6 ms·
"Some legal experts, like Ryan Rodenberg, an associate professor of sports law at Florida State University, believe that, as with musical recordings and other c
by jonbaer 8y ago
"Some legal experts, like Ryan Rodenberg, an associate professor of sports law at Florida State University, believe that, as with musical recordings and other copyrighted material, courts will find that real-time sports data is owned by those who produce it: the leagues and their players.
Others dismiss that view. Marc Edelman, a professor of law at Baruch College, said he believed that only "pre-scripted" events were subject to copyright — meaning that while professional wrestling performances might qualify, football, basketball and other true competitions would not."
- rusk 8y agoYes, it seems like quite a departure from what copyright has been applied to so far ... I wonder what unforeseen and far-reaching consequences could emerge from pivoting the whole canon of copyright law to ringfence the value in such a niche area.
- whatshisface 8y agoMaybe people could start claiming copyright over their personal history. If I start running around in artistically meaningful patterns, can I claim that all of the people who track my location and sell it are infringing? I could start a game of Calvinball and be protected until it finished.
- GuB-42 8y agoYou probably signed a contract somewhere allowing location trackers to use your data. Buried somewhere in the terms of service.
- chollida1 8y agoWell the closest analogy that I know of is market data from stock exchanges. this seems close to sports data, in that its not "pre-scripted" and the company that runs the markets owns that data and sells it, in alot of cases its one of the larger sources of revenue. I can't see how the stock exchange can own that data but the sports leagues can't own the data about their leagues. Though as someone who used to do sports betting I wish this was the case:) In the sports analogy the market participants are the same as sports fans watching the game. They get to see the plays unfold (market data) but have to pay for that "privilege". In that case even if you are a participant of the stock exchange you still need to pay for the market data and historical data. Sports leagues could piggy back off this I guess. Seems like a stretch tome but I'll bet some league tries this.
- CamTin 8y agoThe stock exchange is literally the only party which even has the order flow data, whereas sporting events happen in arenas where thousands of people witness them. I wouldn't think a stock exchange could sue me for publishing order flow that I was personally party to, since that would seem draconian, but maybe I'm wrong. Likewise, I don't see how somebody can sue me for recording the fact that I saw Altuve go 2 for 3 with a homer and a single the other day. Again, maybe I'm wrong. Intellectual property doesn't really make much inherent sense, since it's all arbitrary and socially constructed, so lawyers and judges can often come to what ordinary people would think of as bonkers conclusions.
- rusk 8y agoThe stock exchange gather, arrange and publish the data and that's what's copyrighted* , not the actually event itself. If you were to be able to access and compile the data independently you could publish it and claim copyright. This is similar to how the guys in the article are being ejected from the stadia ... because they're controlling access to the source data. * I am not a lawyer.
- paulie_a 8y agoYou never need the disclaimer that you are not a lawyer.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- arcanus 8y agoSurely ancillary data I can glean from watching sports broadcasts is open? For example, if I use convolutional neural networks to parse broadcast video and derive statistics from that data, how could I not own that information?
- sqrt17 8y agobroadcast video is delayed by 10 seconds. Apparently, that's enough to make the non-delayed stream extra valuable.
- rusk 8y agoAs it stands, I believe you own copyright for that data. You've gathered it, composed it and published it. That's what's copyrighted. Somebody else could independently gather that data, produce alternative, even identical results and their work would be copyright. I am not a lawyer but that's how I understand it.
- ncallaway 8y agoThis is how other factual data copyrights tend to work (such as maps and phone books). It's not a copyright violation to collect and share the same information. It _is_ a copyright violation to simply copy and republish the data from a given source. So how can a map-maker tell that someone copied them instead of collecting their own information? They insert watermarks in the form of inaccurate data (such as inserting a small city that doesn't actually exist). See: https://www.google.com/amp/s/gizmodo.com/the-fake-places-that-only-exist-to-catch-copycat-cartog-1695414770/amp https://www.google.com/amp/s/gizmodo.com/the-fake-places-tha... and https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fictitious_entry https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fictitious_entry. I wonder what kind of fictious entry you could inject into sports data that wouldn't compromise the quality of the data too severely?
- rusk 8y agoWell there's also watermarking for images too right? The idea is that you embed a subtle pattern to the data which only becomes apparent when you apply a particular filter. This apparently operates in such a way as not to compromise the visible image so presumably sports data could be jimmied similarly.
- sandworm101 8y agoThey are wrong, or at least they are right only in an extremely narrow context. The data, as recorded, is subject to copyright. But the facts behind that data is not. The league can copyright it's realtime news feed, which includes things like scores. But those scores are not copyrightable alone. People watching the game are allowed to tell other people the score. Now if the game is truly rigged (ie pro wrestling) then the "score" is part of a prewritten script. That's different. But even there, fair use is a thing. One cannot stop someone from paraphrasing the plot of a script, such as in a review. So while experts like Rodenberg may be correct, they are correct in such a narrow way that it doesn't matter.
- rayiner 8y agoI don't think either would fall under copyright. As to the first, the Second Circuit has held (in a widely cited case) that NBA game data is not subject to copyright: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Basketball_Ass%27n_v._Motorola,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Basketball_Ass%27n_v..... The guiding rule, under the Supreme Court's Feist case, is that facts cannot be protected. What happened at an NBA game is a fact; the fact itself cannot be copyrighted. Only an expression of that fact (an article or radio segment reporting on it) can be protected.
- learnstats2 8y agoToday I learned that you don't have a "database right" in the US.
- eric_h 8y ago> NBA game data is not subject to copyright That is pretty fascinating. In horse racing (where paying for past performance information has been standard operating procedure for more than a century), there is (at least in the US) exactly one company that holds and brokers that information, and it is quite a profitable business. It's interesting that they theoretically can't claim copyright to protect that business.
- SimonPStevens 8y agoThis sounds like it would be a similar situation to that of maps. The fact of what physical geography exists cannot be copyrighted. Anyone is free to produce their own map by measuring the physical world. In theory if everyone used accurate measurements, then all maps would be identical. However a map itself can be copyrighted, and producing your own map by copying another for which you don't have permission is illegal. But how would anyone ever know whether you went out and measured the real world, or just copied someone's map because the underlying data is the same. Historical horse racing data is the same. You could start gathering all the data by recording the outcome of races, and in 10 years you would have 10 years of historical data. Or you could just pretend you have already done that and actually just copy the data from the other company. The result would be indistinguishable. 'Trap steets' is one way the mapping industry deals with this problem - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trap_street https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trap_street - So I would not be surprised to find some deliberate mistakes in the past performance data provided by this company, which should they be found in your data set, would be pretty conclusive evidence of the source of your data. "What colour are your bits" is also relevant and interesting article - http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 - Despite what techies would like to believe, the source of your data does matter, even if multiple different sources would actually result in an identical block of data.
- gautamnarula 8y agoThere has been a similar debate in professional chess as well. Grandmaster Evegny Sveshnikov has spoken out about game scores--the sheets of moves made in a game that the players write during the game--being the IP of the players. His arguments haven't really caught on, and so far high level chess games have essentially been in the public domain as soon as they're played.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Retra 8y agoFunny, I was just complaining about how I find pro baseball dull because they play with such skill and training that it basically is scripted. And on the other hand, I've seen documentaries about serendipitous happenings making movie scenes work. So it would seem that perhaps sports is theater and film-making is luck. Maybe Marc Edelman thinks we've got this copyright thing all backwards.