4 ms·
I'm really glad that people are experimenting with commenting systems. There have been better systems in the past than Reddit or HN (such as Slashdot & Kuro5hi
by rwmj 8y ago
I'm really glad that people are experimenting with commenting systems. There have been better systems in the past than Reddit or HN (such as Slashdot & Kuro5hin). Some ideas which could be explored again:
* Whether you should be allowed to both post comments and vote on a single article.
* Whether you should have a limited or unlimited number of votes per day or per article.
* Whether established users can apply multiple up/down votes to a comment.
* Should votes happen along other axes than up/down (eg. "Funny", "Interesting", "Relevant"<->"Off-topic").
* How could meta-moderation be made to work without it seeming like a slog to review other people's voting?
* Can we see who voted on a comment?
* Can we display comments in a more relevant order? At the moment the highest voted top comments are spread down the page, mixed in with lower voted replies.
* Should there be a limited or unlimited range of voting? Is a -15 comment substantively different from a -20 comment, probably not.
- megamindbrian2 8y agoSlashdot is the grim reaper of commenting.
- rwmj 8y ago> Slashdot is the grim reaper of commenting. I've no idea what it's like now, but in its heyday you could set your comment threshold to +3 or +5 to read the dozen or so most insightful comments on each topic. That was a great reader-friendly time-saving device. As far as I know that's not possible on HN.
- pjc50 8y agoEven better, they had custom multipliers for different kinds of upvote reason. This let you do things like set "Funny" to -1 if you didn't like Slashdot's sense of humour.
- digi_owl 8y agoYou can also tag people, and have their score weighted accordingly (and they can see how you tag them in their profile)...
- digi_owl 8y agoI fear the astroturfers have gotten their claws in, as i constantly see conflicting, and downright asinine, comments hovering at +5 (insightful).
- megamindbrian2 8y agoI read it on no filter. It's the best way to fully absorb the community.
- philbarr 8y agoHow about ranking posts by latest submitted comment? Excluding people that have already commented on the post and the submitter themselves.