eating-n...
- baseethrowaway 8y agoThese works seem to disagree with you. Your turn. Please do try to disprove the law of conservation of energy. Swinburn B, Sacks G, Ravussin E. Increased food energy supply is more than sufficient to explain the US epidemic of obesity . Am J Clin Nutr. (2009) Lack of evidence for high fructose corn syrup as the cause of the obesity epidemic Leibel RL, et al. Energy intake required to maintain body weight is not affected by wide variation in diet composition . Am J Clin Nutr. (1992) Golay A, et al. Similar weight loss with low- or high-carbohydrate diets . Am J Clin Nutr. (1996) Golay A, et al. Weight-loss with low or high carbohydrate diet . Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. (1996) Luscombe-Marsh ND, et al. Carbohydrate-restricted diets high in either monounsaturated fat or protein are equally effective at promoting fat loss and improving blood lipids . Am J Clin Nutr. (2005) Bray GA, et al. Effect of dietary protein content on weight gain, energy expenditure, and body composition during overeating: a randomized controlled trial . JAMA. (2012) Noakes M, et al. Effect of an energy-restricted, high-protein, low-fat diet relative to a conventional high-carbohydrate, low-fat diet on weight loss, body composition, nutritional status, and markers of cardiovascular health in obese women . Am J Clin Nutr. (2005) Keogh JB, et al. Long-term weight maintenance and cardiovascular risk factors are not different following weight loss on carbohydrate-restricted diets high in either monounsaturated fat or protein in obese hyperinsulinaemic men and women . Br J Nutr. (2007) Farnsworth E, et al. Effect of a high-protein, energy-restricted diet on body composition, glycemic control, and lipid concentrations in overweight and obese hyperinsulinemic men and women . Am J Clin Nutr. (2003) Brinkworth GD, et al. Long-term effects of a high-protein, low-carbohydrate diet on weight control and cardiovascular risk markers in obese hyperinsulinemic subjects . Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. (2004) McLaughlin T, et al. Effects of moderate variations in macronutrient composition on weight loss and reduction in cardiovascular disease risk in obese, insulin-resistant adults . Am J Clin Nutr. (2006) Sargrad KR, et al. Effect of high protein vs high carbohydrate intake on insulin sensitivity, body weight, hemoglobin A1c, and blood pressure in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus . J Am Diet Assoc. (2005) Boden G, et al. Effect of a low-carbohydrate diet on appetite, blood glucose levels, and insulin resistance in obese patients with type 2 diabetes . Ann Intern Med. (2005) Heilbronn LK, Noakes M, Clifton PM. Effect of energy restriction, weight loss, and diet composition on plasma lipids and glucose in patients with type 2 diabetes . Diabetes Care. (1999) Parker B, et al. Effect of a high-protein, high-monounsaturated fat weight loss diet on glycemic control and lipid levels in type 2 diabetes . Diabetes Care. (2002) Thomson RL, et al. The effect of a hypocaloric diet with and without exercise training on body composition, cardiometabolic risk profile, and reproductive function in overweight and obese women with polycystic ovary syndrome . J Clin Endocrinol Metab. (2008) Strasser B, Spreitzer A, Haber P. Fat loss depends on energy deficit only, independently of the method for weight loss . Ann Nutr Metab. (2007) Astrup A, Meinert Larsen T, Harper A. Atkins and other low-carbohydrate diets: hoax or an effective tool for weight loss . Lancet. (2004) Golay A, et al. Similar weight loss with low-energy food combining or balanced diets . Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. (2000)
- emodendroket 8y agoWell, it isn't really beside the point, since some foods give you calories without making you feel full or even while making you hungrier -- for instance, juice, according to this article..
- projektir 8y agoIt's beside the point in the evaluation of unhealthiness. Something making you hungry doesn't make it unhealthy. For people who can drink juice, but not overeat, it poses likely no special threat (and if it does, it will be hard to find that out in the current climate of calling calorie dense foods unhealthy).
- emodendroket 8y agoSince the article mostly talks about parents giving their children juice, I doubt a really nuanced view of juice intake is being followed.
- eagsalazar2 8y agoyou are like 10 years late to this conversation.
- projektir 8y agoI wish, still seems relevant as ever and I sense we're going to make full circle on this one a few more times.
- startupdiscuss 8y agoOk, what if you carbonate juice, add ginger, and call it Kombucha? Is it healthy now?
