2 ms·
I could have plenty of other critiques (and share some of OP's), but I had no problem with the record-player metaphor, I found it pretty apt. The very physical
by jrochkind1 8y ago
I could have plenty of other critiques (and share some of OP's), but I had no problem with the record-player metaphor, I found it pretty apt.
The very physical/analog nature of a record player makes it not hard for me to imagine a record designed to break a player, one can totally imagine one whose grooves jostle the arm so much it breaks (no idea if this is actually practical, it doesn't really matter).
I wonder if it doesn't work anymore now that fewer people have experienced a record player, although the author DID say he encountered it first 20 years ago and had trouble with it then, I dunno.
> can the problem of record-player-breaking-records be suitably addressed by redesigning record-players? If no, why not? What if we simply read the information from a record using a visual device with no moving parts?
Dude, it's a metaphor/analogy, it's not that hard to realize taking it that literally takes you out of it. No analogy can ever be carried to it's end and still be a good analogy or metaphor. That's why it's an analogy, not the thing analogized. (which is a lesson that is (ironically? intentionally?) consistent with the messages of GEB? The map is not the territory.)
- grkvlt 8y agoAnd if I remember correctly, in the dialog, one of the record-player-destroying-record-proof record players R^whatever does scan the record visually to see if it would break the player - but is still vulnerable to a recording of 'this record cannot be played on player R^whatever' so this point is addressed...