3 ms·
I am always impressed by the support efforts to curb copyright expansion, as it relates to practical freedoms of expression, information and control over the in
by dalbasal 8y ago
I am always impressed by the support efforts to curb copyright expansion, as it relates to practical freedoms of expression, information and control over the internet. It's a nuanced issue, international and unrelated directly to any major political wing or ideology. So, the fact that it attracts a dedicated and effective activist base is both surprising and heartening. This for the "cause" least likely to get you laid.
Thank you to whoever is involved. You are fighting for me and I appreciate it. I'm going to make a habit of writing MEPs and generally getting behind you guys. I want my next comment on the subject to be in the first person (we).
But.....
I feel like we're at a real structural disadvantage. Copyrights (up generally) are under constant expansive efforts. Expanding rights. Expanding duratii. Expanding enforcement. Practical enforcement edforts that will result in dragnets (like this, now defeated proposal).
The saintly activists are working to defeat restrictions, but they can't win every fight. This proposal will be back, in modified form. It's a ratchet. Sometimes we don't lose. Other times we lose. There are no wins, just defense against loss.
For a practical example: YouTube is the biggest video site, and it does not honour fair use. You can't (easily, anyway) automate fair use detection, so it gets caught in the copyright violation dragnets. In practice this weakens fair use rights. I'm sure pressure from copyright holders played a role on YouTube's policy decisions.
Is there (or can there be) an activist effort that puts pressure on YouTube (just for example) to protect fair use rights, and freedom of expression generally.
Are there wins we can aim for? Is an effort to shorten copyright duration feasible? I think the economic argument is on our side, even if we accept the other side's premises. Is a fair use expansion campaign possible?
- walterbell 8y agoWe need new business models for new media, which are not based on artificial scarcity. Then new media can afford to outspend old media. It's unfortunate that the current flag-bearers for new media are funded by advertising, rather than creativity and innovation unlocked by fair use and remix culture.
- bjelkeman-again 8y agoI hope efforts like the Dutch De Correspondent works out in the long run. I know readers that love their work and happily pays for it. http://www.niemanlab.org/2018/05/dutch-news-organization-de-correspondent-is-getting-more-money-toward-its-global-expansion/ http://www.niemanlab.org/2018/05/dutch-news-organization-de-...
- drb91 8y agoPeople need to lobby for laws protecting consumer interests. There just isn’t any large coporation willing to foot the bill here.