16 ms·
Mastodon WTF timeline (2017)
- rrobukef 8y agoBut what is the actual difference between the two? Is the second more extreme? Is one drawn and the other real? Or is the second drawn but based on real models ( like the fine)? Is it the difference between nude and naked? Pixiv is generally drawn but there are no examples of the other. The book Lolita is ok in europe, a bit weird but not banned. There is even nude art of children - though it is controverial.
- jarfil 8y agoAs far as I'm aware, lolicon is about fantasy, while child porn is about sex with children. The difference is not so much whether it's drawn or not, but whether it actually harms any real children.
- lucideer 8y agoThe refusal of the author to describe the difference between the two (while expending so many words to emphasise that they are different) is a bit odd. Especially as Lolicon is a relatively well-known term in the English-speaking world, and is even derived from an English-language/Russian-American-written/French-published book. It sounds like the author would like to use stronger, more direct words but is skirting the issue to avoid apparent bias (though the bias is really quite apparent) and ends up sounding vague throughout.
- tomtimtall 8y agoThe author does an absolutely great job of describing the actual subject which is the devision and different perspective. This is not an article about the difference and if he went into any sort of detail it would only deraile from the actual point of the article which is that there are two different perspectives on the same thing and that the people involved in general do not understand the other side.
- lucideer 8y agoThat's certainly the author's thesis: binary division, lumping a spectrum of opinion into two diametric extremes. It's a popular narrative and rarely, if ever, representative. It would be much easier to assess how true it is in this case if there were any insight given into the issues themselves.
- Freak_NL 8y ago> The book Lolita is ok in europe, a bit weird but not banned. I don't think people even consider it weird, as most people haven't read it. People who do read the book tend to be predisposed towards appreciating literature as an accepted vehicle for exploring ideas and thoughts that would be condemned in real life — including all kinds of murder, sex, drugs, illicit liaisons, and assorted forms of destructive behaviour. Incidentally, it is for sale in every decent bookshop that has an English literature section; Penguin publishes it in their modern classics line.
- claudiawerner 8y agoTo be specific, "Lolicon" is a Japanese word that's partly a loanword from "Lolita" in English; in the way the author is using it, it means "drawn or simulated representations of fictional children engaged in sexual activity", though in common Japanese parlence the word literally means "pedophile". The author has decided to say that lolicon is "child pornography" and this itself is a matter of debate; some authors (such as Young, in "Resolving the Gamer's Dilemma") consider child pornography to be synonymous with abuse, and hence "virtual pedophila" (as he calls it) does not fall under it. The "other thing" is literally just child pornography through and through, photographs or videos of real children engaged in sexual activity. The fact that the author has neglected to specifically state the difference is strange, and I honestly can't think of a good reason for doing this, or why it was left in Japanese script. Furthermore, there's something else here; a while ago I read an article which claimed that 81% of the Japanese public based on an extrapolated study would be fine with lolicon being made illegal. So how does the author say that lolicon being acceptable is a mainstream view? The author writes too, >The idea that ロリコン is bad in the same way 児童ポルノ is bad, or even that there could be a meaningful category including both ロリコン and 児童ポルノ as if they were somehow comparable, is incomprehensible from the mainstream Japanese point of view. Does this make me an honorary holder of the Japanese point of view? I honestly can't see a way in which drawings and real life photos in this case are comparable at all, it's incomprehensible to me how one could lump them together other than by the subject matter they represent, which is extremely broad and ignores the whole point of the classification - that is, one necessitates child abuse to be created, and the other doesn't. I very much align with the Japanese point of view here. On the other things the author mentioned, I agree with another commenter in saying that it's not at at all useful to frame this as "red" and "blue"; I consider myself rather "blue" on some issues (being a socialist) but the liberal idea of free speech is one I hold very dear to myself, and I am vehemently opposed to laws that target any kind of expression, even if that does entail "lolicon"; I believe the harm principle can stand here on its own, though I'm not sure if I'd bend even if it was proven conclusively (how?) that lolicon "causes" people to molest real children.
- Freak_NL 8y ago> […] "Lolicon" is a Japanese word that's partly a loanword from "Lolita" in English; […] Etymologically, it is a Japanese portmanteau derived from 'lolita complex', which is waseigo (Japanese words comprised of English words) meaning someone attracted to, or an attraction to, prepubescent girls (not boys, so it is not completely analogous to paedophile). > So how does the author say that lolicon being acceptable is a mainstream view? He seems to extrapolate from the acceptance of it in (large) online Japanese communities.
