4 ms·
Oh, I am not saying there are no problems. And I don't deny a certain emotional appeal to having safety features provided by the language. However, great (qua
by mpweiher 8y ago
Oh, I am not saying there are no problems. And I don't deny a certain emotional appeal to having safety features provided by the language.
However, great (quality) is delivered with those kinds of features and without, and crap software is delivered with those kinds of features and without. And more importantly, I have seen little to no evidence that having those sorts of features actually substantially changes the statistical distribution of crap/quality software, no matter what we feel should be the case.
People can use these safety features or not, and they can use them well or not. Just like they can use non-linguistic safety mechanism, such as really good test-suites...or not.
Elsewhere, he writes:
> This is where I stop understanding how the rest of the world can work at all. And so you probably need to upgrade your understanding.
If the world doesn't conform to your understanding of it, the thing that's lacking is almost certainly your understanding of the world. Because it does work.
- jacquesm 8y ago> And more importantly, I have seen little to no evidence that having those sorts of features actually substantially changes the statistical distribution of crap/quality software, no matter what we feel should be the case. I have. Our company has done a fairly large number of studies on the internals of companies producing software and the better companies are at the tech the better they do in the long run. Note that there is such a thing as 'good enough', and once that bar is cleared I'm fine with cutting a corner here or there to meet a deadline. But I'm not fine with categorically ignoring quality and security in favor of short term wins.
- mpweiher 8y agoHmm...not sure we are disagreeing. You: "the better companies are at the tech..." "categorically ignoring quality and security" That is about doing something about quality and security, and I agree wholeheartedly. Me: "having those sorts of features [in the language]" That's whether having some specific language features is determinant for doing things. I don't think it is.