3 ms·
Second time in this thread I see someone mention GEB in the same breath as TAOCP. I'm curious how they ended up occupying the same kind of mental space for you
by pvg 8y ago
Second time in this thread I see someone mention GEB in the same breath as TAOCP. I'm curious how they ended up occupying the same kind of mental space for you and apparently others. In the immortal words of Jules Winnfield, it "ain't the same fuckin' ballpark, it ain't the same league, it ain't even the same fuckin' sport". Not that you are under any obligation to read either and plenty of very good arguments can be made you're better off not-reading at least one of them.
- Tomte 8y agoIn the same way as both chocolate ice cream and riding a rollercoaster make me happy, but are totally different. :-)
- pvg 8y agoRight but do you feel you have to read, to pick a slightly less fraught example, the white algorithms book? Or Patterson and Hennessy? Like TAOCP, those work perfectly well skimmed or read in bits and parked on your bookshelf or in your bathroom. GEB (or Moby Dick) are intended to be read in entirety.
- commandlinefan 8y agoI assume you mean CLRS when you say "the white algorithms book" - if so, I'm not sure I necessarily agree that any of these books are meant as reference works or "not intended to be read entirely". They're textbooks, of course, so there's something of an expectation that you'll read them over the course of months or years, but I do believe that all three of your examples are _meant_ to be read cover to cover rather than used as a reference book like a dictionary or a thesaurus or even a cookbook; if you pick up any of these books and start at a random chapter (much less a random section) you're likely to be lost. You might use them as references once you've finished them, but you are expected to start on page 1 and finish on page 1,892 (or whatever insane page count these books have now).
- pvg 8y agoThis 'reference' business really seems to stick in people's craws for some reason. I don't mean it disparagingly nor do I feel 'reference' is limited to the style of cookbooks and dictionaries. Nobody writes a multi-volume (or monolith-sized) technical work without the intent it also be used as reference. The work might have other purposes and even a different stated primary purpose - that doesn't make it not-a-reference.
- pnathan 8y ago> plenty of very good arguments can be made you're better off not-reading at least one of them. I'm extremely confused as to why this would be the case for TAOCP. While I wouldn't recommend TAOCP for "just reading", I don't know why it wouldn't be recommended for study. Knuth provides a very interesting approach for algorithms analysis, deep in substance.
- pvg 8y agoLet's say, like many people, you enjoy the occasional article from The Onion. You can very easily continue enjoying them without reading Animal Farm, Gulliver's Travels or the collected works of Aristophanes. TAOCP, to me, is in a similar category - it's worth remembering Knuth essentially carved the field of study out himself. If you need a reference or textbook, there are by now better places to start. If you are interested in the field, you should definitely get a hold of TAOCP as well. But you can be a perfectly fine and educated programmer (let alone person) and never touch the thing.
- pnathan 8y agoI see what you mean. I'll be frank, I think that Knuth's analyses have surprisingly fresh and useful approaches, particularly compared with the other algorithms texts I've read. The usual texts are better at compressed results and a "Straight path" through, but as ways of thinking, I find Knuth more useful to study. I wouldn't recommend TAOCP to anyone not interested in algorithms, mind.
- pvg 8y agoOh, I'm an unrepentant TAOCP and Knuth fanboy. TAOCP is undoubtedly a Great Work™. I'm just bothered by the notion that someone would feel bad or inadequate for not having read it. GEB, on the other hand is... I dunno, an ok monitor riser if you don't have anything else handy.
- tptacek 8y agoThat's what Cormen/Rivest is for. Much sturdier, too.