5 ms·
That's insane. Unfortunately politicians will not touch this issue because most people either have insurance which covers these idiotic baseless fees or indige
by mc32 8y ago
That's insane. Unfortunately politicians will not touch this issue because most people either have insurance which covers these idiotic baseless fees or indigent people go to the emergency room and avoid these fees as well. But the poor sap who wants to do things the right way gets effed over like these people. What a shame.
I don't care who, Bernie, Trump, some socialist, take this cause (hospital billing) and have them come correct. They need someone to get tough and straighten them out.
I mean, it's legalized robbery. Nothing less.
- lamlam 8y agoI've often wondered if we could open up private clinics in Canada for Americans where we charge reasonable rates. Kind of start a medical tourism industry by the border.
- duxup 8y agoComfy buses would be nice. Maybe some outpatient services where you recover at a local sporting event, fishing maybe....
- vmlinuz 8y agoThailand has a fairly large medical tourism industry - a number of hospitals in Bangkok are considered world-class (if not world-leading). I know a few people who just go there once a year for a weekend for their annual check-up, since the difference in price from doing it in a decent private hospital in Hong Kong can cover the cost of flights and accommodation, plus you get a weekend in Bangkok which is nice...
- pkaye 8y agoWould not help because many of those without insurance cannot afford a trip up to Canada. And secondly it will not help for emergency care.
- lamlam 8y agoWhile many would not be able to afford a trip to Canada, I would think there would still be a sizeable number who live within 1-2h from the border who could drive there for non-emergency care.
- annablaylock 8y agoPoliticians won't touch this issue because healthcare costs are approaching 20% of GDP and every election since the 70s has been a jobs election.
- nshelly 8y agoThe amount an health insurance company pays is kept secret and we can assume is far less. Otherwise, insurance companies would find ways to open up more hospitals to compete with the large irrational ones, or face huge costs. The hospitals know they can get away these amounts on paper, so they do. We should demand price transparency -- as we do for almost all direct-to-consumer purchases. Businesses can charge different amounts for volume purchases to other businesses, but it would be considered discriminatory if a restaurant didn't show their prices and then when you got your bill, it said -- oh, your company's not paying for it -- so it's $15,000 in extra fees.
- adrr 8y agoIs it a secret? I get letters from my insurance company about how much they paid for medical treatment and even the provider sends me invoices with how much insurance paid. Last one was for blood tests were the provider(think was labcorp) charged $200 for a test and insurance paid $20.
- nshelly 8y agoGood point. Prices for each CPT code accepted by by insurance company are kept secret, and the chargemaster published by a hospital is so inflated it's basically useless. For some diagnostic tests, it's pretty straightforward to understand, but for others like an ER bill where there can be dozens of claim lines and codes, it can be really hard to understand and the patient is relatively powerless to do anything about it after the fact.
- semerda 8y agoNo secret. It's all itemized on your insurance bill. What is secret is the deal insurance companies have with hospitals which allows hospitals to charge astronomical fees. That is then ultimately passed on to companies/patients through high premiums. And no one really chucks a stint over it with public shaming so the vicious cycle continues.
- nshelly 8y ago
- axaxs 8y agoThis is something I really hope Trump hits on. He's proven repeatedly he doesn't care what is popular, and was booed during the debates for saying that he wouldn't let people die in the streets, as sick as that situation is. I like that about Trump, he sets popularity aside in his decisions. That said, this is my single biggest issue at the moment. I have great health insurance, probably better than 90 pct of people here. It's not about me, it's about a broken system. I, or any of us, could lose our coverage in the blink of an eye. I will fully support any candidate who runs on nationalised healthcare. I don't care if my taxes go up. Our country is gross that people are afraid to seek treatment, or even ride an ambulance, because of our broken system. And I say this as a fiscal conservative...
- mc32 8y agoIt'd be great if he or anyone did. Unfortunately, I don't think it will be picked up by traditional politicians because doctors are active donors and they don't want to upset that. But, who knows. If it becomes a populist cause, maybe... maybe.
- axaxs 8y agoThat's what I don't understand. The parties are at each others throats, even physically. I think the majority of both parties support reform and/or single payer. It seems like such an easy political win, even if not an easily solvable problem.