- thepumpkin1979 8y ago(2017)
- kennywinker 8y agoI really don’t think describing two sides of the “culture war” as red and blue is healthy for anyone. Most people have a mish-mash of beliefs, but lumping people together creates division and solidifies factions, rather than allowing people to be swayed or make up their own mind.
- loggedinmyphone 8y agoThe "culture war" isn't about beliefs; it's about satisfying the human need to blame (scapegoat) someone else for your problems, meanwhile not becoming the target of blame yourself (or at least, being blamed by anyone you care about). The solution that's been devised is to designate two groups to mutually scapegoat each other.
- RobertRoberts 8y agoI tend to agree fully with your assessment of the labels, but is it a coincidence that people's behavior online during these kinds of situations are divided already? And the labels aren't creating the divide, but only describing it? I've found on both sides of an argument about a person's behavior (ie, depraved, evil, despicable, etc...) was ignored when the arguer discovered that person shared their "groups" view point. I think (in my experience) it's extremely rare that people don't pick a side, and generalities do have uses in communication. Unless you think only one side uses labels to create two sides? Where the other side is innocent of this behavior? (a silly question)
- flukus 8y ago> I tend to agree fully with your assessment of the labels, but is it a coincidence that people's behavior online during these kinds of situations are divided already? And the labels aren't creating the divide, but only describing it? Yes they're divided already but not nearly as neatly as red/blue. Being that unnecessarily divisive (and I've been just as guilty as anyone) pushes people further apart, even people that agree on a lot more than they realise. On the flip side, when you agree with someone simplifying like that it just pulls your bubble tighter and tighter, you can lose perspective on how the other side really feels, which is usually much less extreme than the built up charicature.
- BadassFractal 8y agoMoral psychology is fun. Lolicon is one of those odd moral black holes for westerners. Jonathan Haidt in his book The Righteous Mind talks about a bunch of similar examples of victimless but "immoral" actions that we find wrong and will desperately try to find a victim for when one doesn't exist. Similar examples: incest with 100% guarantee of no conception. Consensual cannibalism (edit for clarity: of someone very well cooked). Eating of a dead dog. Sex with a dead chicken and then its consumption. We find all of those repugnant, immoral, and will try to come up with victims, even when there are none to be found. It's a good example of how morality for humans is much more than just about harm. It's about conformity and cohesion with a set of rules that identify a specific tribe, regardless of harm.
- azeirah 8y agoI understand your point, but I feel like I should point out that consensual cannibalism does have a victim, the cannibal. Humans eating human meat (and likewise, cows eating cow-meat, pigs eating pig-meat) can cause some very very weird and very serious and very rare illnesses. (social?) Animals have not evolved to eat their kind, or perhaps put differently; animals have evolved _not_ to eat their kind.
- BadassFractal 8y agoSure. But let's say it's fully sterilized and fully cooked so you have 100% guarantee of not getting sick from it. Is it still wrong? It's similar to the objection you hear about incest: "Yeah but what if the woman gets pregnant", thus you set the conditions that there is 100% no chance of conception. And actually, our closest relatives, the chimps, have evolved wonderfully to eat their own kind. In fact they find each other delicious during constant raids on the enemy's territory.
- lucideer 8y ago> let's say it's fully sterilized and fully cooked so you have 100% guarantee of not getting sick from it. I'm being a pedant here, and this isn't really relevant to the previous commenters point, but worth noting that one of the known dangers of cannibalism (CJD) is less related to typical sterilisation and not quite as well understood in general, so 100% guarantees are hard to come by.
- mark_edward 8y agoSounds like a bunch of pedophiles trying to justify the spread of pedophiles propaganda by appealing to identity politics about oppressed Japanese speakers who live pedophile "art"
- geoah 8y agoThat is the whole point of this "war". People not being able to understand or accept a culture and having to reduce it to something they can grasp or argue about.
- mark_edward 8y agoI'm sorry I'm not able to understand the artistic and cultural intricacies of drawings of tentacle monsters raping toddlers.
