4 ms·
>> 5mph would take nearly 1000' to bring to an "emergency" stop. That seems far fetched. 1000' is a long way at 5mph. The number of engines doesn't matter.
by sandworm101 8y ago
>> 5mph would take nearly 1000' to bring to an "emergency" stop.
That seems far fetched. 1000' is a long way at 5mph. The number of engines doesn't matter. Each car has its own brakes in an emergency. Cut pressure in the line and every car will brake itself. Perhaps they meant situations involving hills, not uncommon for ore trains heading from mines.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bigjimmyk3 8y agoA train's emergency braking system is somewhat sacrificial (using it can damage engines, cars, etc.) so you're probably correct. I'd say that in either case, most people who are not "train people" will dramatically underestimate the required stopping distance. The mass of a fully loaded train is surprisingly large.
- code_duck 8y agoCar drivers tend to underestimate the amount of space it takes for a semi to stop. Heck, every time I load up my car or attach a trailer, it takes time to become accustomed to the decreased braking performance. Drivers likely could not give an accurate estimation for how many feet it takes to do anything on the road, such as come to a stop in an SUV going 50. Given the extreme mass of a cargo train, I wouldn't be surprised if the distance figures sounded high.
- cup-of-tea 8y agoCar drivers underestimate the amount of space it takes a car to stop.
- grkvlt 8y ago> how many feet it takes to do anything on the road, such as come to a stop in an SUV going 50 Isn't knowledge of stopping distances for vehicles at various speeds and different road surface conditions a requirement for obtaining a driving license? (At least, in the UK I believe it is, and I think the Highway Code tables probably over-estimate these distances for safety purposes)
- gsnedders 8y agoThe Highway Code tables are based on an average family car in the 1960s (IIRC) when the tables were first introduced. They're ridiculously long distances for modern cars, though AIUI the "thinking time" part is nowadays thought to be too low.
- grkvlt 8y agoStill, that's not a bad thing, per se. If we underestimate based on a vaguely remembered overestimated value from the highway code based on 1960s cars, then the effects cancel out and we're basically correct for modern vehicles?
- gsnedders 8y agoI /think/ I recall seeing something that claimed with longer reaction times it actually ended up worse overall. That said, I think often the bigger problem is people not realising especially in more unusual conditions (like snow in much of Britain) quite how much longer braking distances become.
- code_duck 8y agoYes, but I don't think it requires or correlates to real understanding of what the distances are. I doubt that people understand how it varies with speed, or what that number of feet really looks like on the road. The process I have experienced is I read what a theoretical distance is in the booklet the state gave me for the exam, and then select their indicated answer on a multiple-choice test.
- Rodd45 8y agoThis is true. A buddy of mine works for the engine and brake systems of trains. I was helping him install the new skid plates and bumper he ordered from 4WheelOnline for his Jeep when he mentions the critical points and headaches of maintaining the brake system of trains.
- kposehn 8y agoA 30,000 ton ore train in Brazil will take about that long to stop, due to the nature of that weight strung out over 2.5 miles of distance. That said, I think an emergency stop (air loss) would stop it faster.
- ythn 8y ago> A 30,000 ton ore train in Brazil will take about that long to stop, due to the nature of that weight strung out over 2.5 miles of distance. I once learned in a physics class that weight has nothing to do with the stopping distance, but rather the steel on steel friction coefficient.
- LoSboccacc 8y agoWeight and ground pressure cancel each other out in the friction equation. The issue is where all that heat goes. Heated brakes will fade, glaze, fail, break, burn or a combination of the above, so there are limits on how much braking force you can apply to wheels
- marvin 8y agoThere are lots of assumptions in that entry-level physics exercise, for instance that all the energy can be dissipated without destroying anything (that the brakes are able to utilize the full friction available) and also that the entire weight of the vehicle rests on top of the wheels performing the braking.
- kposehn 8y agoExcellent point - it’s the rolling resistance indeed. I pointed out the size for reference (easier than saying 480,000 lbs rolling resistance :)
- donarb 8y agoYou don't want to lock up the wheels in an emergency. Locked wheels will skid on the rails, creating flat spots on the wheel. Later, if not repaired, the rotating wheel can hammer the rail at the flat spot, causing the rail to break.
- DC-3 8y agoIt's an emergency. Who cares about flatspotted wheels? Parts can be replaced.
- userbinator 8y agoIf you slip the wheels it will take longer to come to a stop. Sliding friction is always lower than static friction.
- DC-3 8y agoI agree, but the optimal achievable situation might be to be on the edge of locking wheels like ABS. Anyway, my point was that damaging the wheels is not the issue at hand.
- adrianN 8y agoIt takes a while until the brakes in the last car start braking because the pressure doesn't drop everywhere simultaneously.
- 21 8y agoWhy not also use an electric cable? Sounds like a problem, since the first car will have to "resist" the rest of the train.
- sandworm101 8y agoElectricity wouldn't scale. Solenoids on each brake system would take current. Adding new cars would increase the load on whatever is providing that current. To ensure that cars could be swapped in and out, the cables on all cars would have to be large enough to provide current for even the longest train. Air brakes, once pressurized, don't take much to maintain. Relatively small pipes work on even very long trains. You can add cars all day without increasing the steady load on the compressor. A longer train will take longer to pressurize, but once there it would not need the compressor to run constantly. Air is also not as dangerous as running large electrical cables the length of a train.
- 21 8y agoI meant electricity just for the triggering, not for the action. A small electric signal could for example open a valve in the air tube. Thus all cars would break at the same time.
- extrapickles 8y agoSome trains already to this, where they put in electronic valves in the air lines for in car. Basically, the electronic valve controls if the existing brake is vented or connected to the central air line. This still allows for the fail-safe behavior of being able to brake the train from the central air line by venting it. This lets them start easier/quicker from a stop, as they don't have to re-air the entire train and less wear on the brakes of the trains in the front of the train as all the cars start braking at the same time. This is particularly useful for trains that have to start on a hill as taking minutes for your brakes to fully turn off can complicate things.
- Symbiote 8y ago"Shortly after 08:00 hrs on 8 November 2010, a passenger train running from London Charing Cross to Hastings failed to stop at Stonegate station in East Sussex. The train ran for a further 2.45 miles (3.94 km) with the emergency brake applied, passing the level crossing at Crowhurst Bridge before coming to a stop 3.22 miles (5.18 km) after first applying the brakes." There's a whole sequence of events behind this, from the work to remove slippery leaves from rails, to the sand applied during braking if wheels are slipping, to the IT systems and management processes identifying why the train didn't have any sand. It's a fascinating 151 page report. https://www.gov.uk/raib-reports/station-overrun-incident-at-stonegate-east-sussex https://www.gov.uk/raib-reports/station-overrun-incident-at-... (PDF report linked at the bottom).
- sandworm101 8y agoIt was going far faster than 5mph. 5mph is little more than walking pace.
- Symbiote 8y agoTrue, but the last part of the graph shows what I think is fairly normal braking from 24mph to 0. Counting pixels, the distance covered from 10mph to zero is about 350 feet. With this distance for a lightly loaded passenger train, 1000 feet doesn't seem impossible or even unreasonable for a heavy freight train at 5mph.