3 ms·
> Tax bases are a real thing - and though the Internet should in the long run provide more opportunity for local governments, in the present it's causing losses
by walrus01 8y ago
> Tax bases are a real thing - and though the Internet should in the long run provide more opportunity for local governments, in the present it's causing losses in tax revenues, or at least, those revenues created by new economies are not being realized locally.
nothing is stopping governments from taxing physical, tangible things. Nothing is stopping governments from taxing the gross revenue (such as the WA state business and occupation tax) of ISPs and telecoms in general. Nothing is stopping governments from taxing per-subscriber revenue from mobile phone data connections. The four HSPA+/LTE operators in Pakistan pay a shitload of tax to the government and it works generally quite well.
Where this breaks is when they start deciding to tax specific types of internet content at TCP/IP layer 3, and layers 4-7 in the OSI model. That's fucked.
- sonnyblarney 8y ago"nothing is stopping governments from taxing physical, tangible things." When information is the product of the new economy, and where value is created, it has to be part of the tax base. "Nothing is stopping governments from taxing the gross revenue (such as the WA state business and occupation tax) of ISPs and telecoms in general." True, but this layer of the value chain is not where the new information economy is being developed. "Where this breaks is when they start deciding to tax specific types of internet content at TCP/IP layer 3" 'Content' and 'Layer' are separate issues - they are intertwined for pragmatic reasons, and I agree doing it at 'an internet layer' is dumb ... but there's no clear way around it.