6 ms·
Some people would inevitably fuck up and spend all their money and have none left to buy food... so you’d still need food banks or stamps.
by chrisseaton 8y ago
Some people would inevitably fuck up and spend all their money and have none left to buy food... so you’d still need food banks or stamps.
- matz1 8y agoSame thing with welfare, despite the availability of various government program, some people still end up fuck up. If someone fuck up and use up all their UBI then they must seek private entity such as church or charity.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> If someone fuck up and use up all their UBI then they must seek private entity such as church or charity. But if this is your attitude - people who mess up should be on their own - why are you in favour of UBI? Why don’t you also think that people who can’t get a job should be on their own?
- matz1 8y agoHow is this any difference than the current condition right now? We have many of government program but we still have many mess up, they are on their own too. I prefer UBI because I can't choose however I want to spend it.
- tathougies 8y ago> Why don’t you also think that people who can’t get a job should be on their own? Personally, I recognize that you need some level of money in order to take part in civic society. For example, it's hard to find a job without a mailing address, nice clothes, cosmetic products, and make up. It's also hard to put your time towards finding a job if you can't eat. Thus, in the interest of maximizing economic output and social engagement, we ought to provide enough money for people to be able to afford these things. If you are able to afford these things, but still mess up... well, I mean, you have freely and without coercion chosen to disengage with society. To these people, I hope they are happy with their choice, but I struggle to see how they could be.
- tathougies 8y agoThe libertarian response would be to ... do nothing. Sure people may get hurt, but no one will get hurt because they didn't have the resources to avoid it. Every person who fucks up has only themselves to blame, not the whims of some government bureaucrat. Just as a note, I'm not really a libertarian sympathizer anymore, but that is my understanding of the libertarian justification for UBI.
- anonytrary 8y agoIf people aren't smart enough to know how to spend their money, perhaps we need to provide better financial education in school. I don't remember having an iota of financial education from K-12 -- it was all focused around math, history, literature and science. "How to live your life independently" may as well be a core subject, because the United States is becoming breeding ground for dependent people. It doesn't seem in the government's best interest to push for better financial education, because they profit off of dependency. It makes way more sense to have your constituents be financially educated than to "accept that they are dumb" and then just attempt to fix everything they mess up. The latter is unsustainable. UBI + better schooling should preclude the need for food programs, etc.
- chrisseaton 8y agoSo why UBI then? People getting jobs should preclude the need for food programs, but it doesn’t in practice so you want UBI. UBI should preclude the need for food programs and it also won’t in practice. What’s changed? Why do you care that jobs don’t work for everyone, but don’t care that UBI won’t work for everyone? If you’re a ‘people should just be smarter’ person why do you want to help people using UBI in the first place?
- anonytrary 8y ago> Why do you care that jobs don’t work for everyone, but don’t care that UBI won’t work for everyone? Because jobs and UBI aren't the same thing. You aren't guaranteed a job out of high school or college, so you are more likely to have some sort of basis for your claim that you need support from everyone else. On the other hand, with UBI, if you're given exactly what you need to sustain your life and can't, then it's clearly a personal problem.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> then it's clearly a personal problem Right - so we still need a food program for people who have personal problems that cause them to run out of money - like being innumerate, or having mental health issues, or a controlling abusive partner, or just being super crap with money no matter how hard they honestly try. You can say we’ll leave those people to starve to death, but that’s not going to get me to vote for UBI! You’ll probably more realistically say ‘ok well we’ll help that one mother just one time with the baby starving to death because she is addicted to gambling away her UBI’ but then bingo you’re now running a food program as well.
- thatswrong0 8y agoYou can still buy some junk food and soda with food stamps, and none of that is good for you. You could theoretically trade whatever food you buy for drugs or money to purchase drugs if you so desired. Should we force feed people nutritious food? No, obviously not. Removing all individual agency from welfare is simply dehumanizing. Let people make the best decisions for themselves... and get legitimate help (not food stamps) for the people unable to do that.
- mikec3010 8y agoI've seen a food stamp program called WIC that had limits against junk food and overpriced brands. Also soda and chips will prevent starvation. Dope dealers will not accept food as payment. >make the best decisions for themselves. And what about their children? Many of them are poor because they have kids. No one has the individual agency to get high on free money while their kids starve.
- thatswrong0 8y agoMy point is you can’t force people to take care of themselves or their kids, regardless of whether you give them food stamps or just cash. Sure, food stamps guide them perhaps in the right direction, but there’s no guarantee those parents will use the food stamps responsibly. Bad parents will be bad parents. Those bad parents that would let their kids starve if they were given money rather than food stamps should have their kids taken away from them. But I don’t think most people on food stamps are like that. So then the question is is the overhead worth that marginal case?
- JoeAltmaier 8y ago… or churches or charities or … but the volume would go way down. From a utilitarian point of view, its saving money to switch to a BI.