5 ms·
Probably not. Strong anti-abortion views are mostly religious in nature, and only for specific religious subgroups: http://www.pewforum.org/religious-landscape-
by wpietri 8y ago
Probably not. Strong anti-abortion views are mostly religious in nature, and only for specific religious subgroups: http://www.pewforum.org/religious-landscape-study/views-about-abortion/ http://www.pewforum.org/religious-landscape-study/views-abou...
The evangelical absolutism around abortion is historically new. Before 1980, plenty of evangelical Christians had nuanced views on the topic: http://www.patheos.com/blogs/slacktivist/2012/02/18/the-biblical-view-thats-younger-than-the-happy-meal/ http://www.patheos.com/blogs/slacktivist/2012/02/18/the-bibl...
Even some evangelical writers see this as mainly about a wedge issues used for political power, not morality: http://www.patheos.com/blogs/slacktivist/2018/07/03/the-con-game-of-anti-abortion-partisanship-that-replaced-christianity-has-been-so-successful-that-we-forget-how-recently-it-was-invented/ http://www.patheos.com/blogs/slacktivist/2018/07/03/the-con-...
So I think it's no coincidence that at the same time extreme anti-abortion views came to prominence on the US right, the US right became steadily more extreme, with centrists disappearing from the Republican side of the aisle in Congress: https://xkcd.com/1127/large/ https://xkcd.com/1127/large/
My expectation is that this, like all positive feedback loops, will eventually break, and Christians will return to historical norms. And I'd further guess that this will be aided technological advances that make extreme antiabortion views untenable. Look, for example at the question that goes something like, "In a clinic fire, would you save a five year old or a tank with 1,000 embryos?". [1] Advances in medicine, AI, copying minds, and animal uplift would provide many more examples, forcing a debate around what really makes something a legally protected person. If an AI, a human mind moved to silicon, and a dog with a 140 IQ all get citizenship, it'll harder to explain why a nonsentient fertilized human egg gets those protections.
[1] https://www.quora.com/In-the-abortion-debate-isnt-the-5-year-old-versus-1-000-frozen-embryos-analogy-just-an-emotional-appeal-and-therefore-useless-in-determining-fetal-personhood https://www.quora.com/In-the-abortion-debate-isnt-the-5-year...
- Mediterraneo10 8y ago> Christians will return to historical norms. Abortion is condemned in the Didache (late 1st century/early 2nd century CE). There were already rigorously set penalties under canon law for abortion in the 1st millennium. It may be that American Evangelical Christians will return to the moderate views about the issue that they held several decades ago, but it is entire possible that the "historical norms" that any Christian community might return to are the ones even further back in time.
- wpietri 8y agoSure. Heck, they could go back to approving of slavery, which was theologically justified in a number of times and places. But when I say evangelicals may return to historical norms, I mean relative to other Christians in other well-off societies over the last hundred years or so.
- davrosthedalek 8y agoWhat I find quite interesting in the discussion in the US about abortion is the extreme all-or-nothing view, on both sides. One side sees any abortion, at any time and any condition, as highly immoral, while the other rejects any limits on abortion as an insufferable limit on women's rights. The question is, when does the non-sentient fertilizied human egg become something more. Certainly not at the moment of fertilization, but "birth" seems rather arbitrary too. I like your examples for questions, because they are thought-provoking. Let me add two more: Should a baby born a (2/3..) month (or a day!) premature be less protected than a baby born 3 days late? Would you rather save a five year old, or 20 premature born babies? Or, what do you think about abortions done because the embryo is female.
- hfdgiutdryg 8y agobut "birth" seems rather arbitrary too. It seems like the most notable milestone in the entire process, so what makes it arbitrary?
- davrosthedalek 8y agoThe existence of c-section and labour-inducing medicine. It is certainly the most perceivable milestone. But maybe we can define a status change which is more relevant to the question cell group -> human. Maybe "has consciousness". My point is that this is a discussion which seems important.
- ModernMech 8y ago> has consciousness This hinges on the definition of consciousness, which we really don't have a good definition for.
- harimau777 8y agoI agree that defining an exact moment is difficult and/or somewhat arbitrary, but it seems to me that physical birth doesn't make sense as a cutoff since the baby is usually viable before that point. In my opinion a better milestone is higher brain function which occurs at about 19 to 20 weeks.
- patrickg_zill 8y agoSkeptical response : was Hippocrates a Christian? If not then why did the oath that bears his name prohibit a doctor from participating in abortion ("I will not give a woman a pessary to procure an abortion")?
- bildung 8y agoIt's worth noting that the role of women in ancient Greece was barely above that of slaves. BTW the oath also forbids doctors to treat bladder stones (seemingly for anti-competitive reasons?), so all in all it should, as every ancient text, be interpreted in the historical context.
- patrickg_zill 8y agoThe role of women in ancient Greece varied. Spartan women at one time held 40% of all property, and were highly educated and could freely travel, while women in Athens had a lot less rights. The deferral to (what I assumed to be) surgeons seems to indicate specialization rather than being anti-competitive. That is, there was a split between "doctors" and "chirurgeons" or surgeons.