- vertexFarm 8y agoNo, the whole point of portraying it as a "culture war" of intolerance is to obfuscate and legitimize what it's really about. There's a reason he's so vague about what he's talking about and uses Japanese characters to spell out western words--to inhibit people from working out opinions for themselves. And mainstream Japanese culture does not share his opinions at all. It's obviously trying to push an agenda from an unassailable position of false neutrality. This is just NAMBLA with a fake veneer of noble eastern mysticism. Trying to conflate disagreement with cultural intolerance in order to game the debate is the message.
- AJRF 8y agoLabelling the sides as Red versus Blue is convenient (as in; people know what you mean) but boy is it damaging to simplify like this. It's not the authors fault at all, he's simply using the nomenclature of the time, but it makes me sad to see how polarized we've all become. Ultimately I think the labels act as a screen that people use to bucket people in, and if you ain't in my bucket, I ain't going to listen. Which just perpetuates the polarization.
- RobertRoberts 8y ago>...but boy is it damaging to simplify like this. Do you think that giving a particular group a color will affect the reader's thoughts about a subject? I think it's possible for many people who don't deeply consider a view point, but can those people really be helped then? And if they can't, what difference does it matter what people say or how they say it?
- loggedinmyphone 8y agoWhen people adopt a behavior, no matter how damaging, it's because they get something out of it. What might people be getting out of such a polarized worldview? Maybe they'd rather ally themselves with half the world, and be the enemy of the other half, instead of feeling vaguely indifferent about everyone.
- gdulli 8y agoThe author is hilariously non-self-aware about their own bubble-inhabitance. It starts out with a tone of ostensible I'm-above-this-so-I-can-analyze-it-objectively but doesn't take long to devolve into: > Some of this alliance was expressed overtly, for instance by creating an "advisory board" to guide Twitter culture and staffing it with some of the most hateful of Blue leaders > "shadowbanning" persons identified as Red by AI systems > But there were also many on the Blue side angry that the Red side still had not been completely annihilated
- throwaway37585 8y agoAre those statements wrong?
- scarejunba 8y agoOkay, I think I get it. ロリコン - artificial images representing children or child like people in a sexual context, either drawn or rendered with software 児童ポルノ - photos of actual kids in sexual contexts These online storms in teacups are rarely worth it, but this one is actually quite interesting.
- bscphil 8y agoI believe that's right. Which makes the author's point of view rather odd - in that they are obviously mistaken to think that Westerners don't see a difference between the two, or don't think that 児童ポルノ is worse than ロリコン. (Of course we do.) It's also rather funny that the author uses the word "nerd" to describe people who consume this stuff, because it clearly doesn't fit the ordinary use of the term. No one is denying (I think) that the appeal is a sexual one. Even assuming the interest is above board, we'd never label a fetishist a nerd. So it's (I think ) extremely misleading to describe them that way. I also don't think the Red vs. Blue framing made much sense. For one thing it's not clear at all how the .jp instances are related to the "Red" servers. There's an actual question to be answered about whether ロリコン is morally wrong and if so, a harm that should be prosecuted. If reason that ロリコン is appealing is fundamentally the same as 児童ポルノ (i.e. that there are children portrayed), it seems like the moral case against it is very clear. I don't know enough to say whether that's the case. On the other hand there might be more societal harm from banning it than allowing it. At any rate it's not hard to see why one might be troubled by it, and so I'm suspicious of the author's claim that it's accepted without controversy in Japan.
- myanonaccount 8y agoNote: perspective from non-Japanese observer. And unfortunately has to be posted from an pseudonymous account. "it's accepted without controversy in Japan." While not completely true as an absolute, this is close enough to the truth to be a fair statement. Even some 児童ポルノ wasn't illegal in Japan fairly recently. And like the other Japanese censorship laws, was brought in as much due to a desire to align with Western pressure and laws as due to any moral sense. (I'm not trying to diminish the second aspect here; I'm saying that both were strong pressures to create the law). Remember that Japanese morals are much more Confucian than Christian. Breaking a law is immoral in Japan in and of itself because laws exist to create harmony and breaking harmony is immoral. So the fact that 児童ポルノ is illegal, and ロリコン is not forms a large part of the opinion of whether it is immoral or not. Also remember that the Western hatred of pedophilia and child porn is partially Puritanism. We've successfully thrown off the Puritan yoke, but that part of our culture was deeply rooted, so rather than disappearing, some of it has transferred over to perversions that it's still acceptable to demonize, namely pedophilia. And I think the Confucians have it right on this one. Pedophilia and child pornography is one of those things that needs to be banned and made illegal for social harmony reasons, and practicers of softer forms of it like ロリコン should be marginalized. Different from, but mostly compatible with the somewhat commonly held opinion that pedophiles are "sick, not necessarily evil".