- greywolf 8y agothat's soo disinformed. there's absolutely no sign republicans or even most of democrats will support single payer
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoDoctors aren't the schemers here. When a doctor submits a claim to your insurance for let's say $500 what he gets back is a magic and opaque number. His only choice is take it, or don't accept your insurance. For programs like medicaid this number is often a tiny fraction of what was charged, which is why some doctors or hospitals simply will not accept it. If you pay in cash at a doctor you'll often pay a much more reasonable price, and that's because they're not at the whims of insurance companies who incentivize them to charge as much as they possibly can.
- tolk460 8y agoArticle mentions the bulk of the bill was a "trauma activation". This is an alert from the EMS units to the hospital that they are bringing a patient with indications of trauma requiring additional medical resources to be diverted. The reaction and resources differ per trauma facility. SFGH is a level 1 center [1]. There are better news sources that describe the trauma system within the context of this story. My opinion based on limited information within the article is that the field EMS suspected a closed head injury. The trauma "doctors at the hospital quickly determined that baby Jeong Whan was fine". If the baby had an MRI instead of a medical exam by a team of specialists, the headline would lose some weight. The fee is to staff ED specialists 24/7. I believe the better question is: "should we charge for resources that were used but stood down after initial assessment by the trauma team?" From the perspective of the EMS field, there are protocols that describe tbe patient condition, mechanism of injury and other indicators which dictate a trauma activation. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trauma_center#Level_I https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trauma_center#Level_I
- mc32 8y agoSorry but $15 grand for “Activating trauma protocol” which was then rescinded is ridiculous and an absurd amount. It’s bald robbery.
- riquito 8y ago> If the baby had an MRI instead of a medical exam by a team of specialists, the headline would lose some weight. How so? In my country (Italy) for an MRI I would pay from 42 USD to 81 USD, depending on my income. Not saying that's its real cost since we pay taxes to grant this to everyone, but from here to 18k...
- rasz 8y agoBad comparison. Italy has far inferior health system, barely able to provide 2x better infant mortality rate at 1/3 the cost when compared to US. /sarcasm
- taneq 8y agoJust how many specialists were they keeping available, and how much do those specialists cost? Let's say five different preeminent medical professionals were needed to respond to that emergency. Let's say that it used an hour each of their time. That's still $1000 an hour, which is exorbitant regardless of your credentials. And that's the most charitable evaluation. They "quickly determined that the baby was fine." So what did the hospital do, charge out the entire cost of running the ER to one unlucky family since they were the only case who was brought in that hour?
- thatfrenchguy 8y agoFucking Universal healthcare is the only solution for this garbage.
- semerda 8y agoWith universal healthcare come other issues like waiting months for a bed. The real solution (and it's maybe 100 years away) is automating hospitals to a point where humans no longer play a role in healthcare management and it's 100% funded by the state/country. Maybe we won't even have hospitals and instead a portable home healthcare unit. One can dream ;-)
- ashildr 8y agoWe have universal healthcare in Germany. The longest time I had to wait was 17 days for a stationary colonoscopy because I wanted that exact hospital. And a MRI of the knee would have been 12 days of waiting until I called different radiologists in my area and got one the nextday. * Yes, our healthcare can be improved and politics is constantly trying to make it worse. But I doubt that the average person waiting for a bed in Germany can even afford a bed in the US. * ah, no co-pay by the way, I have no idea how expensive those things are.
- mnm1 8y agoCo-pay / co-insurance can run into the thousands literally up to your out of pocket maximum. For me as an individual, I think that's about $4-5k and for a family about $8-10k but this is with the second best insurance available. That's every year, an amount that you might have to pay if you are sick. With a chronic condition or a major trip to the hospital one is very likely to hit those limits. Not to mention the months to years of dealing with bills afterwards, when one is trying to recover, and companies wrongly billing, billing for too much, not billing insurance, double billing. No drawbacks to universal healthcare even come close to this absolute fucking hell. It's hell for the patients' family, so one can only imagine how it is for the patient. And then, of course, there are the times when care is simply refused outright and your father dies the day after he leaves the hospital ... but hey, insurance companies gotta make money off of some people dying. They don't care it's someone's father or mother or children.