2 ms·
Yes, it's true, the effectiveness of placebos has to do with belief. It's the person's belief that cures them (has to be, there is only sugar in the pill.) Yo
by carapace 8y ago
Yes, it's true, the effectiveness of placebos has to do with belief. It's the person's belief that cures them (has to be, there is only sugar in the pill.)
You can actually tell someone in a "medically authoritative and confident" way that something is a placebo and that it might work because it's true. The drug studies prove that over and over again. If you said, "This is just a sugar pill so it can't possibly help you." that would be a lie. It doesn't matter what you call it: "Placebo" or "Cure-a-tin Oxynonsense" or whatever. Those fake pills are going to cure some of the people, some of the time. The content of the story doesn't matter, only the sincere belief that the "magic" pill can work.
Anyway, these studies are double-blind. The person administering the pills doesn't know if they're real or placebo.
I have to say, I think it's pretty ridiculous that we don't spend more time and energy trying to scientifically study the placebo effect, aka the incredible healing power of belief. It's been shown to work on almost everything-- sometimes for some people.
Nearly every disease, syndrome, condition, etc. has been cured one or more times, in a medically scientifically recorded case, by "medicine" that has no medicinal value. I've even heard about a case of placebo knee surgery. The common factor in all these cases seems to be that the person involved believed they were going to heal.
Back in the 70's a couple of guys were going to sell placebo pills. The bottle came with a booklet that listed the percentage effectiveness for all sorts of ailments as established by medical tests! If the pills have a low effectiveness for your particular illness, well, you just take more... The FDA was not amused.