4 ms·
This sounds great in principle, but this is 2018... virtually none of the use cases for RSS can be replaced by something which requires the consumer to be onlin
by saurik 8y ago
This sounds great in principle, but this is 2018... virtually none of the use cases for RSS can be replaced by something which requires the consumer to be online and capable of receiving an HTTP POST (which isn't possible on the web platform at all, so this shouldn't be called WebSub). To the extent to which a "thundering herd" ever existed for RSS, it was from large numbers end users with normal computers behind firewalls constantly checking the feed, which is an environment where this protocol has no hope of ever being applicable.
So far, no one on this entire thread has descried a single use case where WebSub actually provides value. Someone mentioned that theoretically a service like Facebook could use this for Facebook, but then they themselves linked to a page on Quora with an explanation from someone at Facebook for why they tested out PubSubHubbub and then gave up on it which stated that he "think[s] the benefits of adopting PubSubHubbub are less clear" for this very issue (that it is inherently a server-to-server protocol, where there wasn't really a problem in the first place).
- rakoo 8y agoAre you saying that webhooks have no purpose in 2018 ? Because while WebSub was created as an effort to help RSS get more realtime, it's a more generic architecture for publishers who have content and need to notify interested subscribers.
- antpls 8y agoWhat we are saying is : In the attempt at understanding the use cases of this proposal, people said in the thread webhooks were created to replace RSS+GET pull, as an "enhancement". As we are trying to explain : this proposal doesn't cover all use cases of RSS+GET pull, so it should not be considered a replacement of RSS nor an enhancement of it. If WebSub has a purpose (if any), many people fail to explain a valid one. Does it worth wasting the resources of the W3C for such proposal? The "world wide web" is wide, and doesn't only include servers
- rakoo 8y ago> people said in the thread webhooks were created to replace RSS+GET pull That's the root of our misunderstanding then: never was PubSubHubbub _replacing_ RSS+GET pull, it was supposed to _help_ it for people who want notifications, on top of the existing system.
- antpls 8y agoThe root of the misunderstandong is that their is no rational in the proposal. How are people supposed to understand any proposal without a rational?