- spectrum1234 8y agoKombucha usually has way less sugar though. I get the brands that have 4-6grams of sugar per serving.
- gameswithgo 8y agois it replaced in part by alcohol though?
- User23 8y agodefinition of fermentation.
- emodendroket 8y agoThere are small amounts of alcohol in juice too.
- throwaway5752 8y agoIf you've ever tried kombucha, it's pretty obvious the ethanol has been metabolized to acetic acid.
- HankB99 8y agoThat was going to be my suggestion. But I was thinking along the lines of orange juice, pomegranate juice and some tequila. Another interesting combo is OJ, pineapple juice, pomegranate, coconut rum and regular rum.
- throwaway5752 8y agoNo, but it's also not kombucha...
- IncRnd 8y agoExcept that carbonated juice with ginger is not Kombucha. Kombucha is a fermented beverage. When fermented, sugars break down, hence the saying that Kombucha is vinegar soda.
- godzillabrennus 8y agoSugar is bad. Juice has a lot of sugar.
- projektir 8y agoCalories are bad. Sugar is very calorie dense. [I'm on the lookout for direct sugar-specifically-is-bad studies so I hope to get spammed with some]
- thatthatis 8y agoNot a study but a theory: Sugar causes a blood sugar roller coaster with an energy crash at 2-3 hours that appears to be specifically designed to get us to over eat. In nature sugar exists in large quantities only during the short period of fruit being in season, and thus it makes sense there would be a mechanism to get us to over eat during the limited window of fruit availability. Sugar triggers our “eat it before it rots” mechanism.
- emmanuel_1234 8y agoThat's a wrong argument. Sugar is three times less calorie dense than fat. (that's not an argument for sugar or against fat, just a fact).
- JshWright 8y agoHere's some context on the authors: https://twitter.com/aaronecarroll/status/1015682328411230208 https://twitter.com/aaronecarroll/status/1015682328411230208
- throwaway080383 8y agoDoes anyone else have about a 40% success rate on clicking Twitter links? Maybe I'm rate-limited because I don't have an account, but the level of reliability I see clicking a few links a day isn't exactly compelling.
- jwilk 8y agoWhat do you mean by "success rate on clicking Twitter links"?
- jakobegger 8y agoLinks to twitter often show an error message instead of the tweet.
- jakobegger 8y agoLinks from HN seem to be broken generally. Clicking refresh works for me.
- iforgotpassword 8y agoI'm getting "twitter takes too long to load" instead of the tweet half the time on mobile. Then I have to refresh to see the tweet. My browser has to load 90 JavaScript files totaling in 20 gigabytes to display a 140 character string and fails along the way. And all the engineering brains at twitter couldn't make it so that it would just try again on its own. It's like they're trying to convince people to stay away from the platform.
- kareemm 8y agoI love the strange looks we get when we tell extended family that our 1.5y old and 4y old kids don't drink juice. I had this exact conversation with a cousin of mine last week. She checked in with me before giving my child juice. When I told her we didn't give our kids juice this is how the conversation went: Q: "They don't drink juice? What do they drink?" A: "Water." Q: "Just water?" A: "Yep. If you want to get fancy they also drink soda water or water with lemon." She looked judgy and baffled at how hard-ass my wife and I were about juice. But juice is straight calories in the form of sugar. There's no fibre to slow absorption like you'd get with eating the whole fruit. It's not much better, calorically speaking, than soda. And in addition to being unhealthy, having young kids wired on sugar also makes our life harder.
- schmichael 8y agoMy only difference is prune juice. Because my 2.5yo has only had other juices a couple of times, he thinks prune juice is a huge treat. I give him 2-3oz as a quick and easy source of fiber to promote regularity which is rrrreally helpful when potty training (side note: parenting is sooo dignified).
- sm64 8y agoTo add, the "no sugar added" thing is wholly misleading because there are fruit concentrates that companies can add that are basically sugar substitutes. It's technically not "sugar added" but it's basically filled with healthy dollop of fructose (which is worse than sucrose but I'm too lazy to cite a reference).
- forgotpwagain 8y agoGrape juice is the notorious one here. It doesn't have a very strong taste on its own, so when blended basically serves as a not-technically-added-sugar source of added sugar.
- gnicholas 8y agoI recently saw a ginger-flavored carbonated that boasted of the percent juice. I was surprised by the number (30%?), and when I looked at the ingredients I saw that the juice was not mostly ginger. It was grape juice. I understand that when I see “cranberry cocktail”, there’s a bunch of sweet juice mixed in. I didn’t realize that drinks of other flavors have so much clandestine grape juice — which is basically sugar.
