3 ms·
The evidence for it is that there are people poorer than middle-class, with no access to capital or loans, and they manage to survive. If somebody middle-class
by nostrademons 8y ago
The evidence for it is that there are people poorer than middle-class, with no access to capital or loans, and they manage to survive. If somebody middle-class or above wants to get out of debt or accumulate savings, all they have to do is live like someone who's poor while continuing to earn like somebody who's middle-class, and bank the difference.
While I think the OP's point was a bit of an oversimplification, for the vast, vast majority of people this strategy actually does work. If you live like you're poor but earn like you're middle class, you will get out of debt. The people who remain in debt - again, assuming a middle class or higher salary - are those whose self-image requires a lifestyle where they can tell themselves they're not poor.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- prolikewh0a 8y agoRichest country in the world, people need to live as if they're poor to pay back the $6000 of debt they have from needing stitches and an x-ray at the hospital. Do you understand what you're saying?
- hueving 8y agoMiddle class usually has healthcare of some sort. I don't think you understand what you're talking about. To be clear, I completely agree that there is a class of people in the US that lives like that, but it's not the middle that is bringing in $70-80k a household from jobs with benefits.
- prolikewh0a 8y agoSure, I have health insurance and work Corporate IT for a Fortune 500. I'm lower middle class. Lets run through the numbers here. I pay $140/month for insurance, have a $1500 deductible, $500 ER visit, and $3000 maximum out of pocket. A hospital trip for me could cost $5000, which would absolutely devastate me even though I have no debt, and have some savings. This is standard for friends who work at other companies with similar jobs, too, including in other states. The middle class does not have healthcare, they have essentially 'Catastrophic' coverage and an illusion that they are covered for anything else.
- hueving 8y agoPut 5k in an HSA. If you're lower middle, you should be able to achieve this in a year (remember it's pretax). If you can't make it work, you are either wasting money somewhere significant (e.g. housing costing more than 25% of your income), or you aren't lower middle class for the area you live.