5 ms·
Massive US business interests. Why should the EU parliament care about that? There's an obvious solution for Facebook et al. Host their primary data centers in
by simonh 8y ago
Massive US business interests. Why should the EU parliament care about that?
There's an obvious solution for Facebook et al. Host their primary data centers in the EU and move their US user data there, instead of vice versa.
- beberlei 8y agoIf privacy shield gets scraped, then I might have to switch my European business to use only European third party services. At our company we use a carefully selected number of U.S. services that we believe have the interest of their customers and data at heart, but without privacy shield we might not be allowed to use them. The massive downside for me as EU business: 1. Lost time and money having to migrate. 2. Usually european companies providing the same service are worse, leaving me and my customers worse off.
- simonh 8y agoOh absolutely. In other words, you'll be in exactly the same situation US businesses are in, that rely on Chinese and other suppliers that are now subject to tariffs. Politicians, eh? Hope someone wins this trade war soon so we can get it over with.
- madez 8y agoThis is not a trade-war issue. This is a long planned review of the Privacy Shield regulation. Even if all trade conflicts ended, this would continue because it is not about trade but fundamental rights.
- davidvaughan 8y agoIt is possible that the resolution gained more votes because of the trade war. In general, Members of the European Parliament have less understanding of business and trade than businesspeople and traders, and in my view[0] tend to follow their emotions more in those areas. Some also have a streak of anti-Americanism, in varying degrees. As the heat increases, this sort of resolution may occur more frequently. I'm sceptical of the notion that MEPs all voted according to their devotion to fundamental rights. None of this means that I believe pursuing the resolution into legislation is a bad or a good idea. I'd have to see (and understand the consequences of) the proposed measure. [0]This is an impression; I have no empirical data
- Angostura 8y ago> I'm sceptical of the notion that MEPs all voted according to their devotion to fundamental rights. This is what it comes down to, your disbelief that MEPs could have a genuine interest in their constituents' privacy.
- ferongr 8y agoIt's the rational belief to hold.
- Certhas 8y agoYou can't just claim a position is rational just because it is cynical.
- Nasrudith 8y agoIt seems like a sadly reasonable assumption given past behavior and their own spying and loopholed cooperation.
- simonh 8y agoSo you don’t think passing GDPR and the previous data protection legislation going back decades, and enforcing them counts as evidence? I’m sorry, that is a bit snarky, but the EU has been pushing strongly in this direction for a long time and it’s been perfectly apparent it was going to come up hard against the US on this.
- Silhouette 8y agoSo you don’t think passing GDPR and the previous data protection legislation going back decades, and enforcing them counts as evidence? Sure it does, but so do all the loopholes they wrote into those laws so EU member states could continue their own surveillance programmes and data seizure powers, and for that matter all the then-illegal spying programmes that were retrospectively legalised when Snowden et al brought them to light. Let's not pretend the EU and its members are whiter than white in this area, nor that the EU is above attacking the US tech sector through non-technical means.
- psergeant 8y ago> This is not a trade-war issue There’s certainly plausible deniability that it isn’t, I’ll give you that. Is it extra leverage that will almost certainly come into play? Yes, it’s also that.
- soneil 8y agoI think it's clear there is a relationship between the two. Perhaps incidental, but they're still bound together. According to the article, the only implementation on the US side was by presidential policy directive. So our faith in the US implementation of the 'privacy shield' is only as good as our faith in the integrity of said Directive. Even starting from a low point where it's quite clear Trump is interested in tearing up anything Obama put his name to; his increasingly reckless approach to international relations lowers our faith in any presidential directive by the day. At this point 'privacy shield' either needs to make it into law proper, or we should just assume its days are numbered.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TomMarius 8y agoSo because someone else has it bad, we have to have it bad as well?
- richmarr 8y agoIn a trade war we all lose.
- A_No_Name_Mouse 8y agoPrivacy shield is just one way to satisfy GDPR requirements for a US business. EU model clauses can be used as well, so it doesn't mean you cannot use US companies any more. The question is if they offer a good enough level of protection if the US government can demand access to data anyway.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Silhouette 8y agoEU model clauses can be used as well, so it doesn't mean you cannot use US companies any more. So all you would have to do is have every EU business renegotiate contracts with or review new terms with every US business they work with where personal data transfer is involved? No big deal. The question is if they offer a good enough level of protection if the US government can demand access to data anyway. Right. But since essentially the same concerns arise when dealing with businesses based in the EU, let's be honest and acknowledge that this isn't really an ethical question and doesn't really have much to do with either privacy or security either. It's just a matter of the EU and its privacy legislation considering EU prying to be acceptable but not US prying, which is a political decision.