- kevingadd 8y agoThis is an interesting saga I didn't hear anything about when it was happening. I recall seeing that Pixiv had launched an instance, but I'm honestly shocked that it took off like it did. It makes sense that it was appealing to artists in part due to a more lax policy regarding sensitive images. The author would've done themselves a significant favor by not wasting a bunch of space on an attempt to neutrally and imprecisely classify 'red' and 'blue' groups before dispensing with the neutrality halfway through. The neutrality wasn't especially helpful in the first place, but his "free speech" and "safe speech" labels later on are (from my interpretation of everything he describes in the series of events) both clearer and more neutral than any attempt to group sides together as 'SJWs' or 'aGG' or 'MRAs' or whatever because it describes the general point of view underlying their behavior. It may not describe those groups as entire individuals but it seems to accurately classify most of the split here - people seeking mastodon instances that are a Safe Environment (hence the incredible threat posed by federated instances not honoring privacy settings) vs people seeking mastodon instances that are moderation-light and rules-light where they can do whatever they like. The legal threat posed to server operators by caching is an interesting side angle that puts the operators in a nasty spot. It sucks that issues with fair treatment of French and Japanese speakers on Mastodon have to get sidelined by getting pulled into right-vs-left US culture wars - what Japanese artists choose to post on social media really shouldn't have anything to do with how Americans feel about concentration camps or no-platforming. In a sense, even this attempt to depict the way Japanese users were impacted by this whole saga falls flat because it centers the western parties ('red' and 'blue') in the story despite the fact that the Japanese users featured in it outnumber them. On a final note, it's interesting to see Twitter described as Blue here, as at the present time Twitter's company leadership is actively and openly courting the right wing in business meetings and online discussions (including "alt-right" leaders), presumably for business reasons but perhaps for others. I guess the political winds shift quickly.
- akavel 8y agoHe notes later in the article, that at some point in more distant past the "free speech" and "safe speech" claims were used in reverse by the Blue and Red "factions": "However, I think it's significant that when we had the same fight on Livejournal ten years earlier, it was the opposite way: fictional "child pornography" in the form of explicit Harry Potter fan art and therefore "free speech" was a Blue/Left/aGG/SJW thing, with the Red/Right/Gamergate/MRA side taking what we'd now call the "safe speech" position. For that reason I'm inclined to think that the link between Culture War sides and free/safe speech is more a matter of historical accident than anything naturally flowing from whatever defines these sides." Interestingly, I remember reading somewhere some time ago (I think on some kind of "rationality" website, but not 100% sure, and probably via HN; but maybe actually in a paper book), that particular concrete views associated with some distinct political "sides"/"factions" (like "rightist vs. leftist") are often surprisingly accidental and "just" of random historical origin. Though usually explained as "rationally/logically founded on basic principles [of the faction]", in reality it seems to often be rather kind of "we say so because we say so". Unfortunately I cannot recall particular concrete examples from the article, I only remember the general idea, as it was quite shocking and surprising to me, as you can see it left a lasting impression. However, in case of the OP story, the "safe speech" vs. "free speech" swap seems a nice example of such mechanism.
- evernon 8y agoThis does explain why platforms like Facebook and Google have arrived at the sad inevitability of filter bubbling.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- aquova 8y agoI found this article to be interesting, but framed in a very strange way. The author continuously promotes that there is a left-right "war", and while several of their examples seems to definitely imply a political spectrum split like that, most of the issues they're recounting come from a cultural divide. This basically boils down to English/Western vs Japanese/Eastern cultural differences, but with political opinions pulled into the mix. Their choice to not even define the two types of content is telling as well: by simply defining it, they know the Western audience of their article won't want anything to do with it. It's an interesting story, but framed in a strange way with key details left out to fit the red-blue narrative, in my opinion. Some, I would assume more Eastern-oriented users, would argue that they are being censored for content that is perfectly acceptable in their culture. Others, primarily Western audiences, would argue that it isn't culturally acceptable here, and that this is what Mastodon was designed for, to choose who you wish to include in your Federation. I don't really know which side I agree with personally, both seem to have their merits, but it's an interesting situation, one of several I've heard whispers of from Mastodon.
