3 ms·
(Socratic dialog as literary device should not be confused with Socratic method/questioning as a thinking device) Socratic dialog's have different uses. On the
by nabla9 8y ago
(Socratic dialog as literary device should not be confused with Socratic method/questioning as a thinking device)
Socratic dialog's have different uses. On the one end it can be used to consider serious existing counterarguments and provide answers to them. One is to explain one point of view and not to provide balanced opinion.
One-sided Socratic dialog that is like a 'happy path' without hairy counterarguments falls into the latter category. Hofstadter uses them to illustrate a concepts, not to go question them.
In fact the hole book is just attempt to repeat the same ideas again and again.