- novaRom 8y agoWhy not to eat just fruits? Why a kind of juice is necessary?
- nine_k 8y agoJuice is way easier to preserve. Also, less messy to consume. If apples or oranges can last a week in a basket, grapes, or peaches, or many other fruit would not. So it's easy to convince yourself that juice is almost like the fruit, or at least lets you feel some of its pleasant taste. Like many things, it's higher concentration than our bodies are naturally adapted to, so it's easy to over-consume (a pint instead of a half a cup).
- maxxxxx 8y agoIt seems people are trained to believe that food always needs some kind of processing. I often eat raw bell peppers and tomato pieces at work and judging from the comments people seem to never even have thought of that as possibility. Right now the best are bottled teas like "Honest Tea" for $3 a pop at lunch. You can get something much better by buying some nice tea and brewing it yourself. And it probably costs only 5 cents instead of $3.
- projektir 8y agoFor me it's raw broccoli. Most people seem to think it's supposed to be bitter raw and I am still rather confused about that since broccoli is not bitter at all to me.
- westiseast 8y agoBecause juice tastes good. Fruit tastes good, and juice is a 10x more cool, watery, refreshing, and sweet. Anyone who says chugging a half litre of cold apple juice after a long run isn’t heaven on earth is dead inside.
- Puer 8y agoNext, let's dispel the notion that fat is bad for you. It's the strangest thing to me to see parents feeding their kids "skim milk", which is really just milk flavored water, because whole milk "has fat" and therefore must make their children fat. I only drank whole milk as a kid. A glass with every meal. My parents never bought any juice or soda and me and all of my siblings grew up healthy and strong with no cavities or health issues. It makes me cringe seeing overweight children glugging down sodas, but it makes me equally sad seeing horribly skinny children who's bones could be broken by the wind.
- alphabettsy 8y agoThere’s some evidence to suggest milk isn’t really good for you either
- JshWright 8y agoAnd basically no evidence that it's good for you. Here's a great video on the topic from one of the co-authors of this article: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzyFZcuHmeI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzyFZcuHmeI
- throwaway5752 8y agoThat's simply not true about skim milk. It has just as much protein and calcium as whole milk. Maybe you and your siblings would have been even healthier with skim, maybe not, but it's not possible to deduce anything from your experience.
- Puer 8y agoSkim milk typically doesn't contain vitamin A and fat is essential for helping our bodies absorb the vitamins and nutrients we consume. Plus, as a source of energy and calories, fat is much better than sugar for children because it takes longer to break down which aids diet regulation. The article talks about this, but the reason it's so easy to binge on snack foods like juice is because they don't make you feel full and so you continue eating. Similarly, you'll feel much fuller if you drink whole milk versus skim milk, which is great for children who can't control impulses very well.
- phs318u 8y agoFor breakfast, my wife and I squeeze a single grapefruit and single orange (the old fashioned, manual and unfiltered way, keeping any "bits") and split and drink that. It's not much to look at - a little over half a short glass each. Basically we have the juice and some of the fibre from a single piece of fruit each. If you think about how much fruit it takes to create a 600ml bottle of juice its crazy. If you couldn't stomach eating half a dozen oranges in a sitting, why would you think that drinking that much juice at a time (sometimes multiple times a day) would be good for you?
- forapurpose 8y agoSerious question: Why not eat the grapefruit and/or orange? That seems like less work, more food, and healthier (and personally I think it tastes better, but YMMV).
- phs318u 8y agoFair question. I agree that the fruit itself tastes nicer. I could say I want to avoid having too much fibre (as I get plenty from other sources), but in reality I just find peeling oranges a PITA and contrary to your claim I find it quicker to cut in half and twist each half a few times on a juicer (plus I can just knock back the output).
- forapurpose 8y ago> I just find peeling oranges a PITA You know, I've almost forgotten about this problem. Buy clementines; they are a kind of orange which happen to be easy to peel. For more ease, at the store you can feel which ones have looser skin; it's no exaggeration that they are easier to peel than plastic wrappers off of processed food. They don't even make a mess - no dripping, no sticky fingers, etc. I can't recommend them enough - one of the wonders of nature, or of selective breeding.
- thirdsun 8y agoNo we only need a proper way to eat grapefruits. Love the fruit, hate the mess that is preparing/eating them.
