8 ms·
The Higgs boson: the hunt, the discovery, the study and some future perspectives
- saagarjha 8y ago> By the end of 2011, ATLAS had collected and analysed 5 fb^-1 of data at a centre-of-mass energy of 7 TeV I'm assuming that the unit being discussed here is inverse femtobarns–but I don't know what to make of this number. Is high? Low? "Good"?
- tobias2014 8y agoA decent perspective comparing to older colliders and an interpretation is given for example at Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barn_(unit)#Inverse_femtobarn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barn_(unit)#Inverse_femtobarn
- scottdupoy 8y agoThe femtobarn is a unit of area. The inverse femtobarn is basically saying the number of interactions "per femtobarn". A higher value means more interactions are occurring. When you fire a beam of particles at something, or another stream of particles then you usually want interactions to happen. Some particles miss, some interact and some are moving too past and fly right by. There is an optimum energy where the most particle interactions occur. If you plot out the interaction rates then you usually get a bell curve. This is known as the excitation function for that interaction.
- herodotus 8y agoMany billions of dollars spent, and no "new physics" seen or even hinted. Now they have to resort to spin.
- tobias2014 8y agoYou make it sound like there is money "lost". The dollars that are spent end up in the economy and go in the development of new materials and technologies that otherwise wouldn't have been developed. Whether there is a direct benefit to humanity of finding the fundamental laws of physics is another matter, but the way towards that has always been very fruitful.
- pasbesoin 8y agoE.g., enjoy your life-saving MRI? Thank research physicists. An often quoted figure, or range of figures, is that the U.S. space program has, per dollar invested, produced between 5 and 10 dollars of returns in commercial technology. I don't mean rockets and such. I mean things used in the everyday world around us. Oh, and a bit further afield from traditional physics, most of the novel drug discovery in the U.S. is developed with public dollars, not pharmaceutical dollars. Pharmaceutical companies convert (some) discoveries to commercial products, spending more money on later series trials and on marketing, than on any original research. And, many drugs were the results of "mistakes". Not what the researchers were targeting. You do research to learn novel things. If you already knew what your result would be, well... (I could jest, then you'd be a theoretician.) P.S. Let me also put it this way: You do research also to learn how to learn those things. Building new equipment, procedures, and understanding. And a lot of those pay off repeatedly, regardless of the particular result of the original research topic.
- wallace_f 8y ago>You make it sound like there is money "lost". The dollars that are spent end up in the economy This trickle down economics argument was used commonly in the Reagan era, and could be heard frequently in the 90s in conservative media. While it is correct that the money does not disappear (which in theory would generally just be a transfer of wealth too all money holders), the problem with the argumenr is that it is wilfully ignorant of the introductory economics lesson of 'guns vs butter,' as well as other lesons. Yes the money 'stays in the economy,' but what is it buying/producing? Someone just replied to me in another thread about the propensity to which Wall St bankers buy prostitutes and drugs. Leaders have bought us wars and domestic surveillance. An arguable reason to spend on basic science would have to do with money multipliers and a great reason would be return on technological investment, which you touched on. TL;DR good arguments exist for this spending, but probably not the trickle down economics one
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- eigenschwarz 8y agoThat's not how science works. Cf. Michelson-Morley.
- sohkamyung 8y agoYou are also discounting serendipitous advances that can happen due to the techniques and technology developed to find the Higgs boson. Here is one example: using the mathematical algorithms designed for the detectors for ATLAS and using it to recover the recordings stored on old wax cylinders. [1] [1] "LHC physicists preserve Native American voices" [ https://www.symmetrymagazine.org/article/june-2015/lhc-physicists-preserve-native-american-voices https://www.symmetrymagazine.org/article/june-2015/lhc-physi... ]
- raverbashing 8y agoYou are using the result of billions, if not trillions of dollars of "useless" research to write and publish this comment.
- BurnGpuBurn 8y ago> The significance is typically quoted as σ, or a number of standard deviations of the normal distribution. In particle physics, a significance of 3σ is referred to as evidence, while 5σ is referred to as an observation, corresponding to the probability of a statistical fluctuation from the background of less than 1 in a million. So, no one has ever observed the particle, and the "observation" is in actuality not an observation. Just a "less than one in a million" chance fluctuation from the background noise. Which doesn't sound very convincing to me if you need to run the experiment millions of times to produce the output.
- mnl 8y agoSo you don't know statistics nor how observations are made in particle physics... Do you think that we collect these things in a jar and make a picture? Of course you look for a signal on top of a background, after modelling it within a control region and then unblinding with data somewhere else, and of course you compare signal against a Monte Carlo simulation because there's no other way to do this. You're welcome to suggest 10,000 particle physicists your ideas about how to find particles with lifetimes of 10^-22 s and a production cross section of 57 pb. I don't understand what makes people that have never opened an actual book about this, nor stepped into a lab, entitled to think they know better than professionals working their asses out what they're talking about.
- BurnGpuBurn 8y agoWell, one of the problems, for instance, is that experiments like this are basically un-peer-reviewable. Who has the money to build another LHC? So it's hard for others to review the work done and thus, basically we all have to trust ONE team of scientists on this. But the particle scientists, in this for science and for them rather peculiar position, don't take proper care at all to explain their findings or their theories, which is obviously made harder with the absence of pictures from experiments like we used to have in particle physics. They just anounce "we've found the Higgs!", throw a party and ask everybody to believe them. The theories of particle physics are not really understandable unless you choose to study them very hard for a couple of years, and for sure the amount of theory needed to understand the experiments at LHC is staggering. I'm just a layman in this regard, and I will probably never understand the theories you guys do. So I'm not a scientist, but I am pretty well versed in politics, and I can tell you from a political view there's two options: you either found the Higgs or you didn't. If you did, you'd be very happy and publishing your results. If you didn't, you'd also be happily publishing results because for all 10,000 of you it'd be career suicide to admit that y'all just spent 15 billion euros to build a device that didn't give the expected results. The amount of anger and disdain displayed by scientists in this field towards anyone asking genuine questions is starting to look like other fields where "the science is settled".
- ThJ 8y agoI too enjoy bosoms. Who's Higgs? Oh! Bos... Never mind.