4 ms·
> When a child picks up their toys and puts them back where they belong, we say "thank you for being so helpful", or "thank you for being so neat". They’re jus
by paganel 8y ago
> When a child picks up their toys and puts them back where they belong, we say "thank you for being so helpful", or "thank you for being so neat".
They’re just kids, it’s ok to let them have their toys in disorder on the apartment’s floor, that’s what toys are for, for playing, “keeping things in order” defeats the whole purpose of “playing”. Granted, I don’t have kids, but when I was young my parents didn’t push me at “tidying things up” and I feel that was good for me, because I had more time to let my imagination run wild. For a young brain imagination and whatever it is that stands behind the idea of playing are more important than the domestication tendencies like forcing children to “keep things in order”.
- scottLobster 8y agoI was raised under a similar thought process, had zero chores in general among other "freedoms", my mom in particular cleaned up my every mess. It left me with vast problems regarding organization and discipline well past college, that I'm only really now getting over at age 30. Sure there is such a thing as oppressive amounts of structure, but rest assured my kids will have reasonable chores and a strong reinforcement of "when you're done with something, put it back where you found it". Imagination should be encouraged, but not at the the expense of execution. Good ideas are cheap, it's the ability to implement them that really makes a difference.
- Consultant32452 8y agoIn psychology, trait conscientiousness correlates strongly with success. To the extent conscientiousness might be taught and reinforced through ideas like you should put away toys you're not playing with anymore, perhaps it should be encouraged.
- mijamo 8y agoI don't think any serious psychological study would correlate anything with something as abstract and undegined as "success". Is there a way to win at life?
- dnissley 8y agoThey're using "success" as a shorthand for positive life outcomes -- high level of education, high income, health, longevity, etc.
- mhluongo 8y agoI was certain you didn't have kids before I hit the second sentence. Imaginative play is important. But developmental psych suggests that a certain amount of order is necessary for later ability to focus and reason later. And honestly, if we didn't ask our toddler to clean up his toys we wouldn't have a living room :P
- jdietrich 8y agoIn the words of the great Burrell Smith, make a mess, clean it up. Japanese schoolchildren are expected to clean their classroom after lunch. It's a part of the curriculum, probably borrowed from the training rules of Zen monasteries. Japanese educators believe that it teaches cooperation and responsibility. It's a habit that sticks, as we have seen at the World Cup. IMO, kids aren't terribly different to adults in their attitudes to work. They thrive when they're trusted with real responsibility and wither into cynicism and demotivation if they're kept busy with bullshit make-work. They'll live up to whatever is expected of them, for better and for worse. https://www.japantimes.co.jp/life/2001/11/30/lifestyle/kids-get-down-to-classroom-clean-ups-2/ https://www.japantimes.co.jp/life/2001/11/30/lifestyle/kids-... https://www.si.com/extra-mustard/2018/07/03/tuesday-hot-clicks-japan-world-cup-locker-room-fans-clean-stadium-belgium-loss-photos https://www.si.com/extra-mustard/2018/07/03/tuesday-hot-clic...