- code_duck 8y agoSeems like a drastic way to say like that juice is not as healthy as eating fruit, and is not a substitute for solid fruit. Also that it has a lot of sugar. When you see this headline, you’d think they might be including fresh squeeze juice from a variety of fruits and vegetables. They seem to only be talking about things like Coca-Cola’s Minute Maid and Walmart apple juice that the average American feeds their children. I thought they might be talking about juice bars. It makes me wonder, have the authors ever heard about the gigantic national trend of drinking fresh juice? Because they don’t seem to be referring to it at all. I don’t know why they don’t suggest that you could give your kids less sugary juice, fresh squeeze juice, orange juice from things other than oranges, grapes or apples. One thing they don’t seem to realize is that many parents give their kids HFCS soda pop. I could think of many parents who believe the only reason to not give their children mountain dew is the caffeine. It is a little healthier to give them juice. Especially the 100% fruit juice they’re condemning, which is a better grade even than most juice on the shelves. I would agree that the pasteurized, filtered, old sugary juices sold in plastic bottles in grocery stores are not very healthy. But they contain far fewer enzymes and vitamins and fiber than fresh squeezed juice. Maybe they should recommend that parents buy a juicer, and give their kids diluted juice that also includes vegetables in addition to sweet fruit. Personally, I have been on a very restricted diet, mainly liquids all year. I don’t have been drinking fresh squeezed juice to solve my caloric deficit, but don’t binge on it or buy store juice because it’s clear to me that the main component is sugar and I don’t want to tempt type 2 diabetes. I’d much rather eat the whole fruits and vegetables if I could, but in the meantime, it’s hard to believe that the juice of 5 apples, a bunch of chard, a beet, 2 carrots, a stick of ginger and some celery would harm me or children.
- indecisive_user 8y ago> it’s hard to believe that the juice of 5 apples, a bunch of chard, a beet, 2 carrots, a stick of ginger and some celery would harm me or children. Is this what each person gets or what you share with your children? That juice alone would contain around 100g of sugar, which regardless of where it comes from would be a lot for a single person, especially considering it won't be their only source of sugar in a day. The problem with juices is that they're very easy to consume compared to their whole food counterpart and keep you full for a shorter time. I'm not sure exactly what definition you're using for fresh squeezed juice, but if you're not using the whole fruit then you're likely losing a lot of the fiber that makes whole fruit healthier
- darkstar999 8y agoIt seems like this article assumes fruit juice. For breakfast I make juice with kale (a bunch), a cucumber, carrots, and an apple. It's a lot healthier than most other American breakfasts.
- driverdan 8y agoHow much sugar is in it?
- burntrelish1273 8y agoI'm continually amazed when people make obviously horrible assumptions: - "Weed is good because it's 'natural'" "Yeah, but so are ricin, hemlock and nightshade." - "Juice is made from fruit, fruit is good, therefore juice must be good." "Although it's not HFCS, juice has more carbs than soda."
- User23 8y agoI'm also disgusted by the "it's natural" platitude some persons spout. But that doesn't mean it's a good idea to drink the latest clinically unproven science experiment like, for example, Coke Zero. Nobody has a clue what those small molecules actually do besides the obvious.
- ofrzeta 8y agoI had that discussion several times. Last time I was told that apple juice is less healthy than apples because of the fibres (missing in the juice). After I have done some "research" on my own I found out that 100g Apple only contains 1g of fiber, so I guess the difference can't be that huge. In animal testing it was found that mice who ate a diet that included apples had up to 50 percent less tumors. Now the exact same effect was achieved by giving them apple juice, with non-filtered apple juice being more effective, supposedly due to a higher concentration of Procyanidins.
- emodendroket 8y agoTry making some fresh juice and see how many apples it takes to make a glass of apple juice
- thatthatis 8y agoCloser to 2.5g-3g Fiber. The major effect isn’t how much fiber, but that the sugar is trapped in a matrix of fiber and water. Your digestive system has to tear away the outer layers to get to the sugar, this slows the absorption of the sugar and reduces the glycemic index. In juice the matrix has been mechanically separated so the glycemic effect is almost exactly the same as eating ten spoonfuls of white sugar.
- ofrzeta 8y agoWhat about the difference between Fructose, Sucrose and Glucose? Fruit usually has a quite high ratio of Fructose as far as I know. Does it matter? It doesn't even get mentioned in the article.