4 ms·
> How could we make different choices? By exercising our free will. By having the courage to stand up and say, "Yeah, I get that we have a huge investment in
by lisper 8y ago
> How could we make different choices?
By exercising our free will. By having the courage to stand up and say, "Yeah, I get that we have a huge investment in Perl code, but Perl really sucks so how about we do this new project in Python instead? Or Scheme? Or Common Lisp?" Or, "Yeah, I get that we can get it done faster by doing it in Java, but that will incur a huge amount of technical debt, and also make it so that the really cool kids, the ones who get why Java sucks, won't want to work for us. So how about we make an investment in our future and try Clojure or Scala or Rust instead?" If enough people do that, eventually one of these overtures will get a green light. Whatever organization does that first will eventually accrue a competitive advantage, and that will in the fullness of time change the dynamic.
But it won't happen if no one even tries.
- tchaffee 8y ago> By exercising our free will. By having the courage to stand up and say Did you miss the part of my comment where I said I gave up Java and C++ for reasons of code quality? That was well over 15 years ago. I am doing my part actually. I've had the "courage" to talk to management countless times in my career about what I think the best choices would be to improve quality. I don't even think it takes courage. It's just a conversation and attempt to sell an idea. Happens all the time in business. Do you think my description of the challenges around getting change to happen were more accurate than the parent's "the belief that this is futile is a self-fulfilling prophecy."? I hardly think my comment claims it's futile when I concluded with being hopeful that change has and is happening.
- lisper 8y ago> Did you miss the part of my comment where I said I gave up Java and C++ for reasons of code quality? No, but the bulk of your comment sounded pretty defeatist to me: "These choices are rarely made by developers" "No one ever got fired for using Java" "Where is the opportunity for us to make different choices?" "It does seem like my own personal choice to give up on Java has had zero effect on its popularity." It's true: a single person's decision to stand up against the system is unlikely to have an effect. But if everyone makes that choice, it will have an effect. And that is more likely to happen if more people stand up and say that you should make that choice rather than whine about they tried and failed.
- tchaffee 8y agoBeing realistic about what you are up against is not defeatist. Is there anything I mentioned that's not a realistic assessment? Is it me that's negative, or is it the actual situation? And I also mentioned where I think the promising opportunities are coming from.
- lisper 8y agoRealism and defeatism are not mutually exclusive. That's the thing about self-fulfilling prophecies: if you believe in them, then they are actually true.
- tchaffee 8y agoYou haven't yet answered any of my questions. Since this doesn't seem like a conversation but more like you trying to take my comments in the most ungenerous way possible, I'm going to stop here. But if you want to answer some of my questions and discuss the massive challenges around changing the global dev culture I'll be happy to continue.
- lisper 8y ago> You haven't yet answered any of my questions. That's because you're asking the wrong questions. "Is there anything I mentioned that's not a realistic assessment? Is it me that's negative, or is it the actual situation?" Those are the wrong questions. The answers to those questions don't get you any closer to a solution to the problem. They only get you to the conclusion that the situation is hopeless and that you should give up. OK, you want an answer? It is both you and the situation that is negative. But the reason that the situation is negative is because of people like you who have decided that the situation is negative and that the only reasonable thing to do is to give up. And you know what? You're right. That is the only reasonable thing to do. Which means that the only way to solve the problem is to be a little unreasonable and carry on despite the fact that it makes no sense. That's why I'm doing things like this: https://github.com/rongarret/ergolib https://github.com/rongarret/ergolib