3 ms·
it is be appropriate Typos of this sort make me wonder how clearly the man is thinking. That's perhaps unfair, but that's what crosses my mind when I read some
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
it is be appropriate
Typos of this sort make me wonder how clearly the man is thinking. That's perhaps unfair, but that's what crosses my mind when I read something like this and on top of the general craziness of the position, it has gibberish of this sort in it.
The post rants a lot about justice, but I am failing to see where in this rant he allows for the ability of people creating videos to get compensation at all. This seems to posit that a streaming service just shouldn't exist, period. The assumption that end users have all these rights, but creators apparently have none -- that's basically the very definition of slavery, no?
A lot of these things he is protesting were created as some attempt to try to capture compensation for the people doing the work that makes it possible for the end user to get all the things Stallman is claiming is some kind of right of end users.
I'm not comfortable with the moralizing language here. I think we need to do a better job of making sure people can get their share of the wealth that they participate in creating, not because of morality or justice, but because when (for example) Amazon employees are homeless while Bezos is insanely wealthy, this is basically preconditions for bloody revolution. When the people you need to create that wealth hate you for how you treat them, this is not a good thing going good places.
It isn't that I think it is "immoral" for Bezos to make that kind of money. It's that I think he's a fool to think that bleeding his workers won't come back to bite him. When their behavior was objectionable enough, even Roman emperors were sometimes offed by the very guard unit intended to protect them.
There's an old DnD concept of "lawful awful." This is where you try to play an alignment 1 Lawful Good character who is so "good" and so rigid about various rules that they wrap all the way around to behaving like a Lawful Evil. This post sounds a bit like to me.
I have a fair amount of respect for the fact that he believed in certain principles enough to put his own time and effort into creating open source alternatives to the proprietary things he felt were inherently in the wrong. And it's fine if he doesn't want to watch Netflix and wants to layout his reasoning for it. But this post veers into trying to tell other people to also embargo Netflix. What I am not seeing is his proposed alternative. And that's a difference here between his past willingness to write the code and make it open source because he felt that mattered and this current rant.
If you have a viable alternative to Netflix that fits your high-minded morals, awesome. If all you have is a rant about how this thing is not good enough, I think that should stay in the land of personal opinion or personal preference and not veer into territory of trying to use his position of influence to get other people to embargo them.