4 ms·
> In many ways Trump's aggressive trade practices may be the only answer to this if Trump focused on China. That's circular, US "aggressive trade practices" (w
by ajross 8y ago
> In many ways Trump's aggressive trade practices may be the only answer to this if Trump focused on China.
That's circular, US "aggressive trade practices" (which means unilateral tarrifs, let's not spin, please) came first, so making them "the only answer" is sort of self-fulfilling.
Frankly it's much more likely that Chinese trade shenanigans like this are the result of the escalating trade war. The volatile climate makes "big steps" like enjoining a whole foreign company more attractive as the relative threat of retaliation is less. If you think your opponent is going to pull the trigger, you shoot first.
Now we just have to wait for more, ahem, "aggressive trade practices" to be announced by the White House, and we'll escalate further.
This is what a trade war looks like, folks.
- ethicsengineer 8y agoAre you saying that Trump's aggressive trade policy is the reason why China is stealing American IP?
- ajross 8y agoI genuinely thought I'd been pretty clear, so that question seems like you're trying an unhelpful "gotcha" instead of reading what I wrote. I'm saying that Trump's "aggressive trade policy" (senseless surprise tarrifs) was the impetus for this particular action (senseless surprise import ban). Absent that, the IP theft would have continued quietly (as it always has, everywhere) and the destabilizing trade war wouldn't be happening. You seem to be taking an absolutist perspective: IP theft[1] must not ever be tolerated and any action to prevent it, however destabilizing, must be taken. And that's how you get trade wars (real wars too, FWIW). This was a nice modern economy we had while it lasted. [1] I mean, come on. It's ?!@#! DRAM and flash. There are a half dozen manufacturers all over the world making exactly this same junk. It's not like sudden "Chinese" threat to Micron was going to introduce competition in any way that Samsung and Fujitsu were not already providing. Please.
- defen 8y ago> There are a half dozen manufacturers all over the world making exactly this same junk. Not in the densities required for modern uses.
- patfla 8y ago> half a dozen No, the market has concentrated and is very largely dominated by just 3 companies: Samsung and SK Hynix in Korea and Micron. I don't think China has a whole lot of choice as regards memory chips in the volumes that they need. And getting new supply up and running is a yrs long process.
- nostromo 8y ago> US "aggressive trade practices" (which means unilateral tarrifs, let's not spin, please) came first This just isn't true. China has not played fairly against the US in modern history. Putting aside problems like currency manipulation, intellectual property theft, and putting up barriers for foreign companies, they also haven't played fair with regards to tariffs. Take Elon Musk's word for it if you don't believe me: "an American car going to China pays 25% import duty, but a Chinese car coming to the US only pays 2.5%, a tenfold difference" https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/08/elon-musk-sides-with-trump-on-trade-with-china-citing-25-percent-import-duty-on-american-cars.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/08/elon-musk-sides-with-trump-o...
- monocasa 8y agoNo one plays fair in international trade. I mean, we've literally installed dictators in countries to get better trade consideration. And recently thanks to Snowden, we know that the NSA hacked AirBus to give Boeing an edge, and appears to believe that the "economic security" of the US is a component of their SIGINT domain. I'm not really sure why we expect others to "play fair".
- coliveira 8y agoThis makes it sound like the US was just a small country mislead by powerful China. In fact every agreement between Chinese and American companies was signed because of it was beneficial to both sides. It was the US that allowed American companies to setup shop in China and transfer their technology for what it looked like a good deal. Now the US wants to recant on its decades old policy as if this was a big surprise.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]