3 ms·
I surely may be wrong in my prediction, but the thing I'm most fascinated about by these libertarian settlement plans is when they organically reintroduce all t
by Waterluvian 8y ago
I surely may be wrong in my prediction, but the thing I'm most fascinated about by these libertarian settlement plans is when they organically reintroduce all the government systems they wanted to escape in the first place.
Child me was always excited for the day I could break away from the government (parents) and spend all my money on vices like snacks and video games. College me did that and learned the hard way what adult me now practices: a responsible need for the restrictions my parents imposed upon me.
I really like some of the ideas of libertarianism. I think it's a valuable counterpoint to strong government in a debate that should go on forever with no real right answer. But I think these libertarianism to the extreme ideas are, at their core, irresponsible fantasy.
- nonbel 8y ago>"I surely may be wrong in my prediction, but the thing I'm most fascinated about by these libertarian settlement plans is when they organically reintroduce all the government systems they wanted to escape in the first place." Is this a prediction or are you referring to examples of this happening?
- Waterluvian 8y agoMy prediction. Are there examples? Maybe I'm wrong! Maybe we really don't need social security and everything just works out.
- nonbel 8y agoI don't know of any examples. I was hoping you did.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mmt 8y ago> Maybe we really don't need social security I think the libertarian idea is that we really don't need social security through threat of violence. There's a notion of the role of "private" charity. Libertarians aren't necessarily selfish or unempathetic. Contributing to something for the common benefit can also be borderline-coerced through social pressure. This is explored somewhat in P K Dick's short story "Foster, You're Dead!" (one of the ones adapted into something rather different in the Electric Dreams TV Series) http://www.sffaudio.com/podcasts/FosterYoureDeadByPhilipK.DickSSF3.pdf http://www.sffaudio.com/podcasts/FosterYoureDeadByPhilipK.Di... Although I found the story to somewhat muddy the waters by the world having both individual/private bomb shelters and a pay-per-use public one, as well as having a subscription-based communal shelter in the school. The town's defense was community paid but optional (through social pressure). Of course that's fiction, and we're all aware of real life examples of "tragedy of the commons", but human nature isn't entirely one-sided, either. Aren't there examples of "pay what you want" or "pay what you think is fair" schemes that work?
- tomjen3 8y agoYou seem to assume Libertarians are planning to do this in order to live in some sort of headonistic society. There are tons or terrible rules and laws out there (the war on drugs to name a big one) and tons of rent seekers. Those would die in a libertarian society.
- CyberDildonics 8y agoI doubt that will be true, definitely not right away. Think about all the prisoners from the drug war in the US. As silly as some people might see a project like this I think it is incredibly important, since there is really no competition in government. You are born somewhere and for the vast majority of people, you can't pick a different set of laws or a different currency. Whatever happens, this is a choice wrapped in a small community. While it is going to be for people rich enough that they had a choice in the first place, at least it is the start of being able to choose something designed instead of a legacy of hundreds of years. My hope is that whatever they choose to do, they set an example for transparency.
- defertoreptar 8y agoThink about the metaphor you've made. In it, citizens are the "children" and need it's parents (government) to restrict their freedoms since they are not able to decide for themselves what is in their best interests. It's not about wanting to be like a child who spends all their allowance on ice cream. It's about wanting to be an adult who is free to decide what is in their best interests for themselves.
- hitekker 8y agoHe didn’t give a metaphor. He said that he once wanted absolute freedom and then he grew up. The notion of “heaven on earth” is a childish one, regardless of ideology.
- defertoreptar 8y ago> He didn’t give a metaphor. In that case, I'm finding it difficult to understand what Waterluvian meant by saying: > Child me was always excited for the day I could break away from the government (parents) and spend all my money on vices like snacks and video games. College me did that and learned the hard way what adult me now practices: a responsible need for the restrictions my parents imposed upon me. Are you saying Waterluvian's parents are literally the government? Why is Waterluvian talking about parental restrictions? If not relating it to governments restrictions on its people, isn't that a non sequitur?
- jimmaswell 8y agoMy parents limited my computer and video game use and would prefer I watched TV - for some bizarre reason they thought the other two were bad for me but TV must have been fine because they grew up with it. Turned out the games were mentally engaging and promoted hand-eye coordination while computer use was my gateway to earning more than they do combined. They wanted me to waste time cleaning my room all the time, yet I don't clean much of my apartmemt much and nothing bad happens. One railed against how awful Chef Boyardee is for you but as far as I can tell they're decent cheap rounded meals. One literally tried to tell me it was wrong to wait until the zebra stripes end on a road to turn into the turning lane - as if you were obligated to drive over the stripes, which is illegal. Child me knew all along my parents were full of it despite being well-meaning and my opinion hasn't changed. So, this analogy has the opposite effect for me.
- njarboe 8y agoWho is restricting you now that did not in college? Your spouse? Or maybe you grew up and can now restrict yourself? Or did you go to prison and now understand breaking some laws are not worth it?