- michaelt 8y agoWhy should the EU parliament care about that? Plenty of EU business interests use AWS and Gmail.
- pluma 8y agoFun fact: because of German paranoia, MS offers Office 365 Deutschland, which is mostly identical with Office 365 but operated by T-Systems (a German company not directly affiliated with Microsoft) and hosted in Germany. It's obvious why Google wouldn't be interested in a similar model for their products.
- jiveturkey 8y agoyour use of “paranoia” implies that the choice is a bad one. quite the opposite, IMHO.
- pluma 8y agoYou could just call it "privacy sensitivity" but by international standards Germans tend to be more "paranoid" when it comes to protecting their data. The reason I'm using the phrase is mostly that it's not always entirely rational (e.g. the outrage about Google Street View was at times a bit absurd). The development is certainly positive and the GDPR is also very similar to pre-existing German privacy laws in many aspects, so I'm not complaining.
- chopin 8y agoWith the CLOUD act, this decision makes sense to me. Could you elaborate where the paranoia lies?
- usr1106 8y ago> MS offers Office 365 Deutschland, which is mostly identical with Office 365 but operated by T-Systems AWS recently wrote me an email, that because my billing address is in the EU, my contract has been transferred to a newly founded company AWS EU, which in turn has subsidiaries in most EU countries. I have no significant business with AWS and have not investigated what this all means. But I wouldn't be surprised if Amazon sees the risk that with the current US administration they don't want to rely on international business anymore. Having only national (or intra-EU) contracts with their EU customers seems just the safer option. Dealing with investments and profits inside a group of fully owned subsidiaries is probably much easier than dealing with two fundamentally different systems in every single customer contract. The EU striving for data-protection and the US insisting that foreigners have no rights and international treaties are bad unless they unilaterally favor the US.
- Silhouette 8y agoWhy should the EU parliament care about that? Because many thousands if not millions of smaller businesses across the EU depend on US businesses as well, and sharing some sort of personal data with them is often necessary for the provision of the relevant service. Given the hassle and costs we've all just had with GDPR, the EU going all-in on undermining Privacy Shield would not be a welcome development for businesses.
- jarfil 8y agoOn the other hand, EU based businesses replacing those US based ones, wouldn't be all that bad for the EU.
- Silhouette 8y agoIf and when that happens, perhaps we'll consider switching, but as with other issues like Brexit, you can't just replace a huge amount of established infrastructure overnight.
- pluma 8y agoWith the precedent of Safe Harbor and the Snowden revelations, I'm surprised any European company preparing for GDPR wouldn't at least have flagged US services as high risk even when they're Privacy Shield certified. Privacy Shield is a fig leaf more than anything. Using any US company (or non-EU company from a country without adequacy) is a major risk for compliance. This is a bit like when people complained their companies were going bankrupt because Facebook/Apple/Twitter/Google shut down an API without warning. If you build your business on such a wobbly foundation, it's a calculated risk and you need to be aware of it.
- Silhouette 8y agoIf you build your business on such a wobbly foundation, it's a calculated risk and you need to be aware of it. It is entirely unconstructive to call US-based foundations wobbly when the EU-based equivalents (a) sometimes don't exist at all, and (b) where they do exist, suffer from analogous privacy concerns around government snooping. The allegation here isn't that, to pick one relevant example, Stripe is abusing the personal data they process when they collect payments from our customers. The objections to Privacy Shield, like Safe Harbor before it, are mostly about the US government itself having rights under US law to gain access to that data, regardless of the actions or intentions of US-based businesses. Now, I don't like the current heavy-handed approach to data hoarding by governments under the guise of national security any more than the next HN reader. But let's be clear: the EU and its member states do essentially the same thing, routinely writing special cases into privacy laws that exclude governments when they want to pry for supposedly security-related reasons. It is the height of hypocrisy for the EU authorities to allege that processing data in the US is unsafe because of the risk of US government interference, while at the same time turning a blind eye to what's going on in their own back yard. In any case, since sadly there is little prospect of any of the governments involved on either side of the Atlantic giving up these powers any time soon, undermining otherwise reasonable privacy laws because of them serves no useful purpose. It just hurts businesses who are trying to do reasonable things, even if they are careful and considerate in how they handle personal data, and by extension it also hurts both their customers and the economies they operate within.