2 ms·
To me this definition is meaningless. For you to be "making a choice" implies that you have the ability to influence the outcome in some way that is not determi
by vidarh 8y ago
To me this definition is meaningless. For you to be "making a choice" implies that you have the ability to influence the outcome in some way that is not deterministically dictated by the laws of physics, yet that is also not merely non-deterministic or a combination of some part of each.
You seem to basically be arguing that we should define free will in a way that makes it entirely an illusion, yet treat it as meaningful.
- ethbro 8y agoAny other definition supposes we have the ability to look at ourselves (who we have the most knowledge about) from an external, omniscient perspective. Otherwise any definition trivially collapses under "Well how do you know that you're acting freely?" Which makes other definitions functionally useless in terms of communicating an idea. I'd rather have a meaningless definition that's useful than a philosophically pure one that's useless. But maybe that's why I'm an engineer. ;)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]