6 ms·
> A quality hiring process would know with at least a 50% confidence level that the person is worth hiring before bringing them in for the onsite. After having
by dahart 8y ago
> A quality hiring process would know with at least a 50% confidence level that the person is worth hiring before bringing them in for the onsite.
After having done a decent amount of hiring interviews and managing in my life, I don't think it's possible to have 50% confidence before you meet someone. The way you gain that much confidence is by 1- talking and listening to them, and 2- comparing them to other candidates.
> I'd still expect them to achieve their results with fewer than 3, and preferably fewer than 2 onsites per hire.
This seems hyper-focused on the minor efficiencies of interviewing, at the expense of employment efficiency; it's feels like an engineering approach that might not have all the requirements at hand.
The employee is (probably) going to be paid a six figure salary, and will have a large impact on the team. Great candidates can improve the efficiency of the people around them for years and years. Bad candidates can slow entire teams down. I've watched some excellent and prolific and opinionated engineers do major productivity damage -- millions of dollars worth, and I've watched some young CS graduates outlearn and outperform some veterans. Resumes & github accounts simply don't have enough information to know whether a candidate can help your company.
In my experience, it has been worth the time to let the hiring process go slow enough to be able to compare people's personalities, and not just their on-paper engineering credentials.
I think far too many engineers here on HN and out in the workforce dramatically underestimate how important attitude and people skills are in the hiring process, and dramatically over-estimate how important specific math & programming skills are.
- mchannon 8y agoOn the last point we agree, but you're missing the main point here. Videoconferencing and phone calls can take care of not all but a large measure of the personality issues that can crop up. Many a brogrammer ends up wasting an onsite by skipping this step when the candidate could have saved them both the trouble, had they just taken the 5 minutes to have a Hangout. The efficiencies of interviewing are anything but minor, and I find it odd how the wrong six-figure hire is bandied about but the existing 2-six-figure manager spending half his workweek interviewing nonhires instead of working is overlooked.
- dahart 8y ago> Videoconferencing and phone calls can take care of not all but a large measure of the personality issues that can crop up. You seem to be making large assumptions and arguing straw man issues. What makes you think that both the author and I don’t use videoconferencing or phone calls? I didn’t say anything about it, and the article mentioned screening calls right at the top; literally the 4th sentence. > I find it odd how the wrong six-figure hire is bandied about but the existing 2-six-figure manager Please explain. What’s “wrong” about my suggestion that an engineer will “probably” make something near six figures? Average salary for all engineering in the US is north of $85k. The average engineering manager salary is around ~$130k. > spending half his workweek interviewing nonhires instead of working You seem to be assuming that the manager is always interviewing, as opposed to, say, filling a few positions, working without hiring for a few months, filling a few more positions. The guy in the article is a recruiter, so recruiting is his full time job. If a normal engineering manager has other work, then recruiting isn’t their full time job, and they might not be hiring at all times. I haven’t ever worked in a department that was constantly hiring, neither in startups nor in huge global companies. Have you? Suggesting that the cost of interviewing a dozen people is larger than the cost of employing one not-so-great engineer seems, from my perspective, to be off the mark.
- mchannon 8y ago> What makes you think that both the author and I don’t use videoconferencing or phone calls? Maybe it would help if you understood it as "use [enough] videoconferencing or phone calls". Answering that question: For the author, the aforementioned 5X ratio. For you, your apparent insistence that a) you have to talk and listen to them, but b) this somehow has to take place in person to get to 50% confidence. Maybe that's true for you, but I doubt it's universally so. > What’s “wrong” about my suggestion I think you parsed my sentence incorrectly. "wrong" modified "six-figure hire", as in, the wrong guy who costs six-figures. > I haven’t ever worked in a department that was constantly hiring, neither in startups nor in huge global companies. Have you? Oh yeah. It's more like everyone had two full-time jobs, and one of them was 30 hours a week of interviewing. > Suggesting that the cost of interviewing a dozen people is larger than the cost of employing one not-so-great engineer seems, from my perspective, to be off the mark. Let's try from my perspective. Say you hire a not-so-great engineer, who's maybe worth $100k, for $90k. A great engineer would be worth $1M, for $90k. Both are wins. O that it were only a dozen people. Say it was 5 hours a week of wasted interviews, for 50 weeks, and the interviewer earns $100k. This puts a loss of >$10k onto your bottom line, neglecting the "real work" the interviewer could be doing, and the other employees also doing the same thing. A low win beats any loss.
- tchaffee 8y agoAs another person with some experience with hiring, I agree with you fully. To put one of your points in my own words, your engineers are going to be spending the majority of their waking hours with this new person five days a week. Take the time to make sure it's a good fit.
- mchannon 8y agoAs yet another person with some experience with hiring, let's not get theory and practice confused. Taking the time to make sure it's a good fit is a worthy goal, but the industry is operating under some kind of delusion that there's a Ballmer Peak (http://xkcd.com/323/ http://xkcd.com/323/) to interviewing people somewhere between the 4th and 5th hour of the onsite interview. Returns start diminishing very quickly after the first five minutes. This is why multiple people earlier in the process are necessary.
- tchaffee 8y ago> Returns start diminishing very quickly after the first five minutes. That's the opposite of a scientific approach. One of the best things I ever learned from an experienced interviewer is the spend the rest of the interview trying to disprove your first impression. Anything else is an exercise in confirmation bias. I'm not saying that I've never ended an interview early when it's obvious there is a bad fit. My time is important and so is other people's time.
- mchannon 8y agoA scientific approach is to pose a theory (this candidate would make a good hire) and perform a measurement (whoa, this guy's good) and then perhaps perform the measurement again, without bias, to see if the measurement is consistent and reproducible. What you're suggesting is to spend the next several hours performing additional measurements in the hopes of finding one contrary to your first measurement. That is precisely the opposite of science. It's also how casinos stay in business.
- 8y ago