3 ms·
journalism from the scourge of fake news. Journalism isn't suffering from a scourge of fake news.
by pvg 8y ago
journalism from the scourge of fake news.
Journalism isn't suffering from a scourge of fake news.
- JoshCole 8y agohttp://science.sciencemag.org/content/359/6380/1146 http://science.sciencemag.org/content/359/6380/1146 You don't need to have an increase in fake news to have an increase in the perception of fake news. Another way to get an increase in the perception of fake news is to change the structural graph through which news propagates. The two most outspoken people I know of on the topic of the problem of fake news both happen to be twitter users (Elon Musk, Donald Trump).
- pvg 8y agoI don't really understand how this is a response to what I said.
- JoshCole 8y agoThe Science paper I linked was meant to show that the twitter graph has properties which spread fake news through its part of the news propagation graph. The people I referenced were meant to show that people on the graph with such a property are talking about the fake news problem as if it is real. Taken together, my response to you was trying to get at the idea that fake news, even if not a thing from the perspective of one node on overall news propagation graph, can seem very real from another position on the graph. So basically, I disagree with the claim that fake news doesn't exist, in a subtle way.
- pvg 8y agoI disagree with the claim that fake news doesn't exist I got that bit, it's just not a thing I argued.
- clickok 8y agoIt is, and has been for decades. Usually, when I read articles on a topic which I have researched, I find the reporting tends to be "wrong" in some sense. Charitably this can be blamed on time or space constraints: the articles need to be ready for publication while the story is relevant, so the author has insufficient time to achieve expertise; or even if the author is an expert, they are incentivized to publish only the most interesting (and perhaps most superficial) details on the subject. Less charitably, you might suspect that the author (or their editor) has a bias depending on what they elide or emphasize. Herman & Chomsky wrote about this topic[0] examining the various filters that determine what gets reported and from what angle. However, it's recently become politically controversial to acknowledge this fact, I think because Trump uses "fake news" to disqualify criticism of himself and his administration[1]. But let's not pretend that journalism is without faults or bias just because (on average) the virtues of the fourth estate outweigh their flaws. ----- 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent 1. He's hardly the first person to have issues with his press coverage, but it seems like he's getting a bit more traction with his complaints. It helps that he has an observably hostile relationship with the press. But the term "fake news" was originally applied to right-wing blogspam/memes that showed up during the 2016 election, which were highly slanted, based on cherry-picked information if not outright lies.
- pvg 8y agoYou don't need Trump for this, just taking the term for what it says. Are there are various quality problems with journalism? Sure. Is journalism as a field plagued by a problem of straight-up, unchecked fabrication of 'news'? Not really. That problem is not a journalism problem.
- clickok 8y agoIt doesn't have to be literally false to misinform, and informing the public is (in my opinion) the main point of journalism. How erroneous/slanted does it have to be before we can assert fakeness? I think it's fair to say that if I have a worse understanding of the world as a result of consuming news media then that constitutes "fake news".
- a_d 8y agoI am not using the phrase ‘fake news’ in the way Trump uses it (to seed doubt and cast aspersions). I mean to say: “sometimes, I know the details (inside story) of a story/situation. When I read an article about it - I can always tell precisely what got misreported or misinterpreted - which causes me to wonder, what else is getting (mis-)reported like that - about things I don’t know”. Probably the choice of the phrase ‘fake news’ is too extreme. I meant to convey a more subtle point.
- pvg 8y agoThat is using 'fake news' the way Trump uses it - 'news reporting I don't like or I think is in some way wrong' rather than 'news that is actually fake with the deliberate intent to mislead'. What you seem to be talking about is sometimes called 'Gell-Mann amnesia effect' - a term I also think is pretty awful (for different reasons) but again, that's not 'fake news'. Leaving that aside and to your actual point - one way to think about this is 'what major journalistic mishap could have been fixed/avoided by crowd annotation'. Judith Miller's reporting in the run up to the Iraq war? Wen Ho Lee's case? Jayson Blair? It doesn't seem obvious to me it would have made a whit of a difference in any of those nor many others.