- icebraining 8y agoI'm an outsider to the whole story, but I read the article as detailing two different clashes, the blue/red and the English/Japanese, though partly intertwined.
- moomin 8y agoWow, this is a classic case of "don't trust someone who describes themselves as neutral". To take the principal example under discussion, either you think lolicon is OK or you don't. "Neutrality" is actually the former position. The exact same thing holds true for the "Red vs Blue" thing. Either you believe Red harasses Blue or you don't. If you don't, fine, but don't pretend you didn't just pick a side. "the mouse will not appreciate your neutrality"
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoI never thought of neutrality like that - thanks, +1 Insightful and such! Although I wonder if that can be applied to other issues too. Like, if I were to have no opinion / consider myself neutral in the pro-choice / pro-life debate, which side would I actually be on? Or is there a neutral / indifferent ground there?
- moomin 8y agoThe quote at the bottom is from Desmond Tutu, who explicitly said that neutrality is a vote for the powerful/status quo. So if you were in Denmark, not caring that much could be treated as a pro-choice position, but in Texas it would be the other way around.
- jtbayly 8y agoWrong. Not caring anywhere in the USA would also be pro-choice since Roe v Wade overturned laws in all 50 states against abortion.
- mabbo 8y agoSetting aside the author's clear but oblivious bias in the English speakers "war", he documents a fascinating problem: how do we globally integrate societies that have very starkly different reactions to specific topics, ideas, etc? We aren't even good at answering these questions within the same culture (liberty vs discrimination, public safety vs 2nd amendment, 'Red' vs 'Blue', and so on). Given the internet's existence, the lowering barriers to trade, immigration, and travel, Pandora's box isn't going to be closed here- we need to figure out how to approach the topic of cross-cultural disagreement on moral quandaries. And it's not fair to just say "Our culture is right and theirs is wrong". That just demeans them and silences the minority. My favorite example: I go to a small men's barber shop usually staffed by two or three male barbers. A woman enters saying "I want a man's haircut". All three barbers are devout Muslims who cannot touch a woman, by their religious beliefs. Yet the customer has a right to be served even though she is female. This isn't hypothetical, it really happened. They sorted it out amicably, but this sure could have gone to court- where a decision would probably be made that makes a lot of people angry. In the case of "ロリコン and 児童ポルノ", can Western culture even perceive that a difference might exist? Or are we bound by laws that grew out of our cultural view that the two are both the same horrible concept?
- Forge36 8y agoI think the line is sightly fussier in the United States. https://www.justice.gov/criminal-ceos/citizens-guide-us-federal-law-child-pornography https://www.justice.gov/criminal-ceos/citizens-guide-us-fede... >Visual depictions include photographs, videos, digital or computer generated images indistinguishable from an actual minor, and images created, adapted, or modified, but appear to depict an identifiable, actual minor I am not a lawyer, but given that language it gives the impression that even art may fall under the scope of U.S. law. Am I correct? Possibly not, however that ambiguity will cause many to avoid crossing the implied law to ensure they don't break the actual law.
- throwaway37585 8y agoIANAL, does the term “actual minor” here refer to depicting a specific real-world person, or to “realism”?
- dielan 8y agoThis is actually a really interesting perspective on Japanese fediverse. The article lacks nuance when talking about the "red" and "blue" sides. Seems like false dichotomy to me.
- konart 8y ago>Twitter that would be free of "harassment," which is a Blue code word for the mere existence of the Red side Sums up greatly.
- iaml 8y agoAuthor could have sidestepped the whole political mess (considering it's tangential to the whole post) by calling sides "tumblr" and "4chan".
- ohtwenty 8y agoWhich is just a proxy for left/blue vs right/red, and since their post is on twitter --> mastodon that would be a really weird way to talk about it?
- iaml 8y agoBlue/red thing is mostly american politics, while I'd argue that tumblr vs 4chan is mostly abstracted from politics and more about world views and has lesser of a chance of hurting ego, which I believe would lead to more productive discussion. I know it's just semantics, but a lot of people are very emotionally invested in those colored labels.