5 ms·
I don't understand this, although I've read something similar many times before; it seems incoherent. All value comes ultimately from labor, I would agree, but
by perl4ever 8y ago
I don't understand this, although I've read something similar many times before; it seems incoherent. All value comes ultimately from labor, I would agree, but if I'm using tools to do work, a portion of the value of my work is attributable to the work done by the creators of the tools I'm using. Not me. It makes a big difference if I have a computer, or not; if I have a backhoe or a shovel. So this idea that capitalist profit is theft from workers has never made any sense to me. If the capital was stolen, then the proposition is tautological, but otherwise you are begging the question of what was actually stolen. I don't see a political or moral revelation in the claim that my employer is necessarily stealing from me. How can the assumption someone else is stealing labor justify you or me stealing labor?
P.S. If profit is illegitimate, then is interest also? I tend to assume that there's no moral or political difference between stocks and bonds, but for all I know other people may think differently.
One possibility from my point of view is that people look at profit as something extra, hence illegitimate, but the way I would look at it is that it is a deferred payment for work done, equivalent to interest. If you store seeds, then it is right and fair and necessary that in a well functioning society, you be paid for preserving them as well as producing them. Society can't function if people are paid only for producing things and not for preserving them, or if they are paid for preserving things before they do it. That's the most reduced scenario I can make up about why interest/profits seem legitimate to me.
- prolikewh0a 8y agoSurplus value after all tools & supplies to do the job are paid for, is not given back to the workers in most cases. The workers produce the profit in the first place.
- perl4ever 8y agoWhich workers are "the" workers? Are the workers the ones who create the capital assets that multiply productivity, or the ones that use those capital assets? It seems obvious to me, morally and logically, that if worker A creates an asset that multiplies the value of the work of worker B, that both should share in the additional value created. The value of capital assets depends on the profit that can be made with them, so I assume you aren't saying that "worker A" is disconnected from the capitalist profit mechanism. Then too, "worker A" and "worker B" are sometimes two roles of the same person - this seems relevant on HN, where people tend to be software developers who are always creating tools and using them.
- jadedhacker 8y agoThe capitalist is able to procure computers from other workers because they control capital. They then take part of the proceeds of any additional labor attached to it. This is the extraction of surplus value that is being discussed. The workers do not control capital or the means of production and the undemocratic processes of private capitalism means that they will be paid only as much as it takes for them to survive and reproduce their living status without the intervention of the state. A key socialist idea is to give the workers the control of the means of production and this theft would cease. The idea is that workers as a whole should democratically decide what should be done with the proceeds as they were instrumental in producing them. Yes, people should be paid to do all kinds of labor. It's not obvious that they should be paid a fraction of all other people's labor in the organization (stocks). As for bonds, I haven't seen an analysis before, but I'll take a stab. Bonds are the idea that I'll lend you some money and you'll pay me back with interest. The idea inherent in it is that I have no interest in what you're doing other than making some money out of the deal. Person to person, other considerations are pertinent, but at a repeatable institutional level, that's what it comes down to (other than enforceable legality and public pressure). Interest payments in general are also exponential rather than a fixed risk premium, and so represent a particularly extractive way of doing business (though bond payments are closer to fixed payments though they are calculated as interest). Credit cards for instance, exhibit this phenomenon more intensively as there is no ceiling on interest.
- lumberjack 8y agoFrom what I understand the basic qualm that socialists have, concerns the moral justification for owning income generating assets. Everything else stems from that. Although I believe some would rather argue from an utilitarian point of view rather than from a moral one.
- ghosterrific 8y agoYou are correct. Examples: Tooth brush for personal use: Good. Use said Tooth brush for cleaning someone's toilet to earn some money: bad. Use your hands to dig your own hole: good. Use your hands (a mean of production) to dig someone else a hole for money: bad. It logically follows that public ownership of the means of production results in the ownership of our homes, bodies and ultimately, minds. That is the intentional theory and actual practical implementation of communist ideology. It ia very dangerous because it is cloaked in "helping the greater good" and anyone who dare show initiative and put their hands to work without getting a politician to sign off on it results with you and your family getting sent to "labor" and "education" camps. Once again, not in theory... this happened several times in the 20th century resulting in over 100 million dead
- nahnahnah3 8y agoYou're correct, but stateless socialism is the goal. What you're describing is state capitalism.
- aninhumer 8y agoSocialists usually also argue from a utilitarian point of view. The utility a person experiences as a result of increasing access to resources is sublinear, i.e. there are diminishing utility returns to an individual as they acquire resources. Therefore an unequal resource allocation is less efficient at creating utility than an equal one. It is argued that the inequality creates incentives that result in more being produced, but many socialists are highly sceptical of this claim, and especially sceptical that the level of inequality that exists is worth the loss of utility it causes. Personally, I think after a certain level of comfort is reached, people seem to be far more motivated by self-actualisation than ever increasing material wealth.
- ghosterrific 8y agoOne small adjustment: All value comes from the Mind (and labor is a subset of that). If I decide to write a book and I self publish, having paid for all my tools.... and still get a profit at the end after selling a million copies.... then who is exploited? Where is the theft? What people don't realize is that the worker is a service provider (like an author) and they are offering their services in exchange for payment (boss is the customer). The customer agreed the book is worth it. The author agreed it is worth taking the risks and using their talents at producing works of art. Win-Win. Now let's add in that the author also hires someone to delivery the books. The delivery person also Wins since they have a stable customer of their delivery services (ie: the author). But would we say that the delivery person is suddennly entitled to additional retained earnings (profits) all of a sudden? Anyone that will tell you that 2 or more consenting, voluntarily engaged adults is stealing from another is being dishonest and has an agenda.
- prolikewh0a 8y ago>If I decide to write a book and I self publish, having paid for all my tools.... and still get a profit at the end after selling a million copies.... then who is exploited? Where is the theft? There was no exploitation and there was no theft. The boss is not the customer and I'm not entirely sure how you have come to this conclusion. >But would we say that the delivery person is suddennly entitled to additional retained earnings (profits) all of a sudden? The worker did not participate in any work creating the book, or writing it. The worker however is entitled to profits from the delivery services. >Anyone that will tell you that 2 or more consenting, voluntarily engaged adults is stealing from another is being dishonest and has an agenda. This is very dishonest itself. There is nothing voluntary for a lot of people. Work, or be homeless and maybe end up dead, this is the reality for many Americans.
- ghosterrific 8y ago>This is very dishonest itself. There is nothing voluntary for a lot of people. Work, or be homeless and maybe end up dead, this is the reality for many Americans. I'm not promising to take from others by force. I'm perfectly happy working for myself and not employing workers. However I do choose to hire people that are offering their services (making me, the "boss" the service providers', customer) so that I can help others earn a stable wage.... because I also want to earn more to protect myself and family. I also spend my profits helping people via charity and community projects. It's not moral from some guy or girl to take from me at gun point or threat of being put into a cage because they think they can allocate my earnings to Their causes... instead of the ones in my community that I'm working so hard to help. Onve again, look at who is pointing guns and sending people to prison in the name of "what is moral". 1 wrong and 1 right does not equal morally good.