6 ms·
I got a chance to drive a couple of different engines at the Plumas rail museum. And one of the things that does is help you internalize the amazing amount of m
by ChuckMcM 8y ago
I got a chance to drive a couple of different engines at the Plumas rail museum. And one of the things that does is help you internalize the amazing amount of mass and momentum a train carries around all the time. The engineer who was with us spoke of freight trains that were a hundred cars of iron ore that, even though they were travelling at only 5mph would take nearly 1000' to bring to an "emergency" stop. While I don't know how true that is, just driving around the engine gave me some insight into how far ahead in time the engineer has to be thinking if they are operating a full train.
- dredmorbius 8y agoMy experience is largely with bicycles (you're very aware of the energy input/output), automobiles, and boats, but thinking of moving vehicles as momentum systems, to which energy can be added or removed, is useful. On a bike, you maintain a steady speed by matching drag losses with the energy you're putting into the pedals. Braking and other actions cost you energy you've put in. For automobiles and trucks, added mass has a significant change to momentum, and I feel that. Boats, from a row or sailboat to a 30m+ power vessel, have their momentum, drag, and interaction with water, waves, currents, and wind. Trains are a whole 'nother ballgame.
- kqr 8y ago> On a bike, you maintain a steady speed by matching drag losses with the energy you're putting into the pedals. Braking and other actions cost you energy you've put in. As does the frequent mistake of putting weight on the rear pedal. Realising this made me understand how little energy it really takes to keep a bicycle going, given the correct gear.
- HumanDrivenDev 8y agoAs does the frequent mistake of putting weight on the rear pedal. I don't follow. What do you mean here?
- abcanthur 8y agoI think he means making sure to actively bring your rear leg forward while pedaling, so that your downstroke doesn't have to push against the weight of your rear leg too.
- btilly 8y agoOn a bike, you maintain a steady speed by matching drag losses with the energy you're putting into the pedals. Braking and other actions cost you energy you've put in. Which is exactly why bicycles are so fond of rolling through stop signs. When you're riding one, it is obvious to you that going from 20 mph down to 10, then back up to 20 is reasonably safe and only takes half the effort as going from 20 mph down to 0 and then back up to 20.
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoIt takes 3/4 of the effort - kinetic energy is proportional to the square of speed.
- hexane360 8y agoNot to mention that a person pedaling from a standstill has a lot less power output than a person pedaling an already moving bike.
- dredmorbius 8y agoNot really, and highly dependant on gearing.
- hexane360 8y agoYes really. I'm sure you know power is velocity * force. For a long range, force output is pretty constant for humans, so power output must be lower: http://users.frii.com/katana/biketext.html http://users.frii.com/katana/biketext.html
- Theodores 8y agoNothing is redundant on a bike, if anything it is the other way around, e.g. the brakes are the wheels, the frame is the suspension, the gear mechanisms are also there to keep the chain on, the passenger is the power source. Nothing can be taken away. Bikes also pioneer high tech lightweight materials, only recently have 'bicycle grade' aluminium and carbon fibre been used on those boxy car things. It is a whole different world of 'body on frame' engineering. I sometimes wonder what a train would look like if it was designed from the ground up by a bicycle designer with a Lotus engineer - 'add lightness'. Some modern 'Tesla truck' tech could be thrown in too. Imagine having half the amount of wheels, all of them actively powered and actively steered so no screeching on corners. The seats could be 'bus stop grade' and the monocoque being some extruded tube with the hand rails and luggage racks being structural elements, like a rally car roll cage. The idea of Brunel's wide gauge was to have the wheels at the side of the train rather than have the train sit above the tracks. Imagine if you had independent suspension and stepped a metre down into the train for some super low centre of gravity. Or if that extra space below the train was a massive parcel area so goods were shifted on/off trains with some standard pallets that just slotted in, aircraft style. Think how much traffic could be shifted off the roads particularly if you ran the trains in mixed freight mode through the night. Rollercoaster style tracks, particularly in tube lines could be used to slow down trains at stations and speed them up afterwards. As for the doors, these could be integrated into the compartment ends, so rather than there being the normal interconnect between compartments the doors would slide back/fore to keep the train enclosed on corners without the usual rubbery bendy bit needed. Add airbags and seatbelts, windows that open, a bit of wifi and you could have comfort and actual passenger safety.
- sandworm101 8y ago>> 5mph would take nearly 1000' to bring to an "emergency" stop. That seems far fetched. 1000' is a long way at 5mph. The number of engines doesn't matter. Each car has its own brakes in an emergency. Cut pressure in the line and every car will brake itself. Perhaps they meant situations involving hills, not uncommon for ore trains heading from mines.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bigjimmyk3 8y agoA train's emergency braking system is somewhat sacrificial (using it can damage engines, cars, etc.) so you're probably correct. I'd say that in either case, most people who are not "train people" will dramatically underestimate the required stopping distance. The mass of a fully loaded train is surprisingly large.
- code_duck 8y agoCar drivers tend to underestimate the amount of space it takes for a semi to stop. Heck, every time I load up my car or attach a trailer, it takes time to become accustomed to the decreased braking performance. Drivers likely could not give an accurate estimation for how many feet it takes to do anything on the road, such as come to a stop in an SUV going 50. Given the extreme mass of a cargo train, I wouldn't be surprised if the distance figures sounded high.
- cup-of-tea 8y agoCar drivers underestimate the amount of space it takes a car to stop.
- grkvlt 8y ago> how many feet it takes to do anything on the road, such as come to a stop in an SUV going 50 Isn't knowledge of stopping distances for vehicles at various speeds and different road surface conditions a requirement for obtaining a driving license? (At least, in the UK I believe it is, and I think the Highway Code tables probably over-estimate these distances for safety purposes)