10 ms·
I wonder why they can’t integrate some service like VirusTotal into their downloader. Sure, for heretofore new objects it’ll take longer, but they have a long
by mc32 8y ago
I wonder why they can’t integrate some service like VirusTotal into their downloader. Sure, for heretofore new objects it’ll take longer, but they have a long list of many many file hashes and their reputation dB .
- chmod775 8y agoBecause I don't want Firefox to send what I download to some (third party) company. Or anywhere for that matter. Their (and chrome's) current solution to block malware domains use a client-side bloom filter afaik. If you'd try to build the same client-side into firefox, you'd have just built another (bad) antivirus software. Might as well integrate clamav into firefox then.
- mc32 8y agoCan’t they just compare hashes and for those where they have to do a scan, serve as an anonymous intermediary/proxy?
- GlitchMr 8y agoPerhaps similarly to Pwned Passwords API, except for files: https://www.troyhunt.com/ive-just-launched-pwned-passwords-version-2/ https://www.troyhunt.com/ive-just-launched-pwned-passwords-v...
- laumars 8y agoThere are quite a few reasons I can think of: * Privacy * Performance * They would likely have to work with Virus Total to support their infrastructure as I can only imagine how quickly they'd take such a cloud service offline if everyone started using it by default * And then what happens if / when the cloud service does have an outage? Does that mean people are blocked from downloading things? * Same question for people on a corporate network who might have Virus Total blocked * Same question for people on poorer internet connections as now the user has to transfer twice as much data if it's not a hash already stored on Virus Total. That all said, its a cool idea for a third party browser add-on (if it hasn't already been done?)
- mc32 8y agoThose are good things to think about, but I'll give them a stab: _Privacy: They [FF] can act as anonymous proxy. _Perf: Yes, for new objects, but for known objects, it should be minimal. _Service outage: Build a system which can allow an override (download at your own peril, while service is out) _Corp should already have enterprisey systems in place _New, unknown object: Yes an issue. As someone else said [GlitchMr], if they can do it ala haveibeenpowned I think it's worth looking into.
- gruez 8y agocue the inevitable "Firefox is leaking every file you downloaded!"