8 ms·
Deere suit sheds light on race for $240B farm tech market
- oedenfield 8y agoFarmers have historically benefited little from advancement in technology and this is no exception. If I think I'm worth more than my employer is paying me, I can shop my services around for a higher bidder. And while the concept is true for a farmer's output/services in reality most farmers (I grew up on a small family farm) have little choice but to sell at the price the local market will give them. Likewise they have to buy input goods (seed, fertilizer, breeding stock, etc.) at the price others choose. Holding output product is often not an option as banks (and other bills) need paid and food needs to be on the table. I'm thankful for a fairly healthy (by comparison) tech market.
- salawat 8y agoThat's just not true. Farmer's have benefited MASSIVELY. Go try breaking some ground without a Rototiller, or tractor. Harvest crops by hand. Or go ahead and seed by hand. Oh! Don"t forget to weed! And you might want to fertilize as well. The thing is there is only the IMPRESSION the farmer doesn't benefit from tech. Modern "Tech" I.e. software is no exception. The reality is the farmer has to cope with the realities of physical constraints, and learns how to deal with things in a way that requires minimal input. They acquire an economy of action. "Tech" today wouldn't understand the notion if it slapped them in the face. "Lets make another thing to do a thing, so THIS thing is justified/monetized." Ask a Farmer if or why they don't collect metrics on all their customers. If they aren't industrial, answer is easy. More important things to do. You can learn a lot from the guys and gals who grow your food. I certainly have. The value you can get out of not doing things you don't need to can be quite large.
- randomdata 8y agoGrain farmer here: > Farmers have historically benefited little from advancement in technology and this is no exception. I think I have benefitted massively from technology. As a sixth generation farmer on my family's land, I expect I do not make any more money (inflation adjusted, of course) on the farm than my forefathers did. I believe this is where your concern lies. However, they spent the entire year working on the farm. I can do all the work in a few weeks, thanks to technology. That also allows me to have a career in the tech industry. Being able to have everything they did and a tech salary is a huge gain! > most farmers (I grew up on a small family farm) have little choice but to sell at the price the local market will give them Western Canada, for instance, had a wheat/barley pool until a few years ago where you had to put your product – by law – into the pool and receive whatever price the pool was able to market your grain at. But these kind of programs are pretty much long gone in 2018. In America, which seems to be the main audience of HN, there was never such a thing. Subsidies are the preferred way to support farmers. Not knowing where you are from, you may still have such a system, but generally that is not the case. For me, different buyers, even within the local market, will pay more or less depending on what they plan to do with the product, and will generally negotiate price. And, of course, I can ship my product outside of the local market if an even better deal is found elsewhere. > Likewise they have to buy input goods (seed, fertilizer, breeding stock, etc.) at the price others choose. This is the same as every other business in existence, however. All sales require negotiation. If the offer made by the seller is not acceptable to any buyers, the seller will make no sales and will be quickly compelled to reduce their next offer. > I'm thankful for a fairly healthy (by comparison) tech market. Uncompetitive is the word you are looking for, I believe. Everything you mentioned before is a result of farming being very competitive. I might even suggest the most competitive industry in the world. Tech is not very competitive, relatively speaking. When it comes to labour, there are not a lot of people to go around, and intellectual property laws limit how many vendors can offer the same product.
- olivierlacan 8y agoDid you write more about this somewhere? I feel like an AMA would be very interesting to read. My mother’s side of the family comes from a very rural area where they farmed on a very small scale so I’ve always eyed the technological efficiency gains in agriculture with a very curious eye considering how much back-breaking labor they still have to do.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ars 8y ago> there was never such a thing Not exactly the same thing, but onions have a special place in the law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onion_Futures_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onion_Futures_Act
- gooderdle 8y ago> Farmers have historically benefited little from advancement in technology and this is no exception. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Revolution
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- digitalzombie 8y agoThe cotton gin advance farmers and arguably extended slavery in America. So yeah... That's the one example my US history teacher gave me in slavery and technology. We don't exactly have dust bowl anymore or the Irish Potato Famine. Crop rotation is actually a thing since at least the Aztec.
