3 ms·
I won't comment about your rhetoric other than to say it's functionally ad-hominem. Wait, how? It's specifically about your language, not you. If, hypothetical
by pvg 8y ago
I won't comment about your rhetoric other than to say it's functionally ad-hominem.
Wait, how? It's specifically about your language, not you. If, hypothetically, he'd taken a little scroll through your older comments and happened to, purely hypothetically, run across some stuff about how slaves had room and board and the persistent racist oppression of white males and then jumped to a conclusion and called you a racist, that would be ad hominem.
But that's totally not what happened.
- ManFromUranus 8y agoThe poster is literally talking about my language, but implying something about me, which is ad-hominem. What they should do is say why I am wrong if they believe Im wrong. If they dont say why I'm wrong because the scope of it is beyond their ability to convey in a HN comment, then fair enough. But they're essentially hand-waving away me and what I'm saying because they've declared it racist (and indirectly me). Actually everyone is racist so the term is redundant. La Raza (now renamed for PR reasons) is not protesting admissions discrimination against Asian applicants in academia for example. They exclusively advocate for the rights of their own ethnic group, the only reason they advocate for other groups is where such advocacy also directly benefits themselves. You're quite disingenuous, I made a comment that slavery is expensive and slaves have to be fed and housed so slavery is not very useful, and actually more expensive that just having "free" people. The reason you choose to cherry pick something to say about "oppression of white males" (which I would never use a phrase like that) is you know the negative sentiment that surrounds that phrase here on HN, so that's why you use it and attach it to me.
- pvg 8y agoEverything is an ad-hominem attack and everyone is the real racist. That's a beautiful constrictor knot of logic, I'll give you that.
- ManFromUranus 8y agoYou didn't address anything I said. This comment is just you calling me stupid rather than demonstrating it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]