5 ms·
I seriously think about if it would be better if there were federal law, or even a constitutional amendment, which prohibited any city or state anywhere in the
by crazygringo 8y ago
I seriously think about if it would be better if there were federal law, or even a constitutional amendment, which prohibited any city or state anywhere in the US from giving favorable treatment (tax or otherwise) to any business, sports team, stadium, or anything else.
All it produces a race to the bottom where businesses win and people lose. And it distorts the free market into an uneven playing field, creating situations which are a win to individual business but where the change/move is a net loss for the economy overall.
I don't understand why this isn't more of a hot-button issue. Everyone should care about this.
- defertoreptar 8y ago>All it produces a race to the bottom where businesses win and people lose. If only businesses win, then why do cities want the business to come to them in the first place?
- caust1c 8y agoThere are some small economic kickbacks for local economies, but realistically I would guess that it's probably small-scale bribery. That or local governments are just really bad at math. Do they really think a business starting in their community is going to give back more than the billions in breaks they're giving?
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoRemember government is really just a collection of individuals. You can't discount the basic human motivations in things like this. Competing is fun, competing and winning is much more fun. Getting a big company/sport/etc to sign on to your city means you beat everybody else they were negotiating with, and those were all big players. That's a big win. It also helps build your legacy. The guy who brings "The SportsTeamers" to a city is going to be remembered for exactly that, not the net economic effect. And yeah that does no doubt open the door to 'consulting positions' after leaving office though I do not think that's a primary driver in the deals, just icing.
- defertoreptar 8y agoIt depends on how many billions, how many jobs, how much tax revenue, how much projected population growth and average wage growth and how the local economy will respond to that growth, etc.
- LeftTurnSignal 8y agoWisconsin is going to find out: http://money.cnn.com/2018/06/28/technology/foxconn-wisconsin-plant/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2018/06/28/technology/foxconn-wisconsin...
- opportune 8y agoWhy do poor people work for low wages?
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 8y agoVery basic game theory. Let's say there's 10 arbitrary 'units' of positive externalities, i.e. economic activity in a region, that comes from HQ coming to town. If no subsidies/tax-breaks/etc. are allowed, then those 10 units go to some town, chosen by some other merit. The 'people' win with 10. If those 10 units are large in proportion to the marginal advantage a town has for selection (i.e. workforce availability, business fundamentals like logistics, etc.), then it's obvious what competing towns do: they offer up a slice of those 10 units. If town A offers 1 (keeping 9), town B can just offer 2, etc. So it's a race to the bottom, where nearly all the positive externalities are passed to the business in a bid to capture whatever remains. Even if you give up 9, it's worth it to have 1 vs. 0. This kind of competitive behavior is fundamental to markets, and is the reason why price is so very often right at the 'pain point' for buyers and sellers. The remaining question is whether those positive externalities (the jobs and economic activity a business can bring to a region) are rightly held by the people or by the business.
- defertoreptar 8y agoCompetition lowers the price, but once the price becomes lower than the "profit point," let's say, then people generally don't agree to the deal. I'm not seeing where you show that people are making a deal against their interests.
- sf_rob 8y agoI wish I could remember the details, but one of the articles I read about this went a step further and suggested when the sell side is limited (a single company moving to a region like Amazon) and the benefits are hard to estimate (community utility) then the best bid will inevitably be deriving negative utility due to over-bidding. In your example, one city might bid 11 because they wanted to beat 9 and estimated the total utility at 13, not knowing it would be 10.
- AmericanChopper 8y agoThe nature of these deals themselves is not one sided. They’re supposed to create more jobs, more local consumer spending, which means more tax collected and more revenue. The body making the concessions can very well come out ahead, and an everybody-wins outcome can be reached. Theoretically the deal could also be so one sided that only one side wins. But that really comes down to the specifics.
- hibikir 8y agoIn a world with no tax incentives, the determining factor for a large company is access to potential workforce. Therefore companies will move to places where other large successful companies are already, because ultimately you want to recruit from them. This creates a few really big winners, and a lot of losers. In practice, even metro areas with a couple million people are not desirable enough, and lose population. There are many cities that will be willing to offer more just to avoid depopulation. Midwestern metro areas are not going to be happy if there was a federal law that, for all intents and purposes, guaranteed that they were going to shrink, shrivel and eventually die. They have the right to fight for their community's existence with economic means: The "best" you could get is, instead of the government doing it, a private consortium of businesspeople doing the same thing with their own pockets, producing the same effect. The one difference only comes when you start from the dubious position that all government actions distort, while a trade association's never do. Would the economy overall be better if San Francisco had 10 times its current population and we all moved there? In the short term, probably yes, but imagine what even larger differences in state population would do to politics.
- crazygringo 8y agoThere are myriad factors which affect the success of a company -- they're not reducible only to tax incentives and size of workforce. Big metro areas tend to have very expensive workforces, and plenty of companies intentionally set up shop outside of them in order to gain a competitive advantage through cheaper labor, services, rent, etc. No more tax incentives aren't going to cause metro areas to die. It just means companies won't be able to shop around for an artifically low price. They'll still wind up somewhere that isn't SF, but it won't be at the cost of local schools and pensions.
- vuln 8y agoRight then after the state falls into bankruptcy the federal government will have to bail it out or FANNG will snatch it up. Welcome to the state of Google.