- amoshi 8y ago>Unfortunately, our website is currently unavailable in most European countries. We are engaged on the issue and committed to looking at options that support our full range of digital offerings to the EU market. We continue to identify technical compliance solutions that will provide all readers with our award-winning journalism. Nice - "get tracked or fuck off" approach.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tomp 8y agoYeah this is hilarious to me. If they offered an ASCII-only version of their website, they (1) wouldn't be losing any revenue (i.e. they're making zero right now on Europeans anyways), and (2) they wouldn't be losing any reputation ("a publishing company firmly stuck in the 19th century").
- rgbrenner 8y agoBut then they might have data on you in their logs.. and may need to service removal requests (even if its just to say they dont have anything). So that would just open a can of worms. The Chicago Tribute is a small paper in chicago. They've lost zero reputation here.. since their user base is in chicago. Be honest: how much information about Chicago do you want to read? This article isn't even theirs -- it's syndicated from Bloomberg. Go click on their homepage.. you want to read about the local protest? Or the restaurant downtown? Are you interested in the list of great ice cream places in Chicago? Are you ever going to pay them for a subscription?
- voxadam 8y agoA better link, one that's not blocked in European countries: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-06-20/deere-suit-sheds-light-on-race-for-240-billion-farm-tech-market https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-06-20/deere-sui...
- jessaustin 8y agoI had looked for that one, because that was what got syndicated in the little local farmer paper in which I first saw this. However, after 5 minutes in DDG I just took the top result that mentioned that Deere is alleging infringement for work done by a firm it had previously attempted to purchase. I thought that was a notable detail...
- vasili111 8y agoWhy is it blocked in European countries?
- KozmoNau7 8y agoBecause they don't understand how GDPR applies to them, or they don't want to respect their users' privacy.
- chriswitts 8y agoThanks for that, it's also blocked in South Africa, which is pretty damn far from Europe. I suspect they just block anything non-NA.
- mistrial9 8y agoCan we recall for a moment, that more than 70% of the continental US population lived on farms or in rural areas, not much more than 100 years ago. The crush of humanity to the cities, and the concentration of capital in farming, is very much a huge experiment. There is nothing in capitalism that says that humans have to live, or enjoy life, or said another way, the drives of capital take over even common sense things. Secondly, wafting around some huge number of dollars for a market cap is getting pretty close to (WS:WEASEL) weasel words.. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style/Words_to_watch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style/Word...
- hirundo 8y agoThis is an evergreen story. Regulations sold as weapons for davids to defend against goliaths are instead used by goliaths to fend off davids. It turns out that Goliath can learn to use a sling too, and can hurl bigger stones with it. This is why goliaths like regulations so much, and why patents may be more disease than cure.
- nerdponx 8y agoIt's like mandating a certain minimum stone mass, arguing that small stones are ineffective projectiles, and that we need to help stop people from getting scammed by unscrupulous stone vendors. But in reality all it does is make it so that only giants can use slingshots effectively.
- ethn 8y agoIt's refreshing to see such critical thought on HN; it's too often that the intent and aesthetic is of more concern than the consequences.
- hammock 8y agoThe real problem is when one's intent and focus is to create certain consequences (at a macro level)...inevitably it doesn't work (it may still work at a micro level), as evidenced by the analysis of actual consequences you are pointing at. Better to act according to a set of principles, consequences be damned--or blessed as the case may be. Cf. Taleb's ideas on inductive reasoning/enduring conservative philosophy over deductive reasoning, etc
- ethn 8y agoI understand and agree with the overall stirrings of your comment, but it's not necessarily relevant in this case. Taleb is about making choices in uncertainty where it's a reiteration of Biblical, Aquinas, Augustine of Hippo, Berkeley, Kant, Ricoeur, Geertz, and Eliade philosophy. It's no question that given an uncertain circumstance, one should stick to a framework that works independent of circumstance, a categorical imperative framework. In this case I am sure that the concern is almost always on the intent of individuals rather than the consequences. I'm sure you can find your own examples of this, it would be more difficult for me to guess which examples you would agree have had negative consequences but good intent. Regardless, consequences can be deduced with good analysis: for instance physics has done such a tremendous analysis from deductive reasoning on the universe that I am able to communicate to you right now. In regards to Taleb using only inductive reasoning over deductive reasoning: I hope not. Inductive reasoning is even controversial among logicians to be a reasoning at all, it's a weak logical intuition. Deduction is much more powerful, even Taleb argues for his non-novel idea of a categorical imperative, in the same way religions (and all the philosophers I listed) have, given that no circumstantial framework always works because circumstances change, we are forced to find a framework that is irrelevant to dynamic environment. The reasoning to choose a categorical framework at all is deductive. Taleb shouldn't be seen as a tool to justify cowering from rational analysis but instead the justification for favoring morality and epistemology over utilitarianism.
- wcchandler 8y agoI’m pretty interested in a lot of AgTech. While I like to see these pieces as it justifies my interest, it reminds me you can’t escape capitalism and everyone is going to try to make a dime off of you. As such, I feel like I’ll only be able to take my projects seriously if they’re funded or vested by an incubator or VC who is equally benevelont or altruistic. I’m even contemplating going for a PhD just so a large university would be willing to handle this burden. Farmers are always thought of as the humble, true “American” figure. The idea that hard work pays off. But I’ll be damned if it’s not rife with more corruption than any other industry.
- dreamcompiler 8y ago> its machine has far more lines of computer coding than a space shuttle. This kind of comparison is ridiculous. It's like saying "Niagara Falls produces far more water per second than a kitchen faucet." Well of course it does. The computing power of a space shuttle is laughably tiny in comparison to an Arduino, which is itself a tiny computer by modern standards. Does the general public not know this?
- benjaminsuch 8y agoThe computing power of a space shuttle is laughably tiny in comparison to an Arduino Is that so? I'm actually surprised and yes I did not know this. Do you have something to read about that? Sounds interesting.
- rhcom2 8y agoSome quick research tells me: Arduino: 8 million instructions per second IBM System/4 Pi: 480,000 instructions per second
- jcranmer 8y agoPeople tend to overestimate the actual complexity of code for a space shuttle; it's rocket science, therefore it must be some sort of complex black magic. Most of the space shuttle is going to boil down to control theory. The code for a control system essentially looks like this: while (true) { readInputs(); smoothInputs(); computeUserDesiredSetpoints(); adjustVariablesToHitSetpoints(); makeActuatorsMove(); } These functions are not computationally challenging. Even the complex mathematics boils down to "evaluate this function", and you can often get away without needing high precision if you have a feedback mechanism that can adjust for systematic error. There's also a lot of leeway on how simple or complex you can make the user direction: it is far more complex to implement a "perform a translunar injection orbit" than it is to say "burn thrusters at X heading at Y thrust for Z seconds" (think the difference between self-driving cars and cruise control).
- noonespecial 8y ago
- billysielu 8y agoI thought it was going to be some sort of farming iron man.
- rl3 8y agoSame. Though instead of an arc reactor it'd probably run on ethanol.
- ourmandave 8y agoIn its patent-infringement complaints, filed June 1 in federal court in Wilmington, Delaware, Deere said the combination of AGCO unit Precision Planting's vSet seed meters and SpeedTube seed-delivery system infringes 12 patents related to Deere's ExactEmerge, which allows farmers more accurate seed placement and spacing while planting at higher speeds. Getting flashbacks to Apple's infringement claim based on it's patent for rectangles with rounded corners.
- dragonwriter 8y agoApple's case was a design patent case, this is a utility patent. The two are quite different.
- onetimemanytime 8y ago>>“There must be sufficient difference in the technology, or else Deere wouldn’t have wanted to acquire it in the first place." Or just to kill a competitor for next to nothing ($190 mil.) Together they have 80+% market share This is the way it should be: well financed competitors fighting each other in courts, not a farmer vs John Deere.
- specialist 8y agoThere's some cliche about two wolves deciding how split the lamb...
- jessaustin 8y agoAs long as AGCO sells retrofits that give old, completely-depreciated planters the performance of new planters, they are firmly on